Book of Heroes

SW "fix" in 1.3.3

So with what I would describe as a brutal nerf to SW's ability to attack things I would like to know what the benefit of dual wielding is. Please enlighten me. So far I have "costs an extra 155000 silver and 4 extra gems to be supposedly as good as a 2H." Melee was already a questionable stat for Shadow Walkers to begin with, but with this change it is even worse. When I saw it initially I didn't even think it was a bug. I just figured it was a bonus for having to pay double in resources to unlock sockets, have two chances to lose damage on an attack instead of one, and have to buy an extra set of gems (which btw once I start buying KV gems in a few weeks I am going to be VERY angry about that one).
If offhand damage will not be increased to a functional level I would like the option to equip a trout or perhaps a piece of moldy cheese in my offhand to better represent it's impact on my overall damage output.
Do I understand the "fix" right? Normally 1h weapon does 100% damage as a basic attack. Seems reasonable. Add a second weapon in the other hand, presumably to cause extra damage (and only on the basic attack) and you lose 25% of your main weapon attack? But then you get that 25% back on the second weapon, but as that does less damage (at same tier) you still end up with less than 100% of your main weapon damage? Who worked that one out? As for carrying two sets of gems, a shield will carry the gems for me, AND actually add to my block chance. So why would I carry a second weapon now? Only because I spent a lot of Soldier's Valor buying one and thus don't have the Valor left to but a shield with.
That's buy a shield with. Your edit function takes me to the first paragraph with no way to scroll down to the bottom to fix the typo.
Pfaff wrote:That's buy a shield with. Your edit function takes me to the first paragraph with no way to scroll down to the bottom to fix the typo.

You'd use two weapons because all of the special attacks use a MH + OH + MEL/MAG formula. So the OH increases your special attack damage though admittedly not by all that much. So I guess now you get a choice between a 20% damage (roughly) boost to your special attacks or having a shield since the "attack" button is pretty weak now. While it was probably too good before this solution seems to be taking the "over-nerf and then increase later" philosophy.

Overall I feel more that a useful button has been decreased in usefulness to the point where SWs may have been put where Mages were in the previous patch. Melee attacks make up roughly half my boss damage and this effectively lowers my boss damage by 25%. I'll still be fine, but people that aren't at 7k might are probably going to have some issues.
Hmm. I agree with your points regarding resource expenditure versus benefit gained. Opening all slots does take more silver, but doesn't that point apply to weapon + shield setups as well? As for having "two chances to lose damage on an attack instead of one," I guess I see it from the other side - two chances to hit, rather than one, on flighty enemies like bats and wolves. (My justicar keeps a point in smite pretty much just for those guys.) But you're right, there should be a more substantial benefit to opening up 8 slots, at a substantial cost, instead of just 4. Not to mention the additional cost of the gems themselves.
Meian wrote:I'll still be fine, but people that aren't at 7k might are probably going to have some issues.
I'm at 6.3k and change with tier 8s (MH is 9) and mostly +6 gems, some +4s still, all slots unlocked. I guess I'll have to wait and see when this goes live.
In regards to the sword and board deal. It is true for sword and board as well but this game really does not support shields in a viable fashion so I consider it to be moot.

As far as the higher dodge enemies go, my offhand doesn't do enough damage to actually kill one unless it was nearly dead anyways. So I generally need 2-3 hits to down one even with T10 weapons and a very high melee stat. So I usually need a couple of attacks to down then anyways. So if my main hand misses it might as well be both attacks miss (which also happens too often).
Meian wrote:It is true for sword and board as well but this game really does not support shields in a viable fashion so I consider it to be moot.
Actually, while I like the higher damage of two-handers for my justicar, I prefer the faster speed of a one-hander, so a sword and board set-up is what I use. You're right though that shields should be of more use.
Meian wrote:As far as the higher dodge enemies go, my offhand doesn't do enough damage to actually kill one unless it was nearly dead anyways.
That's usually the case for wolves and bats after my standard opening for trash mobs, since they resist poison. ;)
I didn't know the formula for special attacks, that alone makes an offhand weapon worthwhile to me, since shields are next to useless anyway in this game. That doesn't make the 75/25 system for basic attack correct, but it does givenme an excellent reason to keep my offhand weapon anyway. I often get a second hit that kills a second near- dead enemy with
my current basic attack, we shall see if the degraded version is still capable of that.
Pfaff wrote:I didn't know the formula for special attacks, that alone makes an offhand weapon worthwhile to me, since shields are next to useless anyway in this game. That doesn't make the 75/25 system for basic attack correct, but it does givenme an excellent reason to keep my offhand weapon anyway. I often get a second hit that kills a second near- dead enemy with
my current basic attack, we shall see if the degraded version is still capable of that.

Well, that's why I didn't mention it as a bug. I figured it was just my bonus for stacking a sub-optimal stat. I think for me it will barely even out once I get 100% crit. Should I really have to get 100% crit to make one of my weapons do it's job though? How about the people who don't have over 250 increased melee damage? That would be just about everyone else. At the end of the day I suspect we're just going to have to deal with it. I am just less motivated to spend money, that's all.

Also, no one has really answered my question yet. ^^