i have something to ask. what is the different between staff warmage and sword+shield warmage. the ability of sword+shield war mage counted as melee attacks or magic attacks? if i use staff it will be counted as magic for sure. if i use sword+shield, melee rating would have an effect for my attacks or no? thanks i hope someone will answer this
war mages difference- Staff vs Sword
Melee is completely useless on a mage. Don't invest in it. Everything except maybe punching (which only happens on the KFS raid) is Magic.
CarlosDanger wrote:Melee is completely useless on a mage. Don't invest in it. Everything except maybe punching (which only happens on the KFS raid) is Magic.so melee rating has no effect to warmages even they use sword or even a staff? okaay
Most of wm use sword and shield to pvp because the staff decrease too much the haste. Even if staff is really more powerful than sword, the différence of haste is really too big.
And with shield u CAN block some attack!! Once u begin to block, u are going to be addictive to block!
And with shield u CAN block some attack!! Once u begin to block, u are going to be addictive to block!
Ceka wrote:Most of wm use sword and shield to pvp because the staff decrease too much the haste. Even if staff is really more powerful than sword, the différence of haste is really too big.well, thats not the point what i'm asking actually-.-
And with shield u CAN block some attack!! Once u begin to block, u are going to be addictive to block!
HI ChainJail,
So I think I know what you are getting at:
The following study was very anecdotal and done awhile back but here is what I noticed:
The 2H staff is magic damage so it is influenced by magic damage bonus/gems etc.
When using basic attack: It made a difference if you had magic gems installed or not. So it is definitely influenced by magic gems.
When using a spell such as Ice storm: the damage was also definitely influeneced by magic gems.
When using a 1H weapon:
The basic attack seems unresponsive to magic gems, meaning there was not a significant increase or decrease in damage with the basic attack if I played with gems.
Ice storm: saw some moderate increase in damage trends as I added magic gems.
Theory:
2H staff take advantage of magic gem damage bonus for any attacks including the basic attack.
1H weapons: are melee weapons, so when you cast a spell, you get magic damage bonus, but if a mage executes a 1H basic attack...only melee gems, which no mage ever equips, would help.
So in the basic 1H attack, the mage gets shafted.
This is an preliminary theory and remains to be rigorously proven, but it is what I suspect at the moment.
Someone smarter than me may have studied this more thoroughly...
So I think I know what you are getting at:
The following study was very anecdotal and done awhile back but here is what I noticed:
The 2H staff is magic damage so it is influenced by magic damage bonus/gems etc.
When using basic attack: It made a difference if you had magic gems installed or not. So it is definitely influenced by magic gems.
When using a spell such as Ice storm: the damage was also definitely influeneced by magic gems.
When using a 1H weapon:
The basic attack seems unresponsive to magic gems, meaning there was not a significant increase or decrease in damage with the basic attack if I played with gems.
Ice storm: saw some moderate increase in damage trends as I added magic gems.
Theory:
2H staff take advantage of magic gem damage bonus for any attacks including the basic attack.
1H weapons: are melee weapons, so when you cast a spell, you get magic damage bonus, but if a mage executes a 1H basic attack...only melee gems, which no mage ever equips, would help.
So in the basic 1H attack, the mage gets shafted.
This is an preliminary theory and remains to be rigorously proven, but it is what I suspect at the moment.
Someone smarter than me may have studied this more thoroughly...
Subject
Staff Attack, Basic Attack, 100% Weapon Damage
Staff Attack is a Physical Magic Attack that can be Spell Dodged for 50% Damage:
All non-Staff weapons are a Physical Melee Attack that can be Dodged for 0% Damage:
Class Abilities use Base Weapon Damage to calculate damage, but you must check the Abilities description to decide if Melee or Magic:
Staff Attack, Basic Attack, 100% Weapon Damage
ChainJail_TheAteaM wrote:
if i use staff it will be counted as magic for sure. if i use sword+shield, melee rating would have an effect for my attacks or no?
Staff Attack is a Physical Magic Attack that can be Spell Dodged for 50% Damage:
Dave wrote:
The War Mage's default attack when wielding a staff uses your spell rating rather than melee rating to calculate damage, even though it does physical damage.
Hero token has no effect- Melee Tome & Staff - RESOLVED
All non-Staff weapons are a Physical Melee Attack that can be Dodged for 0% Damage:
Little_Mike wrote:As Dave said, Staves do not use the Melee rating to compute its damage, but rather Magic rating. However, Swords will use the Melee rating.
Hero token has no effect- Melee Tome & Staff - RESOLVED
Class Abilities use Base Weapon Damage to calculate damage, but you must check the Abilities description to decide if Melee or Magic:
Bj_Knows wrote:
The formula for 100% Weapon Damage, or Base Weapon Damage:
100% Weapon Damage =
Main Hand Weapon Damage ( shown on weapon) + Offhand Weapon Damage ( shown on offhand weapon) + [ Bonus Damage ( shown on Stat page) * Weapon Speed ( shown on weapon ) ] + Appropriate Enchants
Bonus Damage is Melee Bonus Damage for Melee Attacks. Bonus Damage is Magic Bonus Damage for Magic Attacks.
Choosing a Weapon
beekeo wrote:Smite and Radiant Light are noted as "Spirit Attacks" which implies Magic instead of Melee.
By the same note: Nature is Magic for Shadow Walkers and Fire and Ice are Magic for Mages.
All attack abilities use the Weapon Damage rating as the base statistic for calculating damage output.
Skills and abilities damage display- Magic? Melee?