Book of Heroes

Shadow Walker UP · page 3

Cheka,

Your opinion that an sw with high hp, high dodge, and high magic resist can win, is I take it, untested?

If so, that makes it an expensive point of conjecture to test in terms of time and gs to determine if said conjecture has substance.

Perhaps the real kicker is not the one second stun delay, but the unparalleled ability of the wm to cancel any defense when using snap cast, which coincidentally also happens to become available at the one second mark, thereby giving the wm essentially back to back instantaneous critical attacks in combo with potential for multiple stuns and status effects.

The equivalent would be an sw being able to trigger off piercing strike, toxic blade, and smoke bomb instantly -

Or a justi doing the same with something like brutal strike, smite, and seismic slash....

With their opponent not being able to defend.
Its Ceka first.

And with my little sw i have 46% dodge, 30k hp and 22,5% resist. He is only 22k might atm. And at my might i kill wm. I even kill some wm with high might like huy (33k might) and nevla (29k). Ok i was lucky but it shows that its possible.

My goal with my sw is 50% dodge, 40k hp and 40,5% resist. With that im pretty sure that sw can do something against wm. The problem is no sw do this build at the moment and i dont know why... And the conclusion is here: sw is underpower because they dont have the right build.

Im pretty sure when most of player have all resist lvl 9, its going to be hard for wm because sw are going to resist almost everything and dodge everything. Wait later for craft lvl 9 to décide if sw is really underpower.
Ceka wrote:Nevla?

U forget i beat you with my sw 21k might and u are 29k?? Lol :)

I'd rather not think about that. :x :x :x
Ceka wrote:Nevla?

U forget i beat you with my sw 21k might and u are 29k?? Lol :)

When i read you. Its like u are a god of pvp. Its again a joke like u did before with ur record reset or u really think that? Lol.

Nah, I'd say I'm semi-serious. I do think it is a little bit annoying that I have a faulty record when I've played a lot and worked my ass off to gain might and grind shields for 2nd spec, but I suppose I've exagerrated my "fanaticism" a bit because I find it amusing that people become upset about it. :mrgreen:
Officially it is a beta, but things are going real slow so the PvP as it is, is being cemented into the game.

As for my skill. Nah, a PvP god would be a huge exagerration. I'd say I'm in the middle of average and "pro".
You guys are making me want to come back to pvp just to see how underpowered swers actually are, if at all :p

But... pve comes first... so once I get my last 43 t6 gems, I'll start building a new pvp spec.
NightRaven wrote:
Perhaps the real kicker is not the one second stun delay, but the unparalleled ability of the wm to cancel any defense when using snap cast, which coincidentally also happens to become available at the one second mark, thereby giving the wm essentially back to back instantaneous critical attacks in combo with potential for multiple stuns and status effects.

The equivalent would be an sw being able to trigger off piercing strike, toxic blade, and smoke bomb instantly -

Or a justi doing the same with something like brutal strike, smite, and seismic slash....

With their opponent not being able to defend.

I could be mistaken, but Snap Cast doesnt activate until the 1.5 sec mark. It might feel like its earlier to opponents, as most pure ice WM defend between a successful Grasp and the next spell, assuming they havent or dont stack burns first. That defend pushes the fight into the ability to use Snap next, which may or may not be a good idea (the defending between) depending on ability is going to be used to break Grasp.

However, like the rest of PvP, the balance shifts at different level and might ranges. I agree wit Ceka, as enchantments shift upwards, specifically Status Resist, WM become significantly less effective. In the level where most level 32s play, say the 12,000 to 18,000 might, WM are probably a bit OP.

At the 25k+ range, against veteran PVP'ers, I win or lose only because of the RNG giving me a bit of luck to either resist someone elses ability, or they resist mine. Against someone like Purao with 2 level 7 and 1 level 6 status resist, the fight is over in the first 1.75 seconds.

From my perspective at 27k might, the truely borderline OP class is currently Justicars, at least the ones that know how to play and are built for PVP. The ability to activate Stun and, worse, Seismic before the artificial delay... Well, it should be obvious.

I will concede though that Snap Cast should always cause the user to select their next ability before the opponent when both are in selection mode, such as after a stun break. Right now its about 50/50 who has to pick first. Of course, I also think if Sticky is going to be unresistable, applying it should break Stun.

I also believe the ability to sandbag might needs to be eliminated, or at least signicantly mitigated. The way might is calculated needs to give more weight to the weapon equip'd and potentially factor in open gem slots versus the average gem values actually in use... Have 4 slots unlocked but only 2 gems equip 'd, your might is calculated based upon 4 gems slots x the average might of those 2 gems.

And while Im at it, I believe the artificial level restriction once you hit level 32 needs to be eliminated. If it is ok to match a level 28 against a level 31 based upon might, why cant a level 32 be matched against a level 30 or 31 if the might is close? From experience, it was brutal when I leveled to 32, since I had much lower might and could only be paired against much higher might toons, since that was all that was in the pool.
Sanguin wrote:
NightRaven wrote:
Perhaps the real kicker is not the one second stun delay, but the unparalleled ability of the wm to cancel any defense when using snap cast, which coincidentally also happens to become available at the one second mark, thereby giving the wm essentially back to back instantaneous critical attacks in combo with potential for multiple stuns and status effects.

The equivalent would be an sw being able to trigger off piercing strike, toxic blade, and smoke bomb instantly -

Or a justi doing the same with something like brutal strike, smite, and seismic slash....

With their opponent not being able to defend.


From my perspective at 27k might, the truely borderline OP class is currently Justicars, at least the ones that know how to play and are built for PVP. The ability to activate Stun and, worse, Seismic before the artificial delay... Well, it should be obvious.

Finally someone elses who sees this. I completely agree with this person!
Shadow walker is pretty balanced (my main class). Justices seems underpowered. Warmage is crazy op right now. But, hey, it's beta. I think justicars need 2 blocks. They should be more tanky in PvP. It's messed up that war mages have was waaaaay more health than justicars. And then add the stuns, instacast, knockback, and highest damage. Warmage and justicars still need some tweaking.
I know most of you have more game time and pvp experience than I do. As an officer in a guild, I have and continue to field numerous comments regarding how neither justicars nor sw's can win against wm, and these are at might ratings and levels no where near most of you. Getting a justi and an sw to finally have a chance through the use of enchantments and high tier armor is currently a long time away for most of the players in my guild. Is the consensus that this is okay? That players of lower rank should just tolerate being farmed for coinage and sacrificed for the good of beta testing unless they decide to play a wm? This is how games lose players and revenue.
My personal observation when going up against a wm is the following...
We both try to jink for the one sec cutoff. Usually it's a combo on the wm part where ice lance leads up to the mark. The opponent has a choice to either risk getting hit with a critical and a knock back, or, defending. If the opponent defends, then the wm wins through icy grasp, critical, snap cast, defend, critical with knock back, critical. There is no defense against this at might levels below what has already been mentioned.
If by some coincidence the opponent wins a lucky chance and dodges ice lance, them lands a stun, some status effects, and a critical, s/he is then met with snap cast, defend, critical, icy grasp, critical with knock back, critical. The snap cast and icy grasp may be interchanged depending on the timer. This combo as well is difficult to impossible to defend against.
My apologies Ceka for mistyping your name. Thank you for your contributions, and your admission that your build wins against wm class are still unable to be categorized as something more than good fortune. I sincerely hope that your observations and buildout in that direction yield results beyond conjecture.
I, players in my guild, and many other players are not looking for any class to be op. We are looking for fairness. Yes, there is beta testing. How old is the game now? This last update may have improved pve, but either the programmers and assorted staff just completely dropped the ball on pvp, or, they made a deliberate choice to skew pvp to favor the wm class.
And in pvp, I feel that every active attack should be subject to resists, dodges, and blocks including sticky grenade.
Jetface wrote:Shadow walker is pretty balanced (my main class). Justices seems underpowered. Warmage is crazy op right now. But, hey, it's beta. I think justicars need 2 blocks. They should be more tanky in PvP. It's messed up that war mages have was waaaaay more health than justicars. And then add the stuns, instacast, knockback, and highest damage. Warmage and justicars still need some tweaking.

I don't think so. Good Justi can win against WM. Just need a bit of luck and hit with stun/knockback, than just keep him at long cast time or better stun him again.