Book of Heroes

Spell Dodge

Figured I'd go ahead and make a topic on this.

For the sake of discussion, would combining spell dodge and regular dodge into one "Dodge" have significant balance repercussions? I've always been kind of at a loss as to why spell dodge even exists.

From an intuitive perspective, If I "block" an attack, I understand that my shield may only absorb a portion of the blow, and therefore I take the remainder as damage. I understand that if I "resist" a debuff, my mental fortitude or w/e was strong enough that I was able to shrug off the status. I even understand that when I "dodge" a melee attack, I happened to avoid the blow completely, and therefore didn't take damage. So then... what exactly happens on a "spell dodge"? I take damage... and am still affected by the debuff... doesn't sound like much of a dodge... if anything, sounds more like a spell block, except its not since the block would atleast resist the debuff.

So... part suggestion/part question/part discussion... can we just remove spell dodge completely? From a balance perspective, it would make wm vs. sw in pvp slightly more balanced. It's a weird feeling going through a pvp fight... dodging and blocking every attack (with full defense enchant), but still losing due to sheer damage output (Both enemy and I have same # of damage gems). Feels like well... if my dodge's were completely dodged, then maybe there wouldn't be the need for radical balance changes down the road. That said, this is a very biased argument but I've always been curious about that ;)

Regarding spirit justis and poison walkers... Smite can't be blocked in the first place, thereby bypassing the whole spell dodge problem. Poison walkers would be put at a further disadvantage than they are now though with the loss of spell dodge.
The WM damage is quite high with fractures and smoldering armor, knocking a clear 30% off defenses and then hurting resists. That 30% can take you into the negatives.

I guess it's where there's no real true way to "dodge" magic as there is melee. And when you get up in the higher mights, dodge of 35% is possible with justi and wm (I know walkers have a tiny bit more, which is felt harder when we get slowed since we lose a larger percentage since our base is higher)
Hmm.

I think its better to let the spell dodge. If there is no spell dodge, the balance will be changed and it can be too much difficult for wm. And same thing for sw poison.

But especially for a wm because if dodge spell is like a dodge. U just need to put 60% dodge and wm can never touch you and cant put any debuff. Just too simple for a sw.

Dont forget calltrops and smoke bomb cant be blocked or dodged too. Its a little unfair to put all the spell dodgable but not smoke bomb or calltrops.

Sw physical will be too much strong. So its better to change anything.
Ceka wrote:Hmm.

I think its better to let the spell dodge. If there is no spell dodge, the balance will be changed and it can be too much difficult for wm. And same thing for sw poison.

But especially for a wm because if dodge spell is like a dodge. U just need to put 60% dodge and wm can never touch you and cant put any debuff. Just too simple for a sw.

Dont forget calltrops and smoke bomb cant be blocked or dodged too. Its a little unfair to put all the spell dodgable but not smoke bomb or calltrops.

Sw physical will be too much strong. So its better to change anything.

What if caltrops and smoke were then made blockable/dodgeable?
Dont know. But its only 2 Skills versus all skill wm....

But its better to change anything from what i see. Personally i win already a lot against wm with my sw. Why nerf wm again? If they put dodge instead of dodge spell... Wm will be too easy for me and for another sw. I prefer this close battle!
Haha, yeah Wm is the weakest PvP class. They need their hand held. They typically do low damage and have low health.