Book of Heroes

Re-thinking the entire Raid dynamic

This is a semi-radical re-think of the raid concept, intended to make it more intense, and more based on player skill and on character skill, instead of being a boring grind.

Instead of raid instances being separate events each costing 2 Energy and giving 1 battle against either a triplet of mobs or the raid boss, each raid instance should cost 8 energy, and give the player a certain amount of ingame time (not realtime/realworld time), such as 2 minutes (120 seconds, or 2400 game "ticks" of 0.05s each).

The player then has this much time to win as many fights as possible. In the initial phases he faces mob triplet as before, while in the last phase he faces the raid boss. Each fight won in those 2 minutes gives RPP (Raid Participation Points), so that the challenge lies in optimizing one's kill speed, killing the mobs and the bosses in as little time as possible.

With this different dynamic, I don't think RPP should escalate for long sequences. It should simply be a fixed amount of RPP per fight won, perhaps 20 or 25 RPP.

For added challenge, perhaps the mid-phases (for raids that have 3 or more phases) could disallow any use of healing potions during the 8E raid sequence, so that you can only heal between sequences. I'm not sure if that's a good idea, though. Healing potions should be available at least during some parts of raids, and certainly against the raid bosses. If healing potion is disallowed during mid-phase raiding then this has the effect of excluding player characters of marginal skill, that is ones who are only barely capable of killing the mobs. Such players would then be encouraged to be sure to log on to participate in the early raid phase(s), where they can use potions, and then do something offline in the mid phases, and come back on for the boss fights.

The cost per "unit" of 8 Energy is based on some consideration. A new player has 12 Energy, and so can buy one such "unit", and must then wait for Energy to recharge, since it takes 10 minutes of realtime to recharge 4 Energy, and presumably it will take less than 10 minutes of realtime to burn those 2 minutes of game world time.

But it is fairly doable to get a +2 Energy Sigil. Now the Energy max is 14, and so after paying 8 Energy for a raid "sequence", the player has 6 Energy left. After 5 minutes he has 8 Energy and can do a 2nd unit. It's quite possible he'll burn through his allotted inworld 2 minutes faster than 5 minutes, but not much faster (2400 ticks is a lot of fights - roughly 120 attacks assuming no Haste). Only after that is he barred from further play until his Energy recharges.

For players with more Sigils than just one +2 one, the analysis is less clear, but I think overall 8 Energy is an apt choice.

Also note that carefully that the 2 minutes I am talking about are not realtime as experienced by the player. I'm not asking for any twitch element to be added to the game. A central concept of BoH is that the player can always sit and think, taking as much time as he wants in order to make the best possible decision, and this proposed change of the raid mechanics does not change that in any way.
An interesting idea, and certainly one that addresses my main objection to the current system, which is, as you correctly noted, "a boring grind." Very well thought out - it makes character stats and player skill matter again. Which they don't, right now.

The only thing I'm a bit leery of is the ban on health potions in some phases; with the cooldown on potions already limiting their use thanks to your 2m system, it strikes me as unnecessary.

Also, I think the RPP bonus wouldn't have to be eliminated. But those are niggling details.

Kudos, and you'd get a second from me, if this were up for a vote! :)
Well, the ban on healing potions in the mid phases was a throwaway idea, to make raids more "hardcore". It is in no way intrinsic to my proposal.