Book of Heroes

Suggestion: Future Speedruns, Additional Category

OK, I bitched and moaned about the fact that the speedrun competition effectively excluded many guilds who were nearer the "target" membership for the lower-end raids. I've been yelled at before for complaining without offering a constructive option, so here we are...

Please note, this is based on illustrative numbers and examples only! I assume the same raids as the last speed run, with the same qualifiers for which raid a guild is eligible to compete in (ie you compete in the highest of the raids the guild has ever completed).

General:
For each raid, there are 2 wins available.
1. Overall speed of completion - exactly the same. Fastest time wins, no restrictions on guild membership, etc. If you want to pack a new / resurrected guild with 100 40k Might toons to take the speed run for Lockbolt, then go for it.
2. Best "Tier Score", calculated as below for all raids EXCEPT HitM. As the highest raid available to compete in, and intended for end-gamers, no such option is required for this one.

Raid Might Req
Lockbolt's Reign: 500
Attack At Dawn: 2950
Cursed Keep: 5300
Horde of the Goblin King: 11850


Tier Scoring OPTION 1: AVERAGE MIGHT
Each raid completed is given a "Tier Score" for the raid. This is an overall score for the raid based on time taken, modified by the Might of the GUILD MEMBER participants (ie not modified for mercs - as a guild has no direct control over the mercs that join).

Each raid has a base score of 1000 - (time taken in seconds). So a Lockbolt completed in 6:32 would have a score of (1000 - 332) = 668.
This base score is then modified based on the average Might of participants compared to the minimum Might req for the raid.
100-150% of min: +10%
150-200% of min: +0%
200-250% of min: -10%
250-300% of min: -20%
300%+ of min: -40%

So if that guild that completed LockBolt in 6:32 had an average Might of 650, their score would be modified to (668 * 1.1) = 735.
If the guild in question was an average Might of 20K, they would fall into the 5th category and suffer a -40% modifier to give a score of (668*0.6) = 401 for the same completion time.

The average Might would be calculated by taking each participating Guild Member's Might, and averaging (Total Might / Number of Participants). This is irrespective of the number of hits a player's toon makes. If it makes 1 hit or 100 hits, it contributes to the average in the same way. This would mean that any toons overpowered for the raid would have to contribute much more in terms of reducing the overall time to compensate for the impact they would have on the Guild's average Might.
Example #1: A Guild with an average Might of 800 across 30 toons raiding Lockbolt would have an average 800 Might for +0%. If they were joined by a 25k Might alt of one of the players, that average Might would increase to 1581, taking them into the -40% bracket, with the corresponding impact on their Tier Score.
Example #2: A Guild with an average Might of 14k across 80 toons raiding Lockbolt would have an average 14k Might for +10%. If they were joined by 5 more toons at 20k Might each, that average Might would increase to 14352, having no impact on the bracket in which they fall and their bonus. If they were instead joined by 20 toons at 35k each, the average Might would increase to 18200, losing their bonus by taking them into the +0% bracket. Those 20 high-Mighters would have to hit fast and often enough between them to justify losing that bonus.


Tier Scoring OPTION 2: PARTICIPANT MIGHT
Each raid completed is given a "Tier Score" for the raid. This is an overall score for the raid based on time taken, modified by the Might/Contribution of each participating GUILD MEMBER (ie not modified for mercs - as a Guild has no direct control over the mercs that join).

Each raid has a base score of RAID SCORE - (time taken in seconds * 10)
RAID SCORE is calculated for each participant as RPP modified by comparative Might.
Each toon has Might compared to the Raid Might Requirement:
100-150% of min: +10%
150-200% of min: +0%
200-250% of min: -10%
250-300% of min: -20%
300%+ of min: -40%

So a toon raiding GK (Might Req 11850) scoring 3475RPP with a 16k Might toon would contribute a RAID SCORE of (3475*1.1) = 3823. A toon scoring 3475 with a 36k Might toon would contribute a RAID SCORE of (3475*0.6) = 2085.
Any merc joining contributes RPP exactly as scored, no modifiers apply. This deliberately gives an incentive to recruiting high level mercs to hit.

Example #1
Imagine a guild with 80 players with exactly 15k Might each on GK, each hitting exactly 20 times 2725 RPP (except one toon hitting 24, 3325RPP) and completing in 10:00.
Their Tier Score would work out as:
(79 * (2725 * 1.1)) = 236,842
(1 * (3325 * 1.1)) = 3,658
TOTAL RAID SCORE = 240,500
TOTAL TIER SCORE = 240,500 - 6,000 = 234,500.

Example #2
Exactly the same scenrario as Example #1, except that now the extra 4 hits are completed by a toon who is 36k Might (over 300% of GK Might Req 11850).
Their Tier Score would work out as:
(79 * (2725 * 1.1)) = 236,842
(1 * (3325 * 0.6)) = 1,995
TOTAL RAID SCORE = 238,837
TOTAL TIER SCORE = 238,837 - 6,000 = 232,837.

Example #3
Again, the same scenario - except that the 80 toons have exactly 25k Might each (in 200-250% bracket), and the raid is completed in 6 mins.
Their Tier Score would work out as:
(79 * (2725 * 0.9)) = 193,787
(1 * (3325 * 0.9)) = 2,993
TOTAL RAID SCORE =
TOTAL TIER SCORE = 196,780 - 3600 = 193,180.


Summary:
In practice, a system like this would have the effect of allowing high-Might toons to continue to take part in Speed Runs the way they currently do, and take the Speed Run Trophy. PoF, for example, would still have taken the fastest time in CK, in exactly the same fashion. But there would be an additional award given to guilds that are nearer the "Target Might" for that same raid. These guilds would also have a vested interest to allow their lower-Might members to take part, rather than, as frequently happens at the moment, booting them for the duration.

Ideally, the "Tier Score" award would have equivalent rewards to the Speed Winners - and if a guild wins both, the raiding members get BOTH rewards. Hey, if they do that well, they deserve it.


Pitfalls I can see:
* It's not a straightforward system, and could have trouble being communicated (both options).
* When to measure Might? How to avoid people "gaming" the Might calc by taking all their gear off for their first hit (if calculated on entry) or for their last hit (if calculated at raid close)? (both options)
* Numbers will need tweaking... These are, as I stated at opening, illustrative of the concept only. (both options)
* Resistance from end-gamers who feel "penalised" for having higher-Might toons. (both options)
* Additional calculations needed on every qualifying raid, whether being run as a speedrun or not (Hence the required calculations being kept as simple as possible!). (both options)
* Deliberate tampering with raids - joining a guild running (e.g.) Lockbolt with a 40k toon and hitting once to wreck their score by pushing up their average Might. (option 1 only)


Benefits:
* ALL guilds can try and take part in speed runs - not just those with access to high-Might alts / friends.
* Additional participation will lead to greater excitement and buy-in, leading to greater revenue.
* Guilds will be forced to communicate more effectively internally. Many lower-end guilds at the moment don't even talk internally that much. This would encourage an internal discussion on strategy, and hopefully get people more involved - leading to a higher chance of retaining players for the long-term.
* Existing speed run structure - including guildhopping and resurrecting dead guilds is not affected.


Any and all comments, feedback and opinions welcomed - again, I emphasise, this isn't about stopping people do what they do at the moment, but about adding an additional layer to get more people involved and give the lower-level guilds and toons a valid reason to get involved in speedruns and find out for themselves just how much fun they can actually be!