Book of Heroes

"Emergency" merc slots

Xeryn_has_Original_Leather_Tutu

Sat May 17, 2014 1:55 pm
I have noticed that in raids that reach silver or bronze rewards, some mercs will abandon raids and have toons sitting at low rpp. I know that it has beeen suggested that GMs get the power to kick mercs from a raid. I would propose, however, that guilds get to open more merc slots as they progress through reward levels, e.g. when a guild reaches silver in valus, they get to open, say, 5 more merc slots. When they reach bronze, they get 5 or 10 more. Then, in the last 30 min, a few more open up. This, I think, would greatly reduce the amount of failed raids, and give mercs that have been putting e in, and perhaps spending gs as well, a better chance of getting rewards from raids gone south.
Or you could allow officers to spend GS to open more merc slots... on a non-linear scale to discourage too much imbalance...
1GS for 16th slot (11th slot for SqV)
3GS for 17th slot
6GS for 18th slot
10GS for 19th slot
Etc...

Shë_Wølf_Ãrî

Sun May 18, 2014 3:19 pm
Or merc spots open at silver and bronze to replace the low hitters under a certain rpp. And maybe a gs offer to open more as you reach the last half of bronz
I thinl that there shpuld be a minimum rpp for raids for mercs if you dont have said rpp at ph1 ph2 ect. You get booted
Ilyana wrote:Or just remove merc caps entirely. Sorted.
That is just overpowered, may I add that the closest idea to fair was the one before this one. But I think the best way to solve this is to make the payout per RPP sloped. so if someone with 1000 RPP got 100 valor then someone with 7500 (neither player is getting a top 3 bonus) would get more like 1125. Exponential growth if I may, with a small 1.x exponent. I know this is the point of top 3 but there is the issue of getting stuck in a raid with three people who are hitting like 17000 RPP. And for the second part of my solution, I think that you should be allowed to kick a merc after they have been there for atleast 10 minutes, and you lose all that they have done and go back another half of what they have done. If you boot a merc on three different occasions they cannot join your raids for two months(this number is of course not a solid "must be" thing it is just an idea).
I forget who proposed the system in a different thread, but the idea of having a "merc rating" appeals to me. Below is one way to calculate and use the rating.

Calculating the rating:
A rating of zero would be the ideal merc: a merc gets a negative "point" for failing to hit an expected number of times. The expected number of times should be the number of minutes the raid lasts from the time the merc joined, divided by 5 and rounded down. So if a merc joins a raid 13 minutes before it ends, the merc should have hit at least twice (13/5 = 2.6, rounds down to 2), and if a merc joins a raid 1.5 hours before it ends, the merc should have hit 18 times (90/5 = 18). The mercs rating becomes the number of negative points (in last 30 days) divided by raids participated in (in last 30 days). Merc ratings could be calculated once per day, so someone who has a bad merc outing would have a chance to do some repair before the rating gets hit too hard.

Calculating tolerance:
Instead of GM's choosing a raid tolerance (who wouldn't always choose the highest tolerance), higher tier raids would have higher expectations. SqV raids would allow mercs with ratings as low as -10. SoV raids would allow mercs with ratings as low as -7. KV would allow -5, CapV would allow -3, and ChV would allow -1. If a merc gets a bad rating through an occasional real life event, the rating can be repaired mercking in lower tier raids (or by waiting a few days).

GG raids should probably not count, since many run this raid for large ties with few hits.
I think the smallest change that would be generally acceptable is that if you hit bronze time, you can get up to 99 mercs.