Apologies if many of these have been said before. Just tossing out a bunch of ideas.
Ingredient/Crafting Update (benches, drops)
One of many things that has always bugged me is being nickel and dimed for the crafting benches. I'd rather pay a flat rate of 100 gs and 200 gs and unlock those 2nd and 3rd benches permanently than having to keep shelling out increments of 5 and 10 just to keep refining essence. Likewise, I've always found potion-making tedious, long, and relatively unusable in terms of efficiency for the masses. I'd love to see more high tier raids drop ingredients for potions. It'd be simple enough to add the chance of an uncommon/rare potion item drop for each of the five major pots. Otherwise... when am I ever going to use a melee/magic resist potion? The time spent farming them greatly outweighs the benefits of using them, and I've never been a fan of wasted/pointless equipment/items.
Inventory Upgrade
Player inventories need a huge overhaul. For starters, why is there even a limit? A much easier way to handle things would be to have a section in the Equipment layout for gems. There would be a limit of being able to collect up to 20 of each gem of each tier (I could have 20 T1 haste, 20 T2 haste, etc.). I just don't see the purpose of imposing unnecessary limits. I earned the valor, why can't I spend it without losing something else? Likewise, there would be a potion section, consumable section, etc. Just drop the limit. Makes things alot more frustrating to use.
Portals Update
As it currently stands, the only use I can see for portals is to get a 33% discount off BM if you feel like farming ess/flux. Drop rates are nowhere near LoB, and difficulty of max incursion level makes it not really worth the bother to get there. I'd love to see a future quest that somehow incorporates the current portals, and upgrades them in some way (perhaps no limit on incursion levels... or an extension to lv 10, etc. Something to make portal burning worthwhile again.)
Use for materials
Not sure if this is a bug, but there are a ton of materials in my "Materials" Section that I just can't use... what is a "Drop of Putrid Ooze", "Ember of Enduring Fire", "Pristine Crystal Shard", "Vile Extracts", "Crystal Mantra Wurm Hide" even for? I can't use them for anything and they just bug me by existing.
Ht cap
So back when T4 and KV were the highest available valor/tier, I completely understand why ht needed a cap. But nowadays with T6/T16/ChV along with diminishing returns, stats get so high that does it really matter? I'm at 43.4% base haste with my shadow warrior (black number). If I wanted to raise my haste ht up to say... 3000... I'd gain something like 1.2% haste. Is that really so big a deal? It's one thing if no one had reached the ht cap, but by this point... there's quite a few of us that have hit the max and have plenty more ht available. Why not let us use it and enjoy the perks of having supported the game this long. By forcing a limit on us, all it does is make the game lose interest once we max. Unfortunately, any way you see it... valor and ht are virtually worthless in the long run. The only thing that really matters as a limiting factor is essence. Whether you only raid once of twice a day or constantly, whether you burn or not, you'll max out equipment and ht long long long before you max out enchants... and if this is intentional... why not raise the ht cap? Even if it's just to 2000... it'll be something to keep us long time players busy. Among all my suggestions, this one feels most overdue.
Guild loyalty cap
Couple things about guild loyalty. This was literally a fix for a problem that didn't exist. No one wanted it, but fine, I see the perks. But once again... why is there this limit? Make it unlimited. Make the loyalty required to go to the next level double each time and the rewards be +4 energy. I'd need 155,000 GL to get 70e under this system, and its' self-limiting due to the steep curve, while still providing players with the feeling of advancement. And on that same token, just drop the penalty for leaving. Allow players to build loyalty to multiple guilds. I understand it's "loyalty" but why can't I be loyal to say both Kingdom and Fizz at the same time? When did loyalty become decided by whether you visit other people and make friends outside your guild? I'd love to see implemented multiple loyalty levels... one per guild you participate in. It would be an excellent way to keep players raiding. Under the above system, one could raid when the knowledge that every action you take for your guild slowly helps improve your contribution. If you raid up through 155k GL, you'd be rewarded with 70e, etc.
Co-op mode
So raiding is getting really boring really fast. I know the primary purpose of the game is to raid. But much like how guilds and leaderboards were the big thing back with 1.4 or whenever they came out, and how pvp was last year's sorta big thing, we're long overdue for a new guild mechanic. There's only so long a player base can be kept busy with new raids. We need something new to keep our interest. How about a co-op pvp.
Every match is 3v3, instead of 1v1. Every match consists of 1 wm, 1 justi, 1 sw or just 3 random toons. Open up matchmaking to all levels/mights, with the only real matchmaking being total might. So that Team A and Team B couldn't differ by more than say 10%-15% in overall might. It'd change strategy up significantly since you'd now have to work together to defeat a group of players. Just an idea.
guild battles/global raids
Another idea is guild battles... either guild vs. guild challenges, or global dungeons/raids that the community as a whole could work together to accomplish.
Guild Challenges
Why not allow favors to continue being upgraded indefinitely? Building the Infirmary gave us +5% hp. Why not double the items required to upgrade the infirmary and give us an additional +1-3%. Likewise with other challenges. And once again, DONT MAKE A LIMIT. Allow guilds to specialize... choose what they want to focus on or spread evenly. If we want to focus on Dodge for example, why can't we kill a whole bunch of w/e it takes and be dodge masters. Right now... every guild is a carbon copy of every other. What does it mean to be Kingdom instead of Fizz? Outside of having to deal with Fero in one and DaK in the other, and their respective communities, the game side of guilds are identical. Yes the personality of every guild is different, but we have the same favors, the same specializations, etc. I'd love to see guild vs. guild customization. Something to set one guild apart from another. Favors were a great start but they stopped too soon. It's like everything is built to be short-term and then you hit an arbitrary, un-neccesary wall. It's almost as if the game tells you to stop playing once you reach lv. 33, t16 equip, a couple gems, and your guild unlocks all the raids and favors. I'm not necessarily asking for new content, but why not remove the limiters on existing content so that we atleast have something to work to long term. As of right now... all the work put into a guild like fizz or kotor or really any guild in the game means little to nothing. Power decays in 30 days, prestige is an utterly worthless stat that's affected solely by how much you raid and whether you can snag top 3 each week. It bothers me that there's no gain to be had from all this for the guild, only the individuals - this promotes selfishness on the part of members and puts the entire burden of keeping members selfless and working like a team on the shoulders of the guild leadership. Why not provide us with an incentive?
Spectate
Minor suggestion - I'd love a spectate mode just to hang with and watch speed runs and guild raids in guilds I'm not part of without physically having to join and lose loyalty.
Inconsistencies (valor rewards, item drops)
There are a lot of completionist inconsistencies that have bugged me for ages. Why did valor/ht rewards consistently increase for every raid/tier until ChV? Why does payout suddenly drop for HM? Even compared to VG or KFS... correct me if I'm wrong... but HM payout is on par with a sub-standard SV tier raid. Feels like a blatant money grab to force us to spend more gs obtaining valor... or so I thought... but then the first released raid was LoB... which allowed us such ridiculous kills/wave that it made valor obtaining a joke with the right class and build. Not that I'm complaining per se... but was there a logic behind those decisions? If I was looking for money from a company standpoint, I'd have released the non-onslaught raid first with a low payout, forced everyone to burn to gain valor quick... then released LoB after. Or... if money didn't matter and LoB was released first... what's stopping HM payout from say... equally VG or GK or even being higher since it's the next tier up?
Totally unrelated but why aren't their Captain's and Champion's Sigils? Why is the artwork for so many vile realm monsters so amazing but the vast majority never show up in raids?? If you're going through the trouble of making so much cool art, atleast allow us a way to revisit it within the main focus of the game.
Beastiary
I'd love a book detailing all the creatures I've met. Make it a collectable encyclopedia. 1 kill allows me to see the creature's name and picture. Every x kills unlocks a cool fact or stat about it, until you have access to their full stats. Another collectable, unlockable thing that would make Million Monster Massacring more bare-able.
New gems
Another low priority suggestion, but there's a chunk of players who've maxed out gems and are just storing ChV all day. I know a couple dozen with 100k+ stored already. Why not give us an advance on upgrading? We know one day there will be a new tier... that the exchange rate will be 20:1... so let's just pay the 60k Valor and upgrade gems/equip now :p If it feels weird to allow us to do that, make it a halfway... I spend 60k valor...Upgrade my T6 to a T6+, which would give me effective gem bonus of 6.5 instead of 6... and when T7 ever comes out... it auto-upgrades to T7. Likewise, it would be nice to have upgradable gems. Upon investing 2000 CV into a T4 gem... it becomes T5... or 2500 ChV into it to become T6...etc.
Upgrading raid tiers
One of my favorite things to do is revisit old raids. So why not allow us to upgrade the tier of old raids? We could run a ChV form of gg... Lv 33 goblins...same concept... 110 waves or w/e it is now... 3 hit for a nice little chv reward. Would make the monotony of running the same two raids a bit more fun. I'd love to fight a ChV-strength CoC or KFS.
Raid Cooldowns
What's the point of cooldowns? We had a point today where we had every CV and ChV raid on cooldown... feels like you're cutting your own profits by preventing us from continuing to raid or limiting our raiding...
Mailbox
We need a way to save mail. As guild leaders and officers, we're in charge of running things smoothly, but it's a pain to continually forward important mail to one's self just so it doesn't auto-delete. Also as an end-game guild... there's days we run upward of 15+ raids...including pre-raid and mid-raid notifications, that's a huge amount of mail going towards the 100 limit... meaning there's a huge chance of important mail being wiped out within two days of not being present.
Separate pve and pvp skills
It's especially frustrating to see pvp updates effect pve and vice versa. I'd love to see these two seperated into completely different aspects of the game.
Or a similar idea... it might be fun to change things up weekly. Every ability has a range and that range could change randomly. For example, what if Cleave's weapon damage had a range from 120-200%? Every week at reset, it'd randomly flip to somewhere between there. So every week, we'd each get a free respec, and every skill would change. It'd be fun to play around with the week's new skills... and provided the ranges were fairly done... every week would have a fun new build to mess around with. Some weeks... piercing/reflexive might be great... other weeks... garrote and neurotoxin might be the overpowered skills. If every week things switched up, it'd just add to the fun. PvP would be dynamic, raiding would be dynamic, and no class would ever be permanently overpowered.
~Eric
Ingredient/Crafting Update (benches, drops)
One of many things that has always bugged me is being nickel and dimed for the crafting benches. I'd rather pay a flat rate of 100 gs and 200 gs and unlock those 2nd and 3rd benches permanently than having to keep shelling out increments of 5 and 10 just to keep refining essence. Likewise, I've always found potion-making tedious, long, and relatively unusable in terms of efficiency for the masses. I'd love to see more high tier raids drop ingredients for potions. It'd be simple enough to add the chance of an uncommon/rare potion item drop for each of the five major pots. Otherwise... when am I ever going to use a melee/magic resist potion? The time spent farming them greatly outweighs the benefits of using them, and I've never been a fan of wasted/pointless equipment/items.
Inventory Upgrade
Player inventories need a huge overhaul. For starters, why is there even a limit? A much easier way to handle things would be to have a section in the Equipment layout for gems. There would be a limit of being able to collect up to 20 of each gem of each tier (I could have 20 T1 haste, 20 T2 haste, etc.). I just don't see the purpose of imposing unnecessary limits. I earned the valor, why can't I spend it without losing something else? Likewise, there would be a potion section, consumable section, etc. Just drop the limit. Makes things alot more frustrating to use.
Portals Update
As it currently stands, the only use I can see for portals is to get a 33% discount off BM if you feel like farming ess/flux. Drop rates are nowhere near LoB, and difficulty of max incursion level makes it not really worth the bother to get there. I'd love to see a future quest that somehow incorporates the current portals, and upgrades them in some way (perhaps no limit on incursion levels... or an extension to lv 10, etc. Something to make portal burning worthwhile again.)
Use for materials
Not sure if this is a bug, but there are a ton of materials in my "Materials" Section that I just can't use... what is a "Drop of Putrid Ooze", "Ember of Enduring Fire", "Pristine Crystal Shard", "Vile Extracts", "Crystal Mantra Wurm Hide" even for? I can't use them for anything and they just bug me by existing.
Ht cap
So back when T4 and KV were the highest available valor/tier, I completely understand why ht needed a cap. But nowadays with T6/T16/ChV along with diminishing returns, stats get so high that does it really matter? I'm at 43.4% base haste with my shadow warrior (black number). If I wanted to raise my haste ht up to say... 3000... I'd gain something like 1.2% haste. Is that really so big a deal? It's one thing if no one had reached the ht cap, but by this point... there's quite a few of us that have hit the max and have plenty more ht available. Why not let us use it and enjoy the perks of having supported the game this long. By forcing a limit on us, all it does is make the game lose interest once we max. Unfortunately, any way you see it... valor and ht are virtually worthless in the long run. The only thing that really matters as a limiting factor is essence. Whether you only raid once of twice a day or constantly, whether you burn or not, you'll max out equipment and ht long long long before you max out enchants... and if this is intentional... why not raise the ht cap? Even if it's just to 2000... it'll be something to keep us long time players busy. Among all my suggestions, this one feels most overdue.
Guild loyalty cap
Couple things about guild loyalty. This was literally a fix for a problem that didn't exist. No one wanted it, but fine, I see the perks. But once again... why is there this limit? Make it unlimited. Make the loyalty required to go to the next level double each time and the rewards be +4 energy. I'd need 155,000 GL to get 70e under this system, and its' self-limiting due to the steep curve, while still providing players with the feeling of advancement. And on that same token, just drop the penalty for leaving. Allow players to build loyalty to multiple guilds. I understand it's "loyalty" but why can't I be loyal to say both Kingdom and Fizz at the same time? When did loyalty become decided by whether you visit other people and make friends outside your guild? I'd love to see implemented multiple loyalty levels... one per guild you participate in. It would be an excellent way to keep players raiding. Under the above system, one could raid when the knowledge that every action you take for your guild slowly helps improve your contribution. If you raid up through 155k GL, you'd be rewarded with 70e, etc.
Co-op mode
So raiding is getting really boring really fast. I know the primary purpose of the game is to raid. But much like how guilds and leaderboards were the big thing back with 1.4 or whenever they came out, and how pvp was last year's sorta big thing, we're long overdue for a new guild mechanic. There's only so long a player base can be kept busy with new raids. We need something new to keep our interest. How about a co-op pvp.
Every match is 3v3, instead of 1v1. Every match consists of 1 wm, 1 justi, 1 sw or just 3 random toons. Open up matchmaking to all levels/mights, with the only real matchmaking being total might. So that Team A and Team B couldn't differ by more than say 10%-15% in overall might. It'd change strategy up significantly since you'd now have to work together to defeat a group of players. Just an idea.
guild battles/global raids
Another idea is guild battles... either guild vs. guild challenges, or global dungeons/raids that the community as a whole could work together to accomplish.
Guild Challenges
Why not allow favors to continue being upgraded indefinitely? Building the Infirmary gave us +5% hp. Why not double the items required to upgrade the infirmary and give us an additional +1-3%. Likewise with other challenges. And once again, DONT MAKE A LIMIT. Allow guilds to specialize... choose what they want to focus on or spread evenly. If we want to focus on Dodge for example, why can't we kill a whole bunch of w/e it takes and be dodge masters. Right now... every guild is a carbon copy of every other. What does it mean to be Kingdom instead of Fizz? Outside of having to deal with Fero in one and DaK in the other, and their respective communities, the game side of guilds are identical. Yes the personality of every guild is different, but we have the same favors, the same specializations, etc. I'd love to see guild vs. guild customization. Something to set one guild apart from another. Favors were a great start but they stopped too soon. It's like everything is built to be short-term and then you hit an arbitrary, un-neccesary wall. It's almost as if the game tells you to stop playing once you reach lv. 33, t16 equip, a couple gems, and your guild unlocks all the raids and favors. I'm not necessarily asking for new content, but why not remove the limiters on existing content so that we atleast have something to work to long term. As of right now... all the work put into a guild like fizz or kotor or really any guild in the game means little to nothing. Power decays in 30 days, prestige is an utterly worthless stat that's affected solely by how much you raid and whether you can snag top 3 each week. It bothers me that there's no gain to be had from all this for the guild, only the individuals - this promotes selfishness on the part of members and puts the entire burden of keeping members selfless and working like a team on the shoulders of the guild leadership. Why not provide us with an incentive?
Spectate
Minor suggestion - I'd love a spectate mode just to hang with and watch speed runs and guild raids in guilds I'm not part of without physically having to join and lose loyalty.
Inconsistencies (valor rewards, item drops)
There are a lot of completionist inconsistencies that have bugged me for ages. Why did valor/ht rewards consistently increase for every raid/tier until ChV? Why does payout suddenly drop for HM? Even compared to VG or KFS... correct me if I'm wrong... but HM payout is on par with a sub-standard SV tier raid. Feels like a blatant money grab to force us to spend more gs obtaining valor... or so I thought... but then the first released raid was LoB... which allowed us such ridiculous kills/wave that it made valor obtaining a joke with the right class and build. Not that I'm complaining per se... but was there a logic behind those decisions? If I was looking for money from a company standpoint, I'd have released the non-onslaught raid first with a low payout, forced everyone to burn to gain valor quick... then released LoB after. Or... if money didn't matter and LoB was released first... what's stopping HM payout from say... equally VG or GK or even being higher since it's the next tier up?
Totally unrelated but why aren't their Captain's and Champion's Sigils? Why is the artwork for so many vile realm monsters so amazing but the vast majority never show up in raids?? If you're going through the trouble of making so much cool art, atleast allow us a way to revisit it within the main focus of the game.
Beastiary
I'd love a book detailing all the creatures I've met. Make it a collectable encyclopedia. 1 kill allows me to see the creature's name and picture. Every x kills unlocks a cool fact or stat about it, until you have access to their full stats. Another collectable, unlockable thing that would make Million Monster Massacring more bare-able.
New gems
Another low priority suggestion, but there's a chunk of players who've maxed out gems and are just storing ChV all day. I know a couple dozen with 100k+ stored already. Why not give us an advance on upgrading? We know one day there will be a new tier... that the exchange rate will be 20:1... so let's just pay the 60k Valor and upgrade gems/equip now :p If it feels weird to allow us to do that, make it a halfway... I spend 60k valor...Upgrade my T6 to a T6+, which would give me effective gem bonus of 6.5 instead of 6... and when T7 ever comes out... it auto-upgrades to T7. Likewise, it would be nice to have upgradable gems. Upon investing 2000 CV into a T4 gem... it becomes T5... or 2500 ChV into it to become T6...etc.
Upgrading raid tiers
One of my favorite things to do is revisit old raids. So why not allow us to upgrade the tier of old raids? We could run a ChV form of gg... Lv 33 goblins...same concept... 110 waves or w/e it is now... 3 hit for a nice little chv reward. Would make the monotony of running the same two raids a bit more fun. I'd love to fight a ChV-strength CoC or KFS.
Raid Cooldowns
What's the point of cooldowns? We had a point today where we had every CV and ChV raid on cooldown... feels like you're cutting your own profits by preventing us from continuing to raid or limiting our raiding...
Mailbox
We need a way to save mail. As guild leaders and officers, we're in charge of running things smoothly, but it's a pain to continually forward important mail to one's self just so it doesn't auto-delete. Also as an end-game guild... there's days we run upward of 15+ raids...including pre-raid and mid-raid notifications, that's a huge amount of mail going towards the 100 limit... meaning there's a huge chance of important mail being wiped out within two days of not being present.
Separate pve and pvp skills
It's especially frustrating to see pvp updates effect pve and vice versa. I'd love to see these two seperated into completely different aspects of the game.
Or a similar idea... it might be fun to change things up weekly. Every ability has a range and that range could change randomly. For example, what if Cleave's weapon damage had a range from 120-200%? Every week at reset, it'd randomly flip to somewhere between there. So every week, we'd each get a free respec, and every skill would change. It'd be fun to play around with the week's new skills... and provided the ranges were fairly done... every week would have a fun new build to mess around with. Some weeks... piercing/reflexive might be great... other weeks... garrote and neurotoxin might be the overpowered skills. If every week things switched up, it'd just add to the fun. PvP would be dynamic, raiding would be dynamic, and no class would ever be permanently overpowered.
~Eric