Book of Heroes

Final 2 cents worth.

I dont really play anymore. Grinding isnt fun. A lot of players seem to be hitting the same boredom wall. This is not Venans fault. The structure of BOH is restrictively linear.
It ends. XP becomes meaningless. This is a pity both for players and Venan.
It ends because there is no conflict between the players. We play the game. Not each other. Other enduring games have realised this. The myriad 'clash of the clans' and TCG's. These games garner millions of players and multiply year by year, realm by realm.
Venan needs to do this. PVP can be seen as an attempt at this conflict structure, but once again the nature of the game has thwarted the ambition. With limited characters and identical skillsets PVP is basically a mathematically presetermined waitfest. Good players know what is coming (or should) so employ the required defence/comeback. Repeat. And repeat, until the math winds down to the winner. Required skill is low, required fun is missing.
So...
How to produce conflict? A lively world chat instead of people *climbing trees* and *licking their fur*? The solution must involve the current ingame structure at its core. Venan seems to be struggling to innovate. Updates are number tweaks and different quests - all of which are essentially clones of the fetch quests we all remember. And Venan, so they attest, is small. New subroutines and coding protocols would likely never eventuate from them. On this game at least.
The answer then is the raid.
The conflict injected? Guilds raid guilds.
Oh No! Guild wars! Pffft. PVP en masse.
No. That would be just boredom on a larger scale.
How about this...
Guilds are protected by armies. As a guild levels up in prestige their army grows. From 1 wave to 2. Then 3 and so on. Other guilds can raid. Not the members of the target guild per se, but this 'protective army'. Guilds gain valor by raiding in this way. Just as they do now. Raid a squire level guild you get SV. Raid higher, get higher. This would discourage higher guilds raiding lower guilds, and encourage lower guilds to fight above their wait for high tier valor. Attacking a lower level guild could reduce the time required for a succesful raid, furthur discouraging guild farming.
At the start of the raid the attacking guild chooses to attack an opponents monument, statue or, horror of horrors, their precious favor bestowing buildings. It should obviously be harder to atttack a building. More waves, bigger waves, timer tweaks or similar. The current structure of a raid as it is now stays in place. Gold, silver and bronze become stolen, destroyed and defaced. Steal an opposing guilds monument (ie, get gold) you get it and its prestige. Destroy it you get half the prestige. Merely deface it and you lose half prestige. Fail and the defender gets your monument in the ransack.
A similar system could be implemented in the attacking of opposing guilds buildings.
:) Imagine the conflict then...
To make things even more interesting higher levels guilds can customize their army from an expanding list the higher you climb in prestige. Say, LOTS of gob to slow down enemies or heavy hitting bosses to hurt them. A wave of disarming flame witches. A platoon of steelclaws... A final wave could be entirely custom, put together by the guild when members 'take prisoner' a desired monster during a normal raid or quest. This can be linked to the defend button which has a new sub-option - subdue. Tapping this option in an attempt to capture it could double the enemies life due to rage, or needs to be beaten unarmed or some such, but if defeated anyway goes into a pool of creatures elite guilds could build their 4th layer to their guuld army. And their 5th? 6th? Who knows?
Anyway.
Im done. Dont play much anymore. Its become boring and im at war in another game with some very clever people. Its exciting, and not a grind in sight...
This has been, I think, my final 2 cents worth.
Feel free to destroy.
:p
zip.
I really like the idea and where it's going. As long as you don't have to be on for hours at a time (biggest complaint of the LoB raid) I could see it working out. It would be nice to see guilds being able to align with each other as well.

I don't know anything about programming or if this is even doable but beats farming for essence to no end.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Mar 24, 2014 10:13 am
The thing that I most want to see (entirely separate of how realistic or difficult it is to implement - I have no way to know) is this:

An event (in a similar way to the events today) that requires a guild to work as a team to overcome. Not a 'dungeon' style event or something that appears in areas/raids. For argument's sake, let's say a massive dragonman army descends on Glenfort. The event becomes a central point that spawns encounters at guild level, or also at player level for those that don't like/aren't in guilds. At player level, you'd be grouped up into parties that would enter together and fight together (like the second idea below).

At guild level it essentially becomes a raid, though perhaps with different mechanics. I for one really enjoyed the way the enemies were scaled and thrown at you in the Hallowe'en event, so maybe it could be in a similar fashion but with an 'end' point based on kills rather than a timed appearance schedule.

Guilds could also 'link' within the event, say as an option solely for GMs. Once the guilds link up in the event 'lobby', they enter a special encounter level that throws far harder creatures at them but offers better potential rewards.

Essentially the idea would be creating something that the whole community must fight, but with some kind of metaplot (however brief) and an end point - e.g. for the whole last 24hrs a 'final battle' mode activates.

My other favourite is creating dungeons that groups of players can enter, RPG-style. Perhaps when you hit the icon to enter, a separate option pops up to 'Create Party' which can either be passworded so friends can jump in or left open (these mechanics already exist, so this must be possible). The group then goes through an extended dungeon scaled to their average might (or some other way) and fights a dungeon boss. This dungeon would give scaling rewards (like potions etc) but also essence, a chance for flux and perhaps some random shard drops like Karnak. Crucially, the enemies would scale to a might average. So if I join a party of two 40k toons with my 27k, for me the enemies will be harder. These enemies also determine what rewards drop during/at the end of the dungeon. So a bunch of maxed toons could get together for a really challenging fight, or they could open it up for lower mights to join if they want to farm rather than test their toons. Each step in the raid would spawn challenging enemies for the average might involved, rather than onslaught-style waves (I'm thinking here of elite enemies where killing them takes more thought, like behemoths or the rare enemies in the vile realm). To be challenging, these enemies would have far, far more health than in other encounters in the game (similar to character health).

If a bunch of you can jump into something a bit more personal than a raid, maybe this would stimulate the social side of the game and allow people to meet up outside guilds.

In my opinion, dropping the loyalty cost is just a token gesture, an admission that maybe it wasn't the best thing for the social side of the game to lock us in our guilds. Doesn't actually matter if it's 50% or 10% - for a period of time you must lose max energy, so only some will actually guild hop.
I would think its a great idea from Ilyana.

Create something like a world conquest where the players from all over the world hit one raid over a x number of days