Here are my thoughts on justicar post 2.0:
Before 2.0 justicar was stronger then sw and wm in general and this needed to be balanced, agreed. Although, what needs to be said as well is that against sw and wm if same might it was not evident that justi would win, just most times it did, meaning the differences were there but not very big. With the changes made to sw and wm post 2.0, the balance was already accomplished, there was no need to nerf the justicar from hero to zero. Heroic Will should have kept its 50 % cast time reduction, stagger should have kept its 75 % bonus damage on next attack. It was already not a consistent factor, attack needed to be blocked to get stagger and even then it did not proc every time. As a character with longest cast times justicar needed those abilities to be strong enough, even more now that wm and sw got stronger. The reason Venan gives that stagger was not intended for 1h imo is bs, because pvp IS 1h fighting for every class.
But the biggest issue i have with the incredible nerfing Venan did on justicar is that i worked on my justi for over a year to get it where it was, perfect for me and for pvp, and with one update Venan undid this. NEVER downgrade a players toon, ONLY upgrade! Like i said, when you guts at Venan would have left the justicar exactly as it was, the wanted better balance would have been achieved. I think even then wm and sw would have been stronger then justicars in the end, but now you just made us cannon fudder, in pvp AND pve. I will not spend any gs anymore untill this is fixed and if it is not fixed in like 2 weeks or so, i will say a defenite goodbye to BoH. So please get to your senses Venan and listen to your players.
And compliments to Beekeo, great art work!
Armada.
ps: Matues thinks exactly the same about this issue.
My experience is based on leveling in the arena. I had over 1k battles under my belt before I hit 30 on my WM. I remember it being extremely difficult to fight justicars at lower levels, prior to opening t4 moves like burst (short cast timer to counter seismic), time void, & ice shield. By moving burst up and adding some quicker timers at lower tiers, Venan fixed this issue IMHO.
Since hitting 30 and 20k might, I found backswing +stagger + vengeance 3 about as OP as fracture & snap cast now. But I think the overall nerf of justicars is unwarranted. I haven't lost to any since 2.0,* even a couple 10k higher might than me. The answer to balance isn't to lower other classes to the bottom, but rather to find some middle ground.
Kia
Edit: *Accept Ceka

Edit again: And Jingle

. Still blame the outfit tho

I beat u kia dont forget.... Haha btw my opinion:
To balance:
Nerf wm:
ice/fire fracture works but with no stack.
Snap cast must be like the old snap cast before 2.0 ( i use it before 2.0 and it was good).
I think i dont ask too much.
Justi buff:
Hw must me like old hw.
Juggernault need to lower cooldown 10-9-8 (lvl 1-2-3).
Thats it i dont need old stagger. I think i dont ask too much.
If venan dont want to nerf wm:
Buff justi: old stagger- old hw- lower cooldown of juggernaut+ remove all the debuff- old seismic- old brutal.
Buff sw: old ps.
Thats my opinion.
Ps: if guys say "cry cry cry" i have a wm i can kill all the guys and be the number 1 if i want. But i prefer when its balance. So be honnest urself guys before to say "cry" about the balance. Thx.
i honsetly dont care abt pvp but here is my opinion on PVE
PLEASE STOP TRYING TO BALANCE PVP this game is about PVE
a fully buff ,max T5 gem , Max T16 Gear is doing lesser hit in the P2 & 3 of the new Raid then a WM
In KFS a usual 20-25 kills fully buffed with speed and Melee Elixir is a walk in the park
Now even with full T16 gear , fully buff in KFS cant hit even 20 kills.
This is not a normal rant because i have a justi.
I have toon on all 3 class so i know what im talking about.
Spent ages writing my thoughts on this only to find I had been timed out of forum on my browser so all writing lost. Will try to restore some of it but will be in several posts so apologies for spam.
Firstly I think its right and possible to get abilities that work well and are balanced in PvP and PvE. I know not everyone likes PvP but its an important part of the game. I don't think they are too far off for Justi, just need some tweaks.
Here are my suggestions:
1) Reverse Heroic Will nerf. Both other characters slow Justi down so having one chance every 10 secs to land a faster blow isn't unreasonable. Saves say 0.3 secs on Brutal Strike so certainly not overpowered compared to Smoke bomb which gives 1sec knockback with no way to avoid.
2) Stagger: I understand intentions here but it has been nerfed too much I think. When I used this in PvP opponents just defend and then do a slow action and avoid it altogether. At best will reduce damage by 45% in one action chosen by opponent. Old Stagger used with Brutal Strike did 75% * 160% = 120% extra damage and did extra bleed damage as well.
My suggestion would be to change Stagger to a knockback for 0.1/0.2/0.3 secs (depending on level) after a successful block. Much more like the concept of a Stagger after being blocked. No icons needed, very simple, opponent just waits for a short time after the blocked action. 0.3 secs is kind of equivalent to half a Brutal Strike so equivalent to about 80% damage saved very approximately - feels about right. Works in PvE as well (although watch out for Sedalb fo Ecnirp when he has immunity to knockback!)
3) Condemn: this action feels far too slow to me. Wound is 0.75*haste and applies bleed which lasts longer and gives DoT. Wrath times out more quickly so Condemn should be 0.5*haste like Radiant light or Stunning Blow. Damage should be similar to RL/SB depending on level. At the moment level 2/3 of Condemn are useless as they just reduce cd slightly, probably a bug.
4) Heavenly Wave: like the idea of this, but disappointing in practice. Removing 1 debuff from a stack of 2 or 3 doesn't help much. Level 2/3 of this doesn't have much effect at the mo, suggest they also allow you to remove 2/3 debuffs from a single stack, so at least a whole stack of debuffs can be removed. Its not going to be OP in PvP as opponent has plenty of warning, its a slow action. Also I think cooldown for this is too long - its not a game changer like Seismic Slash or Stun which need longer cooldowns.
Really like the suggestion to slightly reduce cooldown on Juggernaut for levels 2 and 3, Gives a bit more benefit to those higher levels like Heroic Will has.
Apart from that the actions feel about right to me. I agree with the changes to Brutal Strike and Seismic Slash - reducing knockbacks for them for 1H, and tying them to weapon speed (although see my Elder Fury bug report).
Hopefully something like the above can be implemented to get us Justis back into the PvP arena!

I beat u kia dont forget.... Haha btw my opinion:
To balance:
Nerf wm:
ice/fire fracture works but with no stack.
Snap cast must be like the old snap cast before 2.0 ( i use it before 2.0 and it was good).
I think i dont ask too much.
Justi buff:
Hw must me like old hw.
Juggernault need to lower cooldown 10-9-8 (lvl 1-2-3).
Thats it i dont need old stagger. I think i dont ask too much.
If venan dont want to nerf wm:
Buff justi: old stagger- old hw- lower cooldown of juggernaut+ remove all the debuff- old seismic- old brutal.
Buff sw: old ps.
Thats my opinion.
Ps: if guys say "cry cry cry" i have a wm i can kill all the guys and be the number 1 if i want. But i prefer when its balance. So be honnest urself guys before to say "cry" about the balance. Thx.
Well said Ceka. It's quite clear the pendulum has swung too far the other way and it should be fixed before too many abandon PvP entirely. A good case for a completely different set of abilities for PvE & PvP IMO, but that probably involves big changes so unlikely.