Book of Heroes

Bug, Elder Fury - RESOLVED

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed Jan 1, 2014 11:05 am
Subject
Bug, Elder Fury

Posted from my iPod

Bonus Damage Melee & Magic are based on Weapon Speed.

Staff Mastery speeds up attacks but uses 1.3 (Staffs original speed) to calculate damage.

Elder Fury speeds up attacks but uses new speed to calculate damage instead of weapon's original speed.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Jan 9, 2014 2:35 pm
Double checked Incinerate with and without Staff Mastery. Damage appears to be modified appropriately.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Jan 9, 2014 3:52 pm
Little_Mike wrote:Double checked Incinerate with and without Staff Mastery. Damage appears to be modified appropriately.

Sorry if my initial post was unclear.

War Mage's Staff Mastery is the control group to see if the bug is in that part of the algorithm. Staff Master and Incinerate works fine. This is most likely because *all* Staffs are speed 1.3, Staff Mastery only works with a Staff, so algorithm probably has 1.3 as a constant instead of a variable based on Weapon Equipped. Staff Master appears to modify the Weapon Speed for casting time, but leaves it unchanged for calculating Magic Bonus Damage.

Justicar's *Elder Fury* reduces damage each time you take a rank in it. Ex: Smite Rank 3 does less damage with Elder Fury rank 1 and continues to decrease with each additional rank you take in Elder Fury. Unlike Staff Mastery, Elder Fury works with Sword 1.3 Speed and Axe 1.4 Speed. Since each rank of Elder Fury reduces damage, it is likely a live calculation based on the Weapon Equipped. It appear to be modifying the Weapon Speed for both casting time and for calculating Melee and Magic Bonus Damage instead of leaving Bonus Damage unchanged. If this is as intended, Justicar Elder Fury should mention the reduced damage.

Little_Mike

Site AdminThu Jan 9, 2014 4:47 pm
No, the code for determining the melee/magic bonus is the same for all classes. It gets normalized against weapon speed. Staff Mastery and Elder Fury modifies the melee/magic bonus the same: if you get either ability, your damage will go down. We discussed this with the rest of the team and determined that this behavior is a bug. Your damage should not change with Staff Mastery and Elder Fury, so we will be fixing this in a future update. Thanks for your report.
Wow! Had no idea Elder Fury was reducing damage. Look forward to doing more damage after next update :-)
Phlip wrote:Wow! Had no idea Elder Fury was reducing damage. Look forward to doing more damage after next update :-)

I turfed it with in the first week or so because of that. :(
After seeing this I must ask. So if staff Mastery is affecting the wm damage does that mean the wm will hit harder after you fix this bug? I can't imagine wm hitting harder than it already does 0.0
EF has another negative impact on justi. Prior to update the brutal,wound,brutal made raiding quicker. EF doesn't compensate for cool down time, so there is an overlap. Without EF I have no overlap now, but it took til I got full t16, level 6 gems. Without EF!
Poppa wrote:EF has another negative impact on justi. Prior to update the brutal,wound,brutal made raiding quicker. EF doesn't compensate for cool down time, so there is an overlap. Without EF I have no overlap now, but it took til I got full t16, level 6 gems. Without EF!

Actually you should be able to take one level of EF and still do Brutal/Wound/Brutal if you wanted. Weapon speed 1.35 * 0.75 > 1s. Note number of haste gems is irrelevant to this.

Brutal/Cleave/Brutal/Smite/Brutal... Works without needing to worry about weapon speed though.