A lot of guilds don't have enough members to circulate their guilds. Even medium guilds, they still need members who live in similar time zone and/or have the same available time to succeed in raids.
If there's CCP, this problem will void and also the game will be more fun.
CCP should be got by exploring the maps. They can be in various race, class, grade. Loot chance and their rarity depends on only player's luck. But if a guild don't have enough members, CCP loot chance will be higher for GM and officers of this guild.
I have to agree with Bims here.
The idea sounds nice in theory, but the real problem is too many guilds created by too many people who don't have the time/resources/ability to build it up. The end result is thousands of abandoned guilds, and plenty of players who never experience the benefits of being in a reliable guild.
New players usually join to large guilds. They will choose most successful guild they can. It is IMPOSSIBLE to build a new successful guild without effort outside the game. Early players are easier than later new players. So There should be a WAY to build new successful guild for new players inside the game. CCP is the ANSWER.
Don't need to worry that if there will be too many guilds or thousands of abandoned guild because of CCP. Being of plenty guilds don't defects the game if they have enough members, instead of many small guild that don't have members like current condition in BoH. CCP usage can be limited when the guild has sufficient level and real people members. In fact CCP is intended for foundation of new guild. Anyway if too many new guilds are not wanted, CCP loot chance can be decreased. So that only the hardworking enthusiasts GM can get CCP.
My opinion is if you're gonna start a guild be prepared for the work it takes recruiting members. I've seen new guilds thrive because their GM invests the time in it. Ive also seen a lot of new guilds fail. Seems a lot of players start guilds so they can be "in charge" and then when it gets tough they bail or they don't have the time to invest in it.
It takes A LOT of hard work and time maintaining a successful guild. If you don't have that then join an existing guild instead of starting a new one.
If you do start one make sure you pick the right players for officers and veterans. Sure everyone wants to be able to start raids but there should be some responsibilities to the officers to help the GM maintain the guild. The GM can't be on 24/7 and when they aren't, the officers need to step up. The GM also needs to relinquish some control to the officers if they want the help as well.
Keep in mind guilds are group efforts from GM to the last recruit.