Suggestion One: Guild Favors are considerable, so there may not be a need to add to the list of nine Guild Favors- although it may be a novel idea to do so. Alternatively, I would like to inquire about the possibility of allowing 7-10 Guild Loyalty Levels, instead of the five we currently have. Guilders new and old, Mighty and not-so Mighty, get so excited when they "earn another star." Earning Loyalty Levels also provides the entire Guild with a good amount of motivation for Toons to be successful Heroes and for Guilds to become more prestigious and powerful. Or perhaps additional Loyalty Levels could be the reward for reaching higher Guild Levels as opposed to adding more Guild Challenges.
Providing rewards for valiant efforts and hard work is often a successful method for assuring continued participation and teamwork. Since guilds survive only through participation and teamwork, giving guilds the proper tools to stimulate and reward members seems like a practical idea.
Suggestion Two: Each Guild is unique in how it operates and regulates activity. Taking away autonomy from GMs is not the intent of the following idea. The intent is to assist GMs who have an active Guild or need a little more activity from their Guild members. As guild membership grows, it can become increasingly difficult to monitor the activity of each gamer. Some Guild members work incredibly hard while others just coast and reap the benefits of Guild Favors that they really did not earn.
Venan already decided on the existence of Recruit, Member, Veteran and Officer. Who has those ranks is entirely up to the GMs. I propose an "all-or-nothing" system here. Either allow GMs to create their own ranks to better accommodate the needs of their Guild, or Venan should provide criteria for meeting those ranks. An example of criteria for a rank could include an amount of time one belongs to a Guild, their Toon's Might level, and the amount of RPP earned in each Raid or a conglomerate of RPP earned from all Raid participation. If a set goal was determined, then each Player knows they must be an active member of their Guild in order to receive benefits from the Guild. This also allows for a fair system for every BoH gamer and every BoH GM.
Suggestion Three: GMs should have the ability to reward their Guild members who have demonstrated exemplary Loyalty and Leadership attributes. Perhaps we do not need a "barter system" or a way to "share" items between the Toons within an account. If GMs had the ability to provide rewards to Guild members by depositing items into the Members' accounts, then that may motivate guilders to work harder for the Guild. Instead of earning points for Leaderboard Scores, GMs can be rewarded with a special "bank" used to warehouse items won through Leaderboard scores or Venan Special Event challenges. Equipment, gs, potions, elixirs, gems, silver, etc, can be earned by the entire Guild or a few stellar performers from the previous week. A safeguard system or a check-and-balance method would need to be in place to assure the integrity of the GMs. A safeguard system could prevent the GM from taking all the loot, and a check-and-balance method could be as simple as information contained within an E-mail to the entire Guild of what the booty contained.
Suggestion Four: Guilders become friends. They enjoy chatting and joking with each other and Raiding alongside their peers. Guilds also develop rapport with Mercs. If Venan keeps the PvP Beta idea, will you please allow an option for gamers to choose who they battle in PvP? Maybe include a "Friend or Foe" challenge where Guild members can challenge each other (friend) or members of different guilds can challenge one another (Foe)? This may help strengthen bonds within a Guild and between guilds while earning currency. Perhaps include a weekly GM challenge where the loser must relinquish Power or Prestige points to the winner? A spectacular battle that BoH gamers can view?
Those are my four suggestions for the year. I am tapped out now.
Providing rewards for valiant efforts and hard work is often a successful method for assuring continued participation and teamwork. Since guilds survive only through participation and teamwork, giving guilds the proper tools to stimulate and reward members seems like a practical idea.
Suggestion Two: Each Guild is unique in how it operates and regulates activity. Taking away autonomy from GMs is not the intent of the following idea. The intent is to assist GMs who have an active Guild or need a little more activity from their Guild members. As guild membership grows, it can become increasingly difficult to monitor the activity of each gamer. Some Guild members work incredibly hard while others just coast and reap the benefits of Guild Favors that they really did not earn.
Venan already decided on the existence of Recruit, Member, Veteran and Officer. Who has those ranks is entirely up to the GMs. I propose an "all-or-nothing" system here. Either allow GMs to create their own ranks to better accommodate the needs of their Guild, or Venan should provide criteria for meeting those ranks. An example of criteria for a rank could include an amount of time one belongs to a Guild, their Toon's Might level, and the amount of RPP earned in each Raid or a conglomerate of RPP earned from all Raid participation. If a set goal was determined, then each Player knows they must be an active member of their Guild in order to receive benefits from the Guild. This also allows for a fair system for every BoH gamer and every BoH GM.
Suggestion Three: GMs should have the ability to reward their Guild members who have demonstrated exemplary Loyalty and Leadership attributes. Perhaps we do not need a "barter system" or a way to "share" items between the Toons within an account. If GMs had the ability to provide rewards to Guild members by depositing items into the Members' accounts, then that may motivate guilders to work harder for the Guild. Instead of earning points for Leaderboard Scores, GMs can be rewarded with a special "bank" used to warehouse items won through Leaderboard scores or Venan Special Event challenges. Equipment, gs, potions, elixirs, gems, silver, etc, can be earned by the entire Guild or a few stellar performers from the previous week. A safeguard system or a check-and-balance method would need to be in place to assure the integrity of the GMs. A safeguard system could prevent the GM from taking all the loot, and a check-and-balance method could be as simple as information contained within an E-mail to the entire Guild of what the booty contained.
Suggestion Four: Guilders become friends. They enjoy chatting and joking with each other and Raiding alongside their peers. Guilds also develop rapport with Mercs. If Venan keeps the PvP Beta idea, will you please allow an option for gamers to choose who they battle in PvP? Maybe include a "Friend or Foe" challenge where Guild members can challenge each other (friend) or members of different guilds can challenge one another (Foe)? This may help strengthen bonds within a Guild and between guilds while earning currency. Perhaps include a weekly GM challenge where the loser must relinquish Power or Prestige points to the winner? A spectacular battle that BoH gamers can view?
Those are my four suggestions for the year. I am tapped out now.