Book of Heroes

How does Arcane Shield work?

I have just landed a 9147 Toxic Blade crit on a War Mage with Arcane Shield up in PvP. Arcane Shield reduces the damage of the next attack by 75%. Does this mean without it would have dealt more than 36k damage? I doubt that this is possible because my largest hit so far is almost 20k, including Shadow Veil. I also have 9.6% Armor Penetration, maybe this is the reason? Or is Arcane Shield just bugged?
Tacita wrote:I have just landed a 9147 Toxic Blade crit on a War Mage with Arcane Shield up in PvP. Arcane Shield reduces the damage of the next attack by 75%. Does this mean without it would have dealt more than 36k damage? I doubt that this is possible because my largest hit so far is almost 20k, including Shadow Veil. I also have 9.6% Armor Penetration, maybe this is the reason? Or is Arcane Shield just bugged?

I've also gotten the feeling that there has been some questionable occurrences regarding the Arcane Shield.

Possessed_Mithrid

Sat Feb 22, 2014 1:29 pm
Hi Tacita,
I have noticed this myself, both on the attacking as well as receiving end, noting where the damage delivered just did not calculate if we took the idea of 75% reduction at face value.

I have had several theories on this but am not certain to date if they are remotely accurate.

First: I do not believe it is a straight 75% reduction of the total calculated damage of an attack, as the description in the abilities section would imply. (meaning if you landed a critical attack that would normally do 20k damage, that if they have arcane shield up, it would only land 5k damage.

One possible theory I have contemplated the most: It is a modifier to your defense rating...meaning that if you have a 30% defense rating, than it would become 105% for the next attack. In such a case AP enchant would be very beneficial as you would bypass some of this rating...it is also possible that the defense rating has a MAX cap...so if you are at 50% defense rating, and have arcane shield, that you would expect a new rating of 125%, but if there is a cap (just like there is a max cap on haste %, crit damage%, crit % etc), and hypothetically say it is 80%...so maybe your arcane shield only gives you an increase of 30% in such a case.

I have a few others but I doubt most of them...

End of day, I am not certain what is really going on but I agree, it does not appear to be a straight up 75% reduction because I have been hit with attacks, while having an arcane shield, that if back calculated would have indicated a massive attack...in many cases, a level of damage never seen when I was hit without an arcane shield.
It was the killing blow, right?
I note that when target is close to death and killing hit landing - dmg numbers shown greater than usual. Both pvp and pve.
For me it's most useful in onslaught - I try to cast rune when boss is near health with good chances rune kills it dealing more dmg than in middle of life bar.
Same with sticky grenade. When it kills the boss dmg shown is higher
Reviving an old thread.

This has come up just lately in PvP vs Jaw. He hit me, in DW with a 13 900 toxic blade crit through arcane shield. If arcane does as it says, then this indicates a 54k crit, which of course is insane. Here are the mechanics as far as I can tell:

Suppose on a normal day Jaw would have crit me for 30k (which I don't think he actually can). He has 21.6% arm pen. This bypasses defence and arcane shield, so

0.216 * (30k) = 6.48k damage goes through.

Out of the rest of the damage, arcane is applied so that portion is reduced by 75%

30k - 6.48 = 23.52k

0.25 * (23.52k) = 5.88 k

Adding the total yields

5.88k + 6.48k = 12.36 k goes through.


In this case the effective damage reduction is 58.8% not the advertised 75%.

Based on this calculation, this means that Jaw would have hit me for a crit between 33 and 34k. Which is crazy alson IMO.

Now having said this I'm not sure how other things like wrath/poison/magma are gonna affect this. More clarification would be useful. BTW I've been told that what arcane shield does is wipes your defense and sets it to 75% but I don't think that actually right. If that's what it does then the advertised 75% reduction in your next hit is definitely misleading.
I got hit with a 16k Smite through defend with Arcane up...do the math Jumper and tell me how big a hit that should of been if Arcane is working properly/like the description says.
Saraa wrote:I got hit with a 16k Smite through defend with Arcane up...do the math Jumper and tell me how big a hit that should of been if Arcane is working properly/like the description says.

50k+
Thats only my opinion but i think a little like Dj.

It seems a critical hit with debuff defense or/and with armor pene makes a huge damage despite of u have arcane shield.
U will never see for example a sw doing 8-9k percing strike crit even with Dw (except if the guy has armor pene x3 but i think only Éric has armor pene x3 amongst sw). That works well with toxic blade because of stack poison.
Saraa wrote:I got hit with a 16k Smite through defend with Arcane up...do the math Jumper and tell me how big a hit that should of been if Arcane is working properly/like the description says.

I know that defend and arcane shield do not stack. You are wasting your time doing this because arcane REPLACES your defense.