Book of Heroes

New raid

I know all top guilds are saying this... The new raid just sucks less payout takes more people to finish it than lob. But, i am however happy with the style 1. No os 2. I can finally use all my e if i show up late
But other than that the update was a bust quest line was cool enjoyed it but, that took me 2 days to finish... Which really sucks but o well what does a bowl of leafy greens know
It takes more people for the top guilds to finish than lob because they have people who can routinely generate 20-60k RPP by killing the lob onslaught segments. The new raid is a "normal" 2e raid that strikes me as being a reasonable length. Perhaps the top guilds could consider actually letting some mercs in their raids if they want to do it faster.
Thats the thing top guilds are greedy with power like my own cough*Raiden*cough but most top 15 guilds dont use mrcs in most their raids
If you're already consistently golding LoB, then HitM isn't really for you.

It's for guys like me at 17k might who want to be able to do more than just p1 LoB.
TurboPeaches wrote:If you're already consistently golding LoB, then HitM isn't really for you.

It's for guys like me at 17k might who want to be able to do more than just p1 LoB.

It is for top guilds - like Steerpike says, a handful of toons do half the work in LoB. With this raid, things are a lot more even, but it does mean that a single WM can only clear 25 waves with 50e rather than 200... So everyone needs thumbs on phones.
Steerpike wrote:It takes more people for the top guilds to finish than lob because they have people who can routinely generate 20-60k RPP by killing the lob onslaught segments. The new raid is a "normal" 2e raid that strikes me as being a reasonable length. Perhaps the top guilds could consider actually letting some mercs in their raids if they want to do it faster.

Firstly, this is a bad mentality to have :p If the stepping stone raid to ChV requires top guilds to use mercs, it's not much of a stepping stone for the rest, is it? :p

I think the only real issue with it is p3. The difficult:reward ratio is way off in my opinion. On both my 26k Justi and my 44k SWer, I'm killing p4 lob faster and easier than I'm killing this p3 bear... for much less reward.

Additionally, I was hoping the lesson would be learned from lob that if there's a significant difficulty change between beginning phases and last one... raids will completely bog down when the last phase starts, unless it drops something worthwhile.
Here are the problems I see:

1. P4 of LoB still has terrible silver payout.
2. The gold time on the HM is too low. My experience in different guilds is like 70% silver 30% bronze 0% gold and most of those silvers required burning. I heard about a guild who had 59 people and still bronzed it.
3. As Eric said "The difficult:reward ratio is way off". Could the bear drop refined essence regularly at least?
4. Once you have finished your tokens/valor, this raid as it is now is 100% pointless. As near as I can tell, VG has the same essence payout for an easier effort and KFS is far superior to both. Heck, the vile realm dungeons are superior due to boss drops.

Salad, plenty of top 15 guilds use mercs.

The guild I am in ran this new raid once. Then we said not impressed - we are leaving KFS and Helion on the schedule for now. Once we finish the Helion guild feat (hopefully this week), we will look at it again. However, we had some free time yesterday and were doing an unplanned raid - the vote was strongly in favor of KFS over HM.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Mar 30, 2014 11:07 am
EricM wrote:
Steerpike wrote:It takes more people for the top guilds to finish than lob because they have people who can routinely generate 20-60k RPP by killing the lob onslaught segments. The new raid is a "normal" 2e raid that strikes me as being a reasonable length. Perhaps the top guilds could consider actually letting some mercs in their raids if they want to do it faster.

Firstly, this is a bad mentality to have :p If the stepping stone raid to ChV requires top guilds to use mercs, it's not much of a stepping stone for the rest, is it? :p

I think the only real issue with it is p3. The difficult:reward ratio is way off in my opinion. On both my 26k Justi and my 44k SWer, I'm killing p4 lob faster and easier than I'm killing this p3 bear... for much less reward.

Additionally, I was hoping the lesson would be learned from lob that if there's a significant difficulty change between beginning phases and last one... raids will completely bog down when the last phase starts, unless it drops something worthwhile.

It's not a stepping stone raid to ChV. It's a stopgap that should've been in place before LoB (in the might chain). Onslaught raids are great, but I think two ChV raids should've been released with 2.0 - one onslaught, one regular.

They should check that HuM has drops that exceed both VG or KFS. Higher might reqs, higher essence/flux demands, more need for silver - these all demand that the raid gives more than the earlier ones. Otherwise, what's the point of doing them?

I don't have any problem with the boss difficulty, but that's at higher mights than the req.
I think more less viable model for new raid is when bear drops pure essence more than p4 lob. this way low level guilds could run it closed till p3 than open to high might mercs who may consider joining it for pure essence if for some reasons don't like (don't have awailable for mercing) lob.
higher chance for drop than p4 lob needed to keep it competitive because onslaught + p4 combined have pretty good chances, not talking about onslaught without p4 (which probably will remain my preference over mist raid even if mist raid will have double chance for pure essence drop vs p4 lob)

high level guilds could probably open early phases to low might mercs willing to hit for valor/ht and burn bear phase.
I just wanted to lend my guild's voice to the discussion. We all agree that we needed a non-onslaught raid that would be a bridge between VG and LoB. The first two phases in Hunted are great, but the last phase is out of reach for lower-might toons. So the lower-might toons are only hitting in phases 1 & 2. And the payout for the overall raid seems really low. I can't imagine what the payout is like for those toons who are only hitting in the first two phases.

The format of the raid is great, but it feels like the raid needs a few tweaks.