It would be nice if the gm or person who starts a raid could remove people that just hit a couple times or not at all from the raid thus opening the spot for a real raider
Raid killers
I can see that you are new to these forums but this is already an active topic. Stinkbugging eliminator Stinkbugging eliminator
One of if not the biggest thing I would institute. Not sure why they haven't gave the raid initiator the power to kick.
DogInc wrote:One of if not the biggest thing I would institute. Not sure why they haven't gave the raid initiator the power to kick.
Been there done that. There are a completely different set of problems which we have covered on the forum previously with that system. The biggest and nastiest flame war in guild and the board was caused by kicking.
You don't want to hear this, but if your guild's raid is in trouble over a couple of skunk mercs, then your guild has bigger problems.
B4Play wrote:Truth.comDogInc wrote:One of if not the biggest thing I would institute. Not sure why they haven't gave the raid initiator the power to kick.
Been there done that. There are a completely different set of problems which we have covered on the forum previously with that system. The biggest and nastiest flame war in guild and the board was caused by kicking.
You don't want to hear this, but if your guild's raid is in trouble over a couple of skunk mercs, then your guild has bigger problems.
What about a self-kick option... Just when you enter a raid ready to empty your e, something comes up after two hits. If one could withdraw, forfeiting rewards, and free the slot for another merc, this might be appreciated. There are cases where a 12k might toon enters a KFS for the first time, and realizes the raid is too tough... Withdraw and give up your slot.
To avoid merc cap abuse, a withdrawn toon must have completed no more than 500 RPP and cannot reenter the same raid.
To avoid merc cap abuse, a withdrawn toon must have completed no more than 500 RPP and cannot reenter the same raid.
NikoNarf_1 wrote:What about a self-kick option... Just when you enter a raid ready to empty your e, something comes up after two hits. If one could withdraw, forfeiting rewards, and free the slot for another merc, this might be appreciated. There are cases where a 12k might toon enters a KFS for the first time, and realizes the raid is too tough... Withdraw and give up your slot.
To avoid merc cap abuse, a withdrawn toon must have completed no more than 500 RPP and cannot reenter the same raid.
good solution. I mean sometimes skunks are skunks but most of the time it's an honest mistake and I think most mercs would do the honorable thing.
scurvynaive wrote:NikoNarf_1 wrote:What about a self-kick option... Just when you enter a raid ready to empty your e, something comes up after two hits. If one could withdraw, forfeiting rewards, and free the slot for another merc, this might be appreciated. There are cases where a 12k might toon enters a KFS for the first time, and realizes the raid is too tough... Withdraw and give up your slot.
To avoid merc cap abuse, a withdrawn toon must have completed no more than 500 RPP and cannot reenter the same raid.
good solution. I mean sometimes skunks are skunks but most of the time it's an honest mistake and I think most mercs would do the honorable thing.
Uh huh...I don't think that's true and most people won't buy it. This happens too often in too many guilds for it to be a mistake. I've said it many times before, take the merc cap away. It solves the problem without having to bring in a more controversial option. That said I'd have no problem kicking mercs that sit below certain rpp numbers, if you join a raid then you can jolly well hit in it. Otherwise you can't complain if you're removed.
Lets cut some guilds that may not be enjoying good times some slack, instead of telling them that if they care about a couple of skunk mercs they suck.
B4Play wrote:DogInc wrote:One of if not the biggest thing I would institute. Not sure why they haven't gave the raid initiator the power to kick.
Been there done that. There are a completely different set of problems which we have covered on the forum previously with that system. The biggest and nastiest flame war in guild and the board was caused by kicking.
You don't want to hear this, but if your guild's raid is in trouble over a couple of skunk mercs, then your guild has bigger problems.
Quoted for truth!
B4Play wrote:DogInc wrote:One of if not the biggest thing I would institute. Not sure why they haven't gave the raid initiator the power to kick.
Been there done that. There are a completely different set of problems which we have covered on the forum previously with that system. The biggest and nastiest flame war in guild and the board was caused by kicking.
You don't want to hear this, but if your guild's raid is in trouble over a couple of skunk mercs, then your guild has bigger problems.
It's quite clear when a merc is skunking your raid (whether intentionally or not). Someone sitting at 1-5 hits is clearly not in the raid to contribute to it...it really doesn't matter if their batter just died, they got a call or whatever. The raid organisers should have some way to kick these mercs OR adjust the merc numbers to compensate.
However, opening more slots increases the risk of more skunk mercs, so a kick function in limited circumstances is fair. The guild should be able to set the bar (eg half a bar in the first phase, or minimum 10 hits, or whatever they desire).
Again, this does affect smaller guilds more than say those in the top 15 power and especially in lower raids where the number of slots is limited.