Book of Heroes

May 20th, 2014 - Information Overload · page 4

Bj_Knows

ModeratorWed May 21, 2014 1:33 pm
DaK_ wrote:Is there anything being done to avoid abuse of the wager system? That is to say I (having loads of chv/cv I can no longer use) wager 30,000 chv against a guildie and unequip half my gear so I can essentially transfer that to them?

Sorry for anyone who was planning this but it's just a feature me and many many others do not want to see implemented

MY PERSONAL OPINION

I had the same first thought.

My second thought was "I like Space Miner and BoH, I should at least *let Venan try* before I comment".

I can think of 4 mechanisms off the top of my head (League Pot Limit, Might Pot Limit, Silver Only, Points Only). Venan is unlikely to keep an abusive system in place for long.

Darkhorse

Site AdminWed May 21, 2014 2:41 pm
DaK_ wrote:Is there anything being done to avoid abuse of the wager system? That is to say I (having loads of chv/cv I can no longer use) wager 30,000 chv against a guildie and unequip half my gear so I can essentially transfer that to them?

Sorry for anyone who was planning this but it's just a feature me and many many others do not want to see implemented

Currently the wager system only works with wagers of Gold Shields in certain denominations. This is for the exact reason you mentioned (potential abuse of other currencies).
Darkhorse wrote:
DaK_ wrote:Is there anything being done to avoid abuse of the wager system? That is to say I (having loads of chv/cv I can no longer use) wager 30,000 chv against a guildie and unequip half my gear so I can essentially transfer that to them?

Sorry for anyone who was planning this but it's just a feature me and many many others do not want to see implemented

Currently the wager system only works with wagers of Gold Shields in certain denominations. This is for the exact reason you mentioned (potential abuse of other currencies).


Ooooooo! Gold shield wagers. That's a terrific idea!
Gold shield wagers?
Sounds like on line gambling.
Why don't you guys just make a separate app for that.
Well, at least no one has to offer gift cards. Now it's just a simple pvp transfer.
Poppa wrote:Gold shield wagers?
Sounds like on line gambling.
Why don't you guys just make a separate app for that.
Well, at least no one has to offer gift cards. Now it's just a simple pvp transfer.

Online gambling was my first thought too. I'm sure Venan have had legal teams examine this for legislative compliance in every country in which the app is available, but wagering a virtual currency (primarily) purchased with $ on playing against others isn't that far from online poker where you wager a virtual currency (chips) primarily purchased with $ on playing against others... which requires gambling licences and age restrictions.
I don't say this to be a killjoy, but rather because I would really prefer that BOH doesn't fall foul of legislative issues and end up draining money to lawyers, as this would impede development and threaten the app itself. Remember that (non-US based) online poker site that got taken down by a judge in Kentucky because it allowed residents to play, thus bteaking state laws? Europe is already looking at clamping down on Freemium games on the basis of IAP costs, this could potentially add fuel to that case.

Although I personally give less of a hoot about PvP than even Derrin, it's nice to see that some work's been done on it, and I hope it's a success. I'm very much looking forward to seeing the weekly leaderboard activity, as this will be the first time pvp activity information will have been made available.

Regards storage, I fully appreciate the technical difficulty that would be involved in expanding this, but perhaps it's time to look at something which has been suggested numerous times - additional separate storage at My House. As a new, separate record, this would circumvent many of those and appease players who will need that space, esp those who will be buying the additional specs.

Finally... Thanks for the work you've put in. I'm very happy to see indications of further expansions in the future :-)
There's already kinda gambling with the gold shield lockbox.

I can see this making real-world trading GS purchases easier. Then again, the person would have to farm GS in another way (like CoC) or lose money trying to sell GS to someone. UNLESS trading for another game currency.
Rather than login and buy GS (say like the trading for another game currency), the person could just go into PVP and lose on purpose to transfer the GS.
The big difference between the on-line gambling casinos and BoH PvP wagering:

In the on-line gambling sites, it is possible to "cash-out", and convert chips into real-world currency.

One cannot "cash-out" gold shields for Dollars, Euros, Yen, Rupees, or Imperial Credits.

(I just checked eBay, and no one is selling BoH accounts with high-level or high-GS toons... anyone want to make me an offer?).
NikoNarf_1 wrote:The big difference between the on-line gambling casinos and BoH PvP wagering:

In the on-line gambling sites, it is possible to "cash-out", and convert chips into real-world currency.

One cannot "cash-out" gold shields for Dollars, Euros, Yen, Rupees, or Imperial Credits.

Truth, that. On the other hand, the winnings can be spent on goods, albeit virtual goods within the game environment, that have a nominal cash value.
You're also making the big assumption that laws make any kind of logical sense to normal human beings... ;-)

I'm not saying it will fall foul of a legality, just that I hope Venan have thoroughly checked this. This seems like the sort of thing that lawyers who charge by the hour would love...
Darkhorse wrote:Heroes!
    PvP Leagues and Ratings
  • Leaderboards and rankings in PvP will now use a fully featured modified ELO system for rankings.
  • Players will have a public rating for each season.
  • Players will move up and down the ranks, moving them into other leagues. These leagues will have an impact on the rewards that can be earned from PvP.

ELO is a great way to do this. I'm sure it'll take some trial and error to make work properly, but it'd be nice if variables were set so there was a cap on max points winnable/losable at a time. It'd be unfortunate to drop 200+ points due to an unlucky 2-3 losses to the same player. One other concern with ELO would be the same concern that's currently there... is there anything in place to prevent rank camping? Meaning, is there anything stopping a player from getting a couple lucky wins in a row and then just stopping pvp for the week to keep their rating (kinda like the current performance charts) and winning rewards? I know currently at high might, 80-85% of my matches are against the same 5-6 players.
Darkhorse wrote:
    All new PvP rewards
  • Gear earned in the Coliseum will be balanced for PvP and have a PvP specific stat, which takes effect only when facing other players.
  • Every week, based on their standings and performance, players will earn special Medals that can be used to get items that are completely unique.
  • Every season (approximately 3 months) will also have unique rewards to earn that show off how well you did.

I suppose time will really tell... but with pvp... are standings and performance going to change that significantly from week to week? It's not like pve where massive time/gs are needed for a top five run. If me or purao win 75-80% of our matches this week, we're not going to suddenly only win 40% next week. I know it doesn't need to be said, but if unique rewards are being offered, balance should be very close to perfect, else there will be disproportionate representation among the top. Good thing is with ELO rankings, it'll be very easy to tell.

Finally, I have heard concerns among wardrobe collectors regarding unique equipment for pvp excellence potentially ruining their shot at a complete wardrobe. Just things to keep in mind.

You guys have a fairly decent track record with updates, and I'm sure this one will be fine as well, but can't hurt to toss my two cents out before it comes out in the slim chance it is something you haven't beat to death in discussion.

Outside that, great work venan! Keep it up! Updates look like they're going to be pretty awesome!