Book of Heroes

Warriors of The SPOON!- Elder Fury

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 14, 2014 10:36 am
Shekka,

It looks like Brutal Strike then Wound then repeat still works with 2h Axe 1.4 Speed and Elder Fury rank 1. Any weapon slower than 1.4 Speed (tested), and Elder Fury rank 2- 3 probably won't work (not spending 2 Respec Tokens to test).

Once they fix the Elder Fury Periodic Damage (DOT) bug, it should be a good ability. Until then I would not put it into any builds for Boss Onslaught. I am currently using it for my Justicar Single Spec, Vile Realm build. With Defend, the Knockback Resist 65% (vs 50% without Elder Fury 1) and Block 24% (vs 0% without Elder Fury 1) is awespoon when Farming to help save on silver coin (Block 50% reduction, Defend+ Block 75% reduction) and relieve boredom ("Hey! I Blocked").
Bj_Knows wrote:Shekka,

It looks like Brutal Strike then Wound then repeat still works with 2h Axe 1.4 Speed and Elder Fury rank 1. Any weapon slower than 1.4 Speed (tested), and Elder Fury rank 2- 3 probably won't work (not spending 2 Respec Tokens to test).

Yes with Fury rank 1 you can rotate between the two. Personally I don't have it in either of my builds as I don't see a point have having just one of it. Once you go higher you can no longer rotate between them as the timers become messed up. :(

Too bad they do because it would be very handy!
why stick to only 2? cleave rank 3 dmg per second even slightly better than wound. and with rend 3 boss rarely has less than 3 wound stacks regardless to attack kind.

and furys shortened attack durations means u land more hits till timer end. not talking about blocking knockback attack.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 14, 2014 4:08 pm
john12345 wrote:
and furys shortened attack durations means u land more hits till timer end. not talking about blocking knockback attack.

According to High Might Rating Justicars in SPOONS, because of the Elder Fury/ Bleed Bug currently cuts into your Legacy of Blades Raid Onslaught RPP:

Bug, Elder Fury Reduced DOT - RESOLVED

My Onslaught RPP is low enough to experiment before the fix.

This bug is fixed, just waiting next Client Update.
Bj_Knows wrote:
According to High Might Rating Justicars in SPOONS, because of the Elder Fury/ Bleed Bug currently cuts into your Legacy of Blades Raid Onslaught RPP:
my justie max rpp in lob with elders fury3 and both elixirs is 3750 (occasionally get 3600)
without elixirs is around 2400-2700, not sure about max

I'm curious how much rpp getting high might justicars in spoons without elders fury ;)
This is actually exactly what I do BJ.

Except I use EF2 and rotate Brutal/Wound. It's a lot tougher to get the haste value down right, but as long as it's between XX.05 and XX.18, it works. (Ex. My haste is at 56.15... I can rotate with EF2... If it goes up to 56.3....cd's prevent that from happening, etc.)

Personally, I find EF1 too slow/inefficient to compare to EF3 and rotating Brutal/Wound/Cleave, but EF2 and rotating Brutal/Wound does fairly decent.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu May 15, 2014 4:10 pm
john12345 wrote:
I'm curious how much rpp getting high might justicars in spoons without elders fury ;)

It's going to depend on your character. Both you and Shekka are right. The difference in Basic Attacks Damage Per Second (BADPS, a metric for DPS) is 2% between the two rotations (Note 1)

The difference in Bleed between the two (Due to Bug in Elder Fury rank 3) will be 4- 11% for 2H Sword and 3- 10.7% for 2H Axe (Higher your Melee Bonus, the worse the Bug), but this difference will be fixed with the next client update.
EricM wrote:
get the haste value down right, but as long as it's between XX.05 and XX.18, it works. (Ex. My haste is at 56.15... I can rotate with EF2... If it goes up to 56.3....cd's prevent that from happening, etc.)

Cool to know.

I just like Brutal Strike/ Wound because it is fast in Real World Speed. If Brutal Strike is in cool down, I use Wound, and vice versa. I have more trouble with Brutal/ Wound/ Cleave because Cleave is on a separate tool bar.

Note 1)

Attack, Damage Ratio Basic Attack, Speed Ratio Basic Attack
Brutal Strike 3, 160%, 1.00
Wound 3, 100%, 0.75
Cleave 3, 140%, 1.00

Attack Rotation A ( Brutal Strike/ Wound/ Repeat )
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
160%+ 100%= 260%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 0.75= 1.75
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
260% / 1.75= 148.57%

Attack Rotation B ( Brutal Strike/ Wound/ Cleave/ Repeat )
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
160%+ 100%+ 140%= 400%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 0.75+ 1.00= 2.75
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
400% / 2.75= 145.45%

Increase in Damage Per Second of Rotation A versus Rotation B
148.57 / 145.45= 2.14%
hmm interesting approach taking dmg per sec of whole rotation rather than cleave vs wound.
but what about rotation a is without elders fury while b is with? while dmg not affected by elders fury, weapon speed does. e.g 100% weapon speed in seconds of rotation b is shorter than 100% of a.
I think more than 2% (lol too lazy to go and check elders fury description)
(I ignored bleeding dot effects here, they probably less influence than regular weapon dmg)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri May 16, 2014 11:38 am
john12345 wrote:
while dmg not affected by elders fury, weapon speed does. e.g 100% weapon speed in seconds of rotation b is shorter than 100% of a.
I think more than 2% (lol too lazy to go and check elders fury description)
(I ignored bleeding dot effects here, they probably less influence than regular weapon dmg)

Short Answer
Once the next client update comes out, it will fix the second Elder Fury Bug. Then there will not be a huge difference between 2h Justicars with Elder Fury, and those without. This may, or may not, be true for Justicars using an Elixir of Speed.

Long Answer
This Topic originated from a discussion with Shekka before Venan fixed the first Elder Fury Bug (Note 1), which *did* impact direct damage. Originally Elder Fury 2 converted a 2h Axe into a 2h Sword as far as the client cared. Shekka noticed a drop off in Onslaught RPP with his 2h Axe due to Rune damage (based off Weapon Speed, Note 2), direct damage (based off Weapon Speed) and Periodic Damage (DOT, based on Weapon Speed). Venan fixed it for Rune damage and direct damage but not DOT. DOT will be fixed in the next client update.

Boss Onslaught uses Combat Encounter/ Loot Rolls (CELR or waves) so Basic Attack Damage Per Second (BADPS) is useful for comparing rotations, but in reality, the last direct damage, or DOT, of a CELR will have wasted damage.

Once Venan fixes the second Elder Fury Bug, the best way to decide is to test without Elder Fury for a week, then a week each for Elder Fury rank 1 to 3. During the month, do not change your Might Rating, Tomes or Gear. Whichever of the four gives you the best Onslaught RPP is the one to go with.

Note 1)
Way more complicated, search Resolved Bug Forum if you care.

Note 2)
Runes are almost all Bonus Damage. DOT get Bonus Damage. Other direct damage attacks get Bonus Damage (Melee or Magic). Except for 1h Sword 1.0 Speed, Bonus Damage is not listed on your character, instead it is the listed Bonus Damage times a Weapon's Speed. So a 2h Sword, or 2h Staff, gets +30% to the listed Bonus Damage. Since this is added to Weapon Damage, the +30% for 2h Sword and +40% for 2h Axe gets added before multiplying for 2h Damage Enchant, Physical Damage Enchant, Frenzy, Crit Power, Vengeance, etc. Because it is based off Bonus Damage, the more Melee Gems you have, the larger the affect of the two bugs.