Book of Heroes

Class Imbalance

The new raid seems to meet the objective of developing a more casual raid that bridges vg and lob. But it is very disappointing that the the large class imbalance that exists in PvE was not even addressed in this update. I cannot imagine that your data does not make it very clear that justicars, particularly one handed justis, cannot possibly compete with the other classes at the highest level.

Why not start by al least acknowledging that fact and let us know if you intend to address it? Class imbalances are always a big problem in any role playing game. PvP may be balanced but only a minority participate in that. PvE is not balanced and everybody takes part. While the new raid is clearly very playable by justis (in fact, they may even have an advantage against the bear because of greater defense, stun, and knockback), this does not address the the lob onslaught problem in any way. The winners in this game remain the tunes that can go through 30+ waves in onslaught and thus obtain crazily high rpp. This is not good for the game,and it can't even be good for Venan as these tunes progress at such a fast pace that they have no need to invest in gs
Steerpike wrote:The new raid seems to meet the objective of developing a more casual raid that bridges vg and lob. But it is very disappointing that the the large class imbalance that exists in PvE was not even addressed in this update. I cannot imagine that your data does not make it very clear that justicars, particularly one handed justis, cannot possibly compete with the other classes at the highest level.

Why not start by al least acknowledging that fact and let us know if you intend to address it? Class imbalances are always a big problem in any role playing game. PvP may be balanced but only a minority participate in that. PvE is not balanced and everybody takes part. While the new raid is clearly very playable by justis (in fact, they may even have an advantage against the bear because of greater defense, stun, and knockback), this does not address the the lob onslaught problem in any way. The winners in this game remain the tunes that can go through 30+ waves in onslaught and thus obtain crazily high rpp. This is not good for the game,and it can't even be good for Venan as these tunes progress at such a fast pace that they have no need to invest in gs

PvP is not balanced.
Nevla_Nom wrote:
Steerpike wrote:The new raid seems to meet the objective of developing a more casual raid that bridges vg and lob. But it is very disappointing that the the large class imbalance that exists in PvE was not even addressed in this update. I cannot imagine that your data does not make it very clear that justicars, particularly one handed justis, cannot possibly compete with the other classes at the highest level.

Why not start by al least acknowledging that fact and let us know if you intend to address it? Class imbalances are always a big problem in any role playing game. PvP may be balanced but only a minority participate in that. PvE is not balanced and everybody takes part. While the new raid is clearly very playable by justis (in fact, they may even have an advantage against the bear because of greater defense, stun, and knockback), this does not address the the lob onslaught problem in any way. The winners in this game remain the tunes that can go through 30+ waves in onslaught and thus obtain crazily high rpp. This is not good for the game,and it can't even be good for Venan as these tunes progress at such a fast pace that they have no need to invest in gs

PvP is not balanced.

PvP being balanced seems subjective. I see people saying it's balanced and unbalanced. When I see people complain about the latter, it is almost always that "I play Class A. Classes B and C have an unfair advantage because X,Y." - it can be WMs complaining about Juggernaut, Justis complaining about Riposte, or SWs complaining about Snap Cast. Whatever. I don't PvP and therefore don't give a flying one about PvP balance.

However. Justis have objectively been nerfed into the realms of crippledom in PvE in the name of PvP balance (hence Steerpike's reference to PvP balance), to the point that I've seen players who have been here longer than me (about a year) reduce their playing dramatically or altogether. And not only Justi-players, but others who have seen what has happened to Justis and decided it's not worth their time, money and effort to carefully build up a toon to have that wiped out by an ill-conceived balancing that the majority of players don't care about.
Imagine if WMs were tomorrow suddenly reduced to their pre-2.0 state from where they are now? I imagine there would be a similar reaction.

Personally, I barely play my 38k Justi any more. Haven't even done the new area. I log on to a raid, burn a non-Onslaught phase in <5mins, and log off. I'm not spending any (more) money on the toon, and I'm not developing it, because when a WM 10k Might lower can demolish me in Onslaught - and Onslaughting is the only real, viable method to take for development - there is zero inventive to bother. A WM can do with natural e what I have to spend $ on refills to achieve, having spent less time, money and effort building up their toon (based on a lower-Might WM that can thoroughly spank me in Onslaught). Pre-nerfing, I could hold my own with similar-Mighted toons of other classes - no Onslaught King, but ok.

For the record, I started a WM to compare, and so far (Undrian complete, Shattered Realm near complete, just under 10k Might) it has been an absolute cakewalk compared to previous toons.

To be clear:
* I don't want WMs or SWs nerfing in PvE.
* I don't want anyone boosting or nerfing in PvP (hell, reduce Justi damage by 90% and take away everything but Basic Attack for all I care).
* I want Justis to be able to compete on a level playing field in PvE in the only viable toon development area left - Onslaught.

Splitting skills between PvE and PvP seems the only workable method. Tinkering round the edges in a manner that affects both is just pissing everyone off.

TLDR:
Justi UP.
WM OP.
-.-
DreamingDaemon wrote:
PvP being balanced seems subjective. I see people saying it's balanced and unbalanced. When I see people complain about the latter, it is almost always that "I play Class A. Classes B and C have an unfair advantage because X,Y." - it can be WMs complaining about Juggernaut, Justis complaining about Riposte, or SWs complaining about Snap Cast. Whatever. I don't PvP and therefore don't give a flying one about PvP balance.

However. Justis have objectively been nerfed into the realms of crippledom in PvE in the name of PvP balance (hence Steerpike's reference to PvP balance), to the point that I've seen players who have been here longer than me (about a year) reduce their playing dramatically or altogether. And not only Justi-players, but others who have seen what has happened to Justis and decided it's not worth their time, money and effort to carefully build up a toon to have that wiped out by an ill-conceived balancing that the majority of players don't care about.
Imagine if WMs were tomorrow suddenly reduced to their pre-2.0 state from where they are now? I imagine there would be a similar reaction.

Personally, I barely play my 38k Justi any more. Haven't even done the new area. I log on to a raid, burn a non-Onslaught phase in <5mins, and log off. I'm not spending any (more) money on the toon, and I'm not developing it, because when a WM 10k Might lower can demolish me in Onslaught - and Onslaughting is the only real, viable method to take for development - there is zero inventive to bother. A WM can do with natural e what I have to spend $ on refills to achieve, having spent less time, money and effort building up their toon (based on a lower-Might WM that can thoroughly spank me in Onslaught). Pre-nerfing, I could hold my own with similar-Mighted toons of other classes - no Onslaught King, but ok.

For the record, I started a WM to compare, and so far (Undrian complete, Shattered Realm near complete, just under 10k Might) it has been an absolute cakewalk compared to previous toons.

To be clear:
* I don't want WMs or SWs nerfing in PvE.
* I don't want anyone boosting or nerfing in PvP (hell, reduce Justi damage by 90% and take away everything but Basic Attack for all I care).
* I want Justis to be able to compete on a level playing field in PvE in the only viable toon development area left - Onslaught.

Splitting skills between PvE and PvP seems the only workable method. Tinkering round the edges in a manner that affects both is just pissing everyone off.

TLDR:
Justi UP.
WM OP.
-.-


I agree with all your points Daemon. I started a Justi 2/3 months back just to see what all the complaining is about. Now, at 26-27k might... well... there's definitely a gap between SW/WM and Justis... but I don't know if its necessarily that Justi's are underpowered, or that expectations have changed. Pre-2.0, Hitting 3k rpp/round in kfs was considered "good". Sure, there were people hitting way more than that, but if you were averaging ~3k, you felt satisfied that you were keeping up with your peers.

After 2.0, with the introduction of LoB, subjectively "good" SWers are averaging 5.1k/round, and WM's upwards of 6k. My little baby 26k justi is still plowing through at 2.7-3k/round, and because I wasn't around for the justi nerf or owned a justi prior to 2.0, it doesn't seem terribly bad. It's only bad when I compare myselves to the other classes' growth.

That said, not necessarily sure what can be done to help. For starters, elder fury only reduces ability cast times, not cooldowns, which becomes annoying when trying to use a rotation. 1h Justi isn't really all that onslaught viable. Spirit justi is full of issues in on cds. Not even a valid onslaught rotation without twisting yourself in a loop.

But then again, it's impossible to balance every subclass (1h, 2h, spirit, melee) to be good at everything. There's always going to be a time and a place for every build. Kinda like how a poison SWer is good at mobs, and melee good at bosses.
Yes agreed, Justis haven't really been nerfed - just the other 2 classes strengthened for PvE onslaught.

Justi are about the same strength as before for onslaught - lost Brutality, gained Elder Fury. 1H nerfed for onslaught by Stagger change but just switch to 2H.

I expect there will be more tweaks in future so make the most of it now if you are a WM!
EricM wrote:
But then again, it's impossible to balance every subclass (1h, 2h, spirit, melee) to be good at everything. There's always going to be a time and a place for every build. Kinda like how a poison SWer is good at mobs, and melee good at bosses.

SW has a viable option in this instance - dual spec solves it quite nicely. Sure, to sort out the enchants and gems takes some farming, but it's perfectly viable to have a melee spec1 and poison spec2 - as many seem to do.
I find these threads funny. I have all three classes and I look at playability instead of payout.

It is the 2.0 SW that I can't stand and I think needs fixing badly. First, you are stuck with 4 extra gems you have to buy. Then you have dual specs. Then you have the extra gem and enchants to deal with magic and melee. Then my understanding is that you have to constantly use Death Wish to get a good onslaught score and I hate having to play that way. Then you have to buy 2 elixirs to be competitive (the second one barely helps justies and mages). Finally, all the extra button presses to get things done.

Sure, my justie is getting lower RPP on onslaught, but I enjoy getting it. After my mage hit 40K, I am just not so much into the essence chase and switched to finishing tokens and valor on the other classes. However, the reality is that I am working on my Justie and I just use my SW to absorb non-onslaught waves to push raids along.

SW is fun on CoC, but otherwise, I don't like playing it. I am just trying to keep it in the might ballpark of my other toons in case a future update makes it better. Much like the Mage was semi-terrible until 2.0.

Please don't say "it's your build". I have used builds/rotations by the top SW players in the game.

Finally, Venan, please give me an option to switch my second SW into a Spirit Justicar. Then at least I would play it.
I'm guessing this is thread #786 that complains about class imbalance. I wonder who will create thread #1000? Should they get a special prize?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Apr 2, 2014 9:24 am
B4Play wrote:I find these threads funny. I have all three classes and I look at playability instead of payout.

It is the 2.0 SW that I can't stand and I think needs fixing badly. First, you are stuck with 4 extra gems you have to buy. Then you have dual specs. Then you have the extra gem and enchants to deal with magic and melee. Then my understanding is that you have to constantly use Death Wish to get a good onslaught score and I hate having to play that way. Then you have to buy 2 elixirs to be competitive (the second one barely helps justies and mages). Finally, all the extra button presses to get things done.

Sure, my justie is getting lower RPP on onslaught, but I enjoy getting it. After my mage hit 40K, I am just not so much into the essence chase and switched to finishing tokens and valor on the other classes. However, the reality is that I am working on my Justie and I just use my SW to absorb non-onslaught waves to push raids along.

SW is fun on CoC, but otherwise, I don't like playing it. I am just trying to keep it in the might ballpark of my other toons in case a future update makes it better. Much like the Mage was semi-terrible until 2.0.

Please don't say "it's your build". I have used builds/rotations by the top SW players in the game.

Finally, Venan, please give me an option to switch my second SW into a Spirit Justicar. Then at least I would play it.

I think at least part of this is caused by a dislike of the SW class, which is fine. Personally I don't like to play my Mage as I don't enjoy it as much as my main SW and Justicars (I'd recommend getting a Spirit Justi, really liking it).

I love my SW, but part of me has to agree about Death Wish. It feels like an exploit, something used for something it wasn't actually designed for (which was probably PvP). I use Shadow Veil a lot too and that feels like an exploit as well. That's just how I feel when playing with those abilities...doesn't mean I won't use them, so maybe it's a moot point.

My enjoyment of classes goes: Melee SW/Spirit Justicar/Melee Justicar/Mage/Poison SW (last one is because I haven't worked on it much and just prefer melee too much).

Also, I don't care how many threads get started regarding balance. I care whether it gets fixed, like most folk.