Book of Heroes

New enchants · page 2

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri May 16, 2014 5:30 am
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Ilyana wrote:
FÈÁR_Thë_ÇhìLLëR wrote:Maybe off-hand enchants? Could help balance the power of two-handed weapons, just an idea.... :)

SW does after all need four more gems to get the same effects as the two-hand folk. ;)

SW (and anyone else using 1h & Shield) does after all have more flexibility with gem placement than the two-hand folk. ;)

Yeah that really makes up for having to get four extra gems. It's not going to make any difference because the effects are 2x/2x as opposed to 4x. Plus using a shield affects other abilities, I never use one in PvE.
Ilyana wrote:
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Ilyana wrote:

SW does after all need four more gems to get the same effects as the two-hand folk. ;)

SW (and anyone else using 1h & Shield) does after all have more flexibility with gem placement than the two-hand folk. ;)

Yeah that really makes up for having to get four extra gems. It's not going to make any difference because the effects are 2x/2x as opposed to 4x. Plus using a shield affects other abilities, I never use one in PvE.

Well that's subjective, just like the speed/hitting power decision to make between various weapons. Or whether it's worth spending GS /time & e farming for +dmg enchants when you get Armour Pen for free. Or the decision whether to use a shield! ;-)
It's not like 10k CapVal for t5s or 12k ChampVal for t6s (less if Commerce Elixirs are used) is exactly gonna take an extra year. 60 minimum-effort (no burning) HM raids would cover 4 t6s with change, which most folks could do in a couple weeks, tops.
(I run 1h Justi and SW alts, amd quite like being able to mix up gems a bit more, personally).

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun May 18, 2014 2:36 pm
2x/2x vs 4x is not subjective. SW need to get more gems, that's the point. That means four more gems per spec if your PvP gems are radically different.

Also, the free enchants aren't that good. Status resist is ok but I've found defence to be much better. Armour pen is not as good as having 1H damage.
Ilyana wrote:2x/2x vs 4x is not subjective. SW need to get more gems, that's the point. That means four more gems per spec if your PvP gems are radically different.

Also, the free enchants aren't that good. Status resist is ok but I've found defence to be much better. Armour pen is not as good as having 1H damage.

The "That's subjective" comment was aimed at whether an individual considers the gem flexibility worth it, rather than needing to get the extra gems, which is clearly a fact. I shoulda made that clearer.

As for free enchants, I used to use Defence exclusively, but LoB is starting to see my time for Status Resist increase... of my 4 toons, 3 have at least one piece with SR. One has 2 pieces. The Armour Pen v 1h (or 2h) damage example was intended to illustrate that a lot of people I've spoken to don't consider +damage to offer enough benefit over Armour Pen to be worth either the GS to buy outright or the time/energy to endlessly farm VG dungeon in the hope it'll drop. A few people have even said they prefer AP over +dmg, tho mainly for anti-Justi PvP. These were just examples of subjective opinions that will vary from onr player to the next.
Ilyana wrote:
FÈÁR_Thë_ÇhìLLëR wrote:Maybe off-hand enchants? Could help balance the power of two-handed weapons, just an idea.... :)[/quote
SW does after all need four more gems to get the same effects as the two-hand folk. ;)

Couldnt have said it better myself

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon May 19, 2014 9:38 am
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Ilyana wrote:2x/2x vs 4x is not subjective. SW need to get more gems, that's the point. That means four more gems per spec if your PvP gems are radically different.

Also, the free enchants aren't that good. Status resist is ok but I've found defence to be much better. Armour pen is not as good as having 1H damage.

The "That's subjective" comment was aimed at whether an individual considers the gem flexibility worth it, rather than needing to get the extra gems, which is clearly a fact. I shoulda made that clearer.

As for free enchants, I used to use Defence exclusively, but LoB is starting to see my time for Status Resist increase... of my 4 toons, 3 have at least one piece with SR. One has 2 pieces. The Armour Pen v 1h (or 2h) damage example was intended to illustrate that a lot of people I've spoken to don't consider +damage to offer enough benefit over Armour Pen to be worth either the GS to buy outright or the time/energy to endlessly farm VG dungeon in the hope it'll drop. A few people have even said they prefer AP over +dmg, tho mainly for anti-Justi PvP. These were just examples of subjective opinions that will vary from onr player to the next.

Lot of people I've spoken to said they either prefer (because they have it) or would rather have (because they haven't had it drop yet) the 1H and Physical (or nature ofc) enchant. This is from a SW perspective. Most of other classes either use or want 2H dmg. Defence is much better as it allows you to use death wish. I can see why status resist might be more interesting to Justicars but cleansing potions are so good, and defence so useful, that I'd never go back to SR.

I had armour pen for a long time too and couldn't see any real benefit in-game over the dmg enchants.
I run a SW in Death Wish with two Defense-enchanted pieces of equipment, and one that is Status Resist enchanted. One time, I ran my buddy's SW which had all three pieces of equipment enchanted with Status Resist, and it was a dramatic difference in the amount of damage he was taking when hit. It seemed like whenever his SW got hit, I immediately had to go into panic mode and heal as fast as possible because of all the damage it took. But with the Defense enchantment, I could afford to take a couple hits before going into panic mode.

My line of thinking is that every attack causes damage, but not every attack puts a debuff on your toon. So having more Defense than Status Resist made more sense to me. Of course, that goes out the window when you're thinking of PvP.