Subject
Guild Loyalty & Contests
Mithrid wrote:
BUT for a guild only type contest, the Guild would need to have a start selection option for the raid to be an "entry into the contest" and then the raid locks out mercs and any guild members with less then Level 3 loyalty or something like that.
The penalty for switching Guilds was changed from 50% to 10%. It is possible to switch Guild six times and still have Level 4 Perks.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
If you want a Guild only contest, you could add "X Days with Guild" to Guild Member List. Then you could award prizes for 1st Place and 1st Place with all members belonging to Guild for Y days. Ex: 1st Place including Mercs and new member then 1st Place with all members in Raid belonging to Guild for 7 days.
I like the switch penalty of 10% Guild Loyalty as it solves a lot of problems:
Leaving a Dead Guild or Loyalty when switching
Bj_Knows wrote:
The penalty for switching Guilds was changed from 50% to 10%. It is possible to switch Guild six times and still have Level 4 Perks.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
If you want a Guild only contest, you could add "X Days with Guild" to Guild Member List. Then you could award prizes for 1st Place and 1st Place with all members belonging to Guild for Y days. Ex: 1st Place including Mercs and new member then 1st Place with all members in Raid belonging to Guild for 7 days.
I like the switch penalty of 10% Guild Loyalty as it solves a lot of problems:
True BJ, with the change in Loyalty penalties for switching, a guild only contest would require a time constraint instead.
I was thinking about making the speed run ranking based on a metric of time and loyalty, similar to how raid power is calculated. Right now, if you let in mercs, they only contribute 50% of the power for their rpp as compared to rpp contributed by a member. Come up with a similar formula that makes a speed raid not just based on completion time, but on a power based formula that reduces points for members not at level 5 loyalty.
Keep a heavier penalty against loyalty for guild hoppers and this will keep guilds from recruiting top burners from other guilds who don't care about dropping their loyalty down to level 1 since they can get it back to 5 in a matter of days.
Another idea earlier mentioned "X number of days in a guild". With some of the super guilds having more than 100 members and many more alts who rotate in and out all day long, this might be a challenge, unless it was X number of days since joining the guild and not going to another guild. Furthermore, members who may have taken a break from the game might come back for speed runs, so being outside the guild recently would impact this in a negative manner.
Another thought that comes to mind is that the last speed run weekend, we had a bunch of noobs joining our guild hoping to be a part of a winning speed run. Of course, their loyalty was reduced. If we were to take a heavy penalty for letting them in the raid, I may want a temporary tool to keep anyone under lvl5 loyalty from participating in the raid. It is very hard to manage who comes and goes in a guild these days so most guilds have open doors all the time. We closed the doors for the speed raids to make sure our members got in before random people who heard we were running a speed raid.
I have no illusions that these changes might be easy, but if any part of this could be implemented, it would help keep speed runs more to the spirit of the event.
Oh, and I like the idea of opting a raid in to the challenge and having under lvl5 loyalty locked out as well. Multiple tiers of qualification would allow more people to have a chance to win something as well.
I really enjoyed the KFS speed run weekend! I say leave it unchanged - it was great to meet other guilds and BoH players I don't normally meet.
We get lots of guild competition each week for the leaderboards, its nice to have something a bit more open like this where we can work together.