Book of Heroes

Suggestion: Guild ban/silence

Many have made this suggestion but recent events make it timely. Please give guild masters the power to ban a player from mercing at a guild. I know one could password protect a raid and then give the password to everyone other than the excluded person, but there are serious adverse consequences to that in terms of availability.

I also repeat that the GM needs the power to silence a player within guild chat, since there is no mechanism to remove the player from guild chat once play has begun. Trying to find a mod to handle it is impractical, particularly since there are so many times when mods just are not available (yes, even in my own guild). Besides, why should a mod be required to enforce the rules of conduct a particular guild chooses to adopt?
Derrin i would merc and you would silence me just so you wouldn't have to listen to my nonsense
Monster_Salad wrote:Derrin i would merc and you would silence me just so you wouldn't have to listen to my nonsense
Your nonsense has not been sufficiently annoying, at least in HJ, that I would plan to silence you if given the ability. :)
Derrin_Watson wrote:
Monster_Salad wrote:Derrin i would merc and you would silence me just so you wouldn't have to listen to my nonsense
Your nonsense has not been sufficiently annoying, at least in HJ, that I would plan to silence you if given the ability. :)

Hmm guess i need to merc again ;-)
I don't think merc banning is a good idea, since it would probably end up making Venan lose a lot of players.
Nevla_Nom wrote:I don't think merc banning is a good idea, since it would probably end up making Venan lose a lot of players.
I disagree. I am not talking about banning from the game. I am talking about a guild being able to control more effectively who can participate with the guild.

Why would a rational guild which makes use of mercs wish to restrict a player from participating with that guild? I can think of only 2 reasons: (1) the player refuses to comply with the standards of the guild, or (2) the player regularly skunks raids. Many are the complaints in the forums about that second type of merc. Shouldn't a guild be able to say "You don't deserve to take up a valuable resource in our guild"?

I submit a rational guild does not exclude good players who perform well. Otherwise, the guild is cutting off potential assistance.

How many players are there that go around from guild to guild skunking raids so that they might find themselves unwelcome anywhere and therefore drop out of the game? I think and hope that we would be talking about very few people. And even fewer will be sorry to see players like that leave.
In theory, this is a good idea. However, the assumption that guilds (or whomever is in charge of them) are rational is a bit optimistic. This potentially becomes a tool that can be abused to exclude some players from mercing certain raids altogether. Example: Say you don't like a certain player (for whatever reason). As an "irrational" guild leader, you ban them from mercing your raids. To top it off, you ask friends to also ban that player from mercing in their guilds as well. Since some high end raids are only run by a dozen or so guilds, it doesn't take much to keep a player from being able to merc that raid completely. I'm sure Venan would not approve of this kind of exclusion. It dances too near to the fine line of online bullying. So, while some "players" certainly would earn the ban you are proposing, the possibility of it being abused is too great.

Beekeo has already said that if a player is found to be intentionally trying to skunk raids, their access to the game may be revoked. I would think that this is an adequate means to deal with the problem. If there are truly only a handful of instances where this feature would be needed, then it can already be handled with little hassle by support.

The ability to silence players in guild chat, however, is definitely fine as it doesn't interfere with a player's ability to "play" the game.
WanderingGrip wrote:In theory, this is a good idea. However, the assumption that guilds (or whomever is in charge of them) are rational is a bit optimistic. This potentially becomes a tool that can be abused to exclude some players from mercing certain raids altogether. Example: Say you don't like a certain player (for whatever reason). As an "irrational" guild leader, you ban them from mercing your raids. To top it off, you ask friends to also ban that player from mercing in their guilds as well. Since some high end raids are only run by a dozen or so guilds, it doesn't take much to keep a player from being able to merc that raid completely. I'm sure Venan would not approve of this kind of exclusion. It dances too near to the fine line of online bullying. So, while some "players" certainly would earn the ban you are proposing, the possibility of it being abused is too great.

Beekeo has already said that if a player is found to be intentionally trying to skunk raids, their access to the game may be revoked. I would think that this is an adequate means to deal with the problem. If their are truly only a handful of instances where this feature would be needed, then it can already be handled with little hassle by support.

The ability to silence players in guild chat, however, is definitely fine as it doesn't interfere with a player's ability to "play" the game.

This is pretty much what I was thinking. It could and it would be abused.

Sure, it would be awesome from a guild/guild leader point of view, but it would make Venan lose players since they would essentially be shut out of a part of the game. The game world would be run by mafia type guilds.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Mar 11, 2014 11:43 am
Nevla_Nom wrote:
WanderingGrip wrote:In theory, this is a good idea. However, the assumption that guilds (or whomever is in charge of them) are rational is a bit optimistic. This potentially becomes a tool that can be abused to exclude some players from mercing certain raids altogether. Example: Say you don't like a certain player (for whatever reason). As an "irrational" guild leader, you ban them from mercing your raids. To top it off, you ask friends to also ban that player from mercing in their guilds as well. Since some high end raids are only run by a dozen or so guilds, it doesn't take much to keep a player from being able to merc that raid completely. I'm sure Venan would not approve of this kind of exclusion. It dances too near to the fine line of online bullying. So, while some "players" certainly would earn the ban you are proposing, the possibility of it being abused is too great.

Beekeo has already said that if a player is found to be intentionally trying to skunk raids, their access to the game may be revoked. I would think that this is an adequate means to deal with the problem. If their are truly only a handful of instances where this feature would be needed, then it can already be handled with little hassle by support.

The ability to silence players in guild chat, however, is definitely fine as it doesn't interfere with a player's ability to "play" the game.

Tihs is pretty much what I was thinking. It could and it would be abused.

Sure, it would be awesome from a guild/guild leader point of view, but it would make Venan lose players since they would essentially be shut out of a part of the game. The game world would be run by mafia type guilds.

I have to agree here. I'm not sure being barred from a guild's raids entirely would make many quit the game, but the potential for abuse here is just far too great. This suggestion is similar to others (like the trade/auction/giving items idea) where the idea is a good one, but actually implementing it would create more problems than it would solve.

Venan knows the skunk merc issue will go away if we revert to a similar merc setup to 1.5. They quickly got rid of the caps on guild members in each raid, lets see merc caps follow please. It should be up to each guild how many mercs they allow.