I need a definitive answer from Venan please. Does critical eye only help physical moves (melee) or does the +20% chance to deal a critical hit apply to nature attacks (poison) as well? Please settle this debate. Thank you 
Critical Eye - all physical or magic?
Its only physical.
Wildflower wrote:I need a definitive answer from Venan please. Does critical eye only help physical moves (melee) or does the +20% chance to deal a critical hit apply to nature attacks (poison) as well? Please settle this debate. Thank you
I can definitively say that it only applies to physical crits. If you check your stats page where it lists your crit %, you'll see that only physical crit is boosted.
The ability text is: 'Grants +20% chance to deal a critical hit and +30% critical hit power with physical attacks.' I can see how it could be read as applying to all hits (though that isn't how I would personally interpret that phrase). It's always worth checking your numbers when dealing with abilities that provide direct boosts. For example you might take Urgency without realising its proc rate isn't as high as they assumed.
And the ability description does say:
"Grants +20% chance to deal a Critical Hit and +30% Critical Hit Power with physical attacks."
(numbers from Crit Eye 3, my emphasis.)
"Grants +20% chance to deal a Critical Hit and +30% Critical Hit Power with physical attacks."
(numbers from Crit Eye 3, my emphasis.)
Yes, I too read that it applied to only physical attacks, but my bro Z insisted the first half of the description also applied to nature attacks & stated he'd gotten that info from Tiffy. That's why I wanted an official answer from Venan. I'd still appreciate an official answer from Venan. Thanks!
Wildflower wrote:Yes, I too read that it applied to only physical attacks, but my bro Z insisted the first half of the description also applied to nature attacks & stated he'd gotten that info from Tiffy. That's why I wanted an official answer from Venan. I'd still appreciate an official answer from Venan. Thanks!
There's been a miscommunication (I'm being generous...) between Tiff, your brother, and you. Poison Crit % isn't affected by Crit Eye.
If you have Crit Eye equipped, and it affected Poison attacks, then your Nature Crit % would be higher than your Fire/Spirit/Ice Crit %. That doesn't happen. Check it out for yourself.
It is all in the same sentence..
Thanks everyone. I love it when I'm right & my bro read this post, so now he isn't wasting ability points on critical eye for his nature sw. *feeling smug ;p