Book of Heroes

Running a Sucessful Raid

Are you suffering from the same problem I have, fear? I am afraid to fail. Especially when my guild suffers when I fail. But I am human. I make mistakes. I fail. So I put together a primer on what I have learned about running raids. Not every guild will follow every item here, but this is my preferred method of running a raid.

What are the decisions and roles you need to run a successful raid:
1] Choose a raid – How many toons and mercs can you get? How many do you need? Ask for advice. If in doubt, start a smaller raid. Running a small successful raid is better than a large failure.

2] Announce the raid in guild chat - this gives ppl a chance to get ready. They might need to shop or be otherwise engaged. Give them a minute or two before you start the raid.

3] Open Merc slots – How many? Generally I will open raids with mercs unless we are doing a raid for a goal or to finish an objective. Example if we need to kill 1 million Galinkas [Galinka’s do not exist in the game except as a character run by a friend of mine :) ] and we are raiding in a Galinka killing field, then NO mercs! We need those Galinka kills to satisfy our objective. If that raid starts to fail, then open it anyway bc success is our most important reason for raiding. Otherwise I usually open for 1 or 2 more than half of what number of mercs available. The merc setting usually defaults to half, so you can just accept that if you wish. Then as the raid progresses adjust. Has the number of mercs joining filled the avail slots? Are we in need of more assistance? You can also use passwords to limit mercs. Generally you would use the password limitation if you have regular mercs who will just know it or you have invited another guild to merc or whatever. If you need it and have a use, use it.

4] Greet and Thank – as the Raid Runner, you have the responsibility to greet every merc and thank them for joining the raid. Mercs can be spotted by looking at the RPP leader board list. All Guilders [you] are a darker color of yellow while mercs are almost white. So you won’t be fighting much as you will be scanning the RPP and greeting and thanking mercs. When a merc speaks, respond! Talk to them! First of all, they are helping you, second you want them to help you again, third you want them to spread your good will to their friends, and finally, they might be looking for a good home! Let them know with your chatting that you are such a home!

5] Be a cheerleader [I always have my cheerleading outfit with me ;-) ] – I know, this may not be something you want to do, but do your best. Tell people when they are doing good [I watch the mercs especially, but anyone that is moving up the RPP chart rapidly or who is burning E deserves a nod of appreciation]. Remind ppl how many minutes there are until the Gold/Silver/Bronze reward ends. When you see a merc burning E, thank them! You want them back! In general, cheer ppl on. Go Team Go!

6] At the end of the raid, thank the mercs and invite them into your home. Then congratulate your ppl and the mercs with a hearty job well done and remind them that you appreciate the gold, silver, or bronze result.

7] Wipe the sweat from your brow and relax! Good job, you did it! Yay!

With thanks to Anet, Teri, PQ_Mysticnite, Dawn1, and Phideaux for their valuable advice and insights on running a successful raid.

I originally created this guide for the Peasants Quest Guild and am publishing it here with the generous permission of Anet, Guild Master Peasants Quest and Peasants Quarters
Sadie wrote: Running a small successful raid is better than a large failure.

Running small raids can kill your guild too. At certain points (e.g. the SV-KV divide), you will find your membership breaks into two categories. The lower toons can't run the higher raids, but the higher might toons will get frustrated and leave if you keep running smaller safe raids. They leave and then you can not complete any raids whatsoever. I've seen many guilds screw this up in both directions.

That is the single hardest guild master challenge in the game IMHO.
B4Play wrote:

Running small raids can kill your guild too. At certain points (e.g. the SV-KV divide), you will find your membership breaks into two categories. The lower toons can't run the higher raids, but the higher might toons will get frustrated and leave if you keep running smaller safe raids. They leave and then you can not complete any raids whatsoever. I've seen many guilds screw this up in both directions.

That is the single hardest guild master challenge in the game IMHO.

Awesome observation, B4Play. I do not run any guilds nor am I an Officer in any, so I might be way off base here. It seems that guilds are resolving this issue by creating multiple tiered guilds, either 3 or 4 guilds in a structure, each catering to different valor raid levels. Does your experience show that to be effective or ineffective Sweetheart?

If that is a possible solution, then I would think the timing of splitting the guilds and adding new tiers to be the crucial decision. I have only experienced a guild adding a tier once, and there were def growing pains, but the split was successful.

BC my experience in this is so limited, I am hoping you and others will add thoughts and ideas here.

Thx, Sadie
Running a guild is never a easy thing.
my view on this.

1] Choose a raid – How many toons and mercs can you get? How many do you need? Ask for advice. If in doubt, start a smaller raid. Running a small successful raid is better than a large failure.

Run raids base on your strength of your guild members

2) Announce the raid in guild chat - this gives ppl a chance to get ready. They might need to shop or be otherwise engaged. Give them a minute or two before you start the raid.

i suggest you have a fix schedule instead of a ad hoc raid. having a schedule worked out and put it on the guild board will attract players that can raid at the fix time ( timing is really trial and error. took me weeks to find a 'perfect' time for my guild.
Also post a ad on global chat informing of the raid that is happening so merc will be informed

3] Open Merc slots – How many?
keep it open unless you are confindent your team can finish it on their own.
once you have a fix schedule merc tend to look out for the raids they need and return regularly.
just keep the slots open.

there are to many guilds in BOH end day you need to find a core group of players that are williing to stay with you.
without it, its very hard to survive.

i agree with B4play that at some point you will encounter a divide between players might but that will be a issue for another day.

i play by this rule . players progress over guild advancement,
A guild without its players is usless
so open up merc slot even if u lose 10% extra guild power main thing is to finish the raid and all get the rewards
reduce raids so that players can hit for events

it is a game after all we play to have fun and not stress over it..

cheers and happy playing
Thank you Monster_Raiden for your response. You make many great points. I would like to discuss a couple of them, ask some questions, and solicit further input. Again, plz bear in mind that my experience here is very limited, though that never stops me from being very opinionated ;-)
Monster_Raiden wrote:
1] Choose a raid – How many toons and mercs can you get? How many do you need? Ask for advice. If in doubt, start a smaller raid. Running a small successful raid is better than a large failure.

Run raids base on your strength of your guild members

I absolutely agree with the concept.

However, not all of your vets and officers know the strength of your members, how many toons each one has, and how many of those toons even qualify for the raid in question. The Guild display of members online is too laggy to be useful and when you ask who is online, you often get greeted with silence.

In general, I know what raids my guild has the strength to run, but at any particular point in time I have zero answers to any of the above questions so I am at a loss how to run raids based on the strength of my guild members, yes? Could you elaborate on how I can do this?
Monster_Raiden wrote:
2) Announce the raid in guild chat - this gives ppl a chance to get ready. They might need to shop or be otherwise engaged. Give them a minute or two before you start the raid.

i suggest you have a fix schedule instead of a ad hoc raid. having a schedule worked out and put it on the guild board will attract players that can raid at the fix time ( timing is really trial and error. took me weeks to find a 'perfect' time for my guild.
Again I agree 100%

I apologize for intimating that raids are run ad hoc. In all four of the guilds I currently inhabit, all raids are scheduled. The schedules are posted in the guild hall for all to see and important updates are sent via message to all members in addition to being posted.

I agree that timing is difficult to master but raids need be run anyway. Since I am not the GM nor an Officer in any guild, I have no control over when a raid is set to be run, nor do any of the veterans who run many of the raids. So you run each raid at the time you are scheduled as best you can, Yes?

I also agree completely with posting in Global for mercs and I do this. And if I still do not have enough mercs I will post again in global. However, it is not included in my guide and it should be. Thank you Monster_Raiden, I shall add it in. Yay!
Monster_Raiden wrote:
3] Open Merc slots – How many?
keep it open unless you are confindent your team can finish it on their own.
Again I must apologize for my poor communication skills. I did not mean to imply that merc slots should be closed once opened. I only meant that if we need bandits, for example, that we run without mercs in LB to get the needed kills for our guild. Should the raid begin to fail though, open the slots anyway as better to complete the raid than to not, yes? Or have I missed your point entirely?
Monster_Raiden wrote:
3] Open Merc slots – How many?
once you have a fix schedule merc tend to look out for the raids they need and return regularly.
just keep the slots open.
In my experience, this only holds true for certain raids. Coc or CK, for example, tend to have a core of repeat mercs and I do my best to run those raids per schedule so the mercs can rely on my raids, but LB or WOO, for example, are not nearly as popular raids to attract consistent returning mercs, yes?
Monster_Raiden wrote:
i play by this rule . players progress over guild advancement,
A guild without its players is usless
so open up merc slot even if u lose 10% extra guild power main thing is to finish the raid and all get the rewards
reduce raids so that players can hit for events

it is a game after all we play to have fun and not stress over it..

cheers and happy playing

Great stuff! I agree with it all [but I still stress over it – personal problem I guess – I mean yes, it is a game, but most players here are very immersed in this great game, me as well. And when I get this immersed, I tend to stress, yes? Yes!]

And on a final note, I adore your signature, Monster_Raiden, for I am still in my "young and stupid" phase. One day I hope to achieve "old and wise". ;-)
Sadie wrote:
Awesome observation, B4Play. I do not run any guilds nor am I an Officer in any, so I might be way off base here. It seems that guilds are resolving this issue by creating multiple tiered guilds, either 3 or 4 guilds in a structure, each catering to different valor raid levels. Does your experience show that to be effective or ineffective Sweetheart?

Keep in mind that I only had an unwilling 3 week time as GM (the job was forced on me and nobody would take it), but have been an officer in 4 different guilds - all of which have been successful.

I have never been impressed with the tiered guild model but never been involved in more than a two level system and the lower guild is weak now because people moved up and were never replaced. The problem as I see it in general is that each guild in the system is going to be different. IMHO, guilds typically survive for one (or both) of two reasons:

1. Going for the top. There are only 4 guilds where I know this applies though there may be some lower ones moving fast up the charts. Also, this strategy can lead to burn out. Let me cite Formosa. They soared up the power charts, but then cratered and are a dead guild.

2. Relationships. People like each other and have each other's backs.

The tiers don't really handle either situation well.

By the way, the relationship problem is why many (most?) mergers ultimately fail in the game.
Regds tiered guilds - I don't know how it is at the moment, but Ethereal Light had a decent arrangement with a progressing lower "training" guild, Ethereal Dragons when I was there. Raid times didn't work for me, so I moved on, but I still see Global ads for Dragons, so they're still running up to KV raids. Might be worth speaking to some of their people for pointers if you want to go that route.
In general, I know what raids my guild has the strength to run, but at any particular point in time I have zero answers to any of the above questions so I am at a loss how to run raids based on the strength of my guild members, yes? Could you elaborate on how I can do this?
I agree that timing is difficult to master but raids need be run anyway. Since I am not the GM nor an Officer in any guild, I have no control over when a raid is set to be run, nor do any of the veterans who run many of the raids. So you run each raid at the time you are scheduled as best you can, Yes?

im not really a pro at this. i just happen to be very luck that i have a great team to support me.
what i mean is run a raid base on the majority of players might eg, SV,KV,CV raids.
For me i GEt the raid time fix up first than send out a propose raid schedule and listen to all the members feedback (if any) if majority have no comments i excute the raids base on what i sent out.
For a start i will try and attend all the plan raids to have a understanding of how the raid is going and if changes are needed, if all goes well and the raid finishes i will keep to it.
Should the raid begin to fail though, open the slots anyway as better to complete the raid than to not, yes? Or have I missed your point entirely?

sorry for not being clear.
you need to make the judgement call on the merc part as you go along in the game you will know how to better manage it so it hard for me to comment on it.
my suggestion is that try not to open the raid only when its about to fail.
being a merc they will normally choose to go into raids that is gold or sliver , not raids that are about to fail.
you must understand that raid rewards valor & HT are better if u get gold raids
if im not wrong the rewards are as follows gold raids 125% / sliver raid 100% / bronze raid 75%
In my experience, this only holds true for certain raids. Coc or CK, for example, tend to have a core of repeat mercs and I do my best to run those raids per schedule so the mercs can rely on my raids, but LB or WOO, for example, are not nearly as popular raids to attract consistent returning mercs, yes?
[/quote]

have not done those raids for the longest time so sorry i really dont know the responds of this raid currently.



hope i manage to answer all your questions :)
Thank you, B4Play and DreamingDaemon for your comments on Tiered guilds. I am involved in a 2 tier guild and was present when they split into two guilds. There were def growing pains, but it seems to be working well. I also joined a three tiered guild and it seems to function as well. The interesting thing I find is that some tiered guilds try to stagger their raids to accommodate the players with toons in the various tiers and some do not. Yet both approaches, from my limited vantage point, seem to be working well. This puzzles me as I would think the raids need be staggered.

At This point, I will just continue to monitor them with a critical eye as my toons progress or don’t progress and continue to grow or not. Since there seems to be no definitive resolution, I see nothing else to do on the Tiered front. I would continue to report on their success or lack thereof, but two such tiered guilds is not a sufficiently large number to be of significance. ;)

Thank you for your clarifications _Raiden. I appreciate your candor and honesty in your response. You did indeed answer all my questions. Thank you, Sweetheart. :lol:

Bimbosigier, I loved your response. But starting and killing other raids to push the one you want ppl to join sounds like fun, until your members get wise to your ways, yes? ;)

And just say NO to being a GM Sweetheart! Better to not GM than to quit the game! Hah! But I am late with my advice as always as you have already stated that in your response, yes? :lol:

I am just teasing you a bit bc I loved your “just woke up” comment and I love your choice of name [much more interesting than say.... Sadie] :lol: