Book of Heroes

Event Weekends & Misc. Stuff · page 2

Anechi

ModeratorThu Feb 6, 2014 1:40 pm
B4Play wrote:
ÇøølÇhäräçtêrsÆçïd wrote:You really don't want to go there. Anybody remember Mardoknol and the Sylver Hunters back in 2012 and the merc kicking flame war? That guild almost died due to that. Note: the guild is alive and well though because it got a new GM, a rename, and disavowed what happened in the past.

I wasn't on in 2012, what happened? Many guilds want this from what I've heard as I've asked a lot of top 100's for a rough idea.

Well back in those days, mercing meant leaving your guild and joining another one (there was no loyalty). Mardokno1 started kicking people out mid-raid for not doing enough RPP in his opinion. What the RPP was exactly is unclear as both sides gave different numbers, but at least one of the mercs in question was/is well known as a quality BoH player.

It started a multi-day flame war both in global (I think this was pre-moderators and might have been one of the events that drove the creation of the current moderation system) and in the forum (I'm sure the thread is still there on like page 50). Most mercs refused to go to his guild anymore. Before the guild completely collapsed, he stepped down. The new GM renamed the guild and did a wonderful job of recovering from that disaster.

The community was much smaller back in those days but the issue is that if you kick the wrong merc, you will get backlash. How severe it would be depends on where your guild is in the standings and who the merc is.

Also, keep in mind, any of us long term players who have merced hundreds of raids have skunked one before. I know I did - I was like 400RPP into a raid when my kiddo fell, got hurt and I had to go.

I think the blacklist is a better solution than the kick button. Once a merc has done any RPP, they are going to expect their rewards and you are denying them of it.

I was in Sylver Hunters when this "accident" happened and yeah it was totally mess. Guild actually didn't die for it and it kept going for a while. Until few officers made a new guild..at that point Mardukno1 gave Sylver Hunters to that new GM and have to say..they did wonderful job and should be proud of their guild.
Bimbosigliere wrote:Ahhhhhh!! Marduknol!!! Gogogogo

Bims, you forget one g...it was always Gogogogog