Book of Heroes

Justicar Boss Rotation Comparison- 2h Axe (R= Expert+)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu May 29, 2014 9:31 am
Subject
Justicar Boss Rotation Comparision

Rating: Expert and up

Attack, Damage Ratio Basic Attack, With Frenzy 3/ Wrath 3, Speed Ratio Basic Attack
Brutal Strike 3, 160%, 208%, 1.00
Wound 3, 100%, 130%, 0.75
Cleave 3, 140%, 182%, 1.00
Smite 3, 200%, 290%, 1.00

Note: Results will vary depending on Monster’s Spirit/ Physical Mitigation, Knockback Resist, Status Resist, Dodge and character’s Enchants

2h Axe+ Elder Fury 1= 1.35 Speed
2h Axe+ Elder Fury 3= 1.25 Speed
1.35 / 1.25= 8%

Attack Rotation Wound (Bleed Stack 1+ Frenzy 3 then Brutal Strike/ Wound/ Repeat )
Melee, with Magic, 2h Axe Justicar, Single Spec, Vile Realm
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
208%+ 130%= 338%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 0.75= 1.75
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
338% / 1.75= 193.14%
Bleed Chances
1+ 2= 3
Bleed Chances per Second of Rotation
3 / 1.75= 1.71
Knockback Chances
1+ 0= 1
Knockback Chances per Second of Rotation
1 / 1.75= 0.5714

Attack Rotation Smite
(Bleed Stack 1+ Frenzy & Wrath Stack 3 then Brutal Strike/ Cleave/ Brutal Strike/ Smite/ Repeat)
Melee, wtih Smite, 2h Axe Justicar, Single Spec, Vile Realm
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
208%+ 182%+ 208%+ 290%= 888%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 1.00+ 1.00+ 1.00= 4.00
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
888% / 4.00= 222%
Bleed Chances
1+ 1+ 1+ 0= 3
Bleed Chances per Second of Rotation
3 / 4 = 0.75
Wrath Chances
0+ 0+ 0+ 1= 1
Wrath Chances per Second of Rotation
1 / 4 = 0.25
Knockback Chances
1+ 0+ 1+ 0= 2
Knockback Chances per Second of Rotation
2 / 4.00= 0.5000


Increase in Damage Per Second of Smite Rotation versus Wound Rotation
(222% * 1.08 for Elder Fury +2 )/ 193.14= 24%

Increase in Bleed Chances per Second of Wound Rotation
1.71 / 0.75= 228%

Wrath 3 Chances per Second of Smite Rotation
Versus
Bleed 1 Chances per Second of Wound Rotation
1.71 * 3 Wrath Stack / 0.25 * 1 Bleed Stack= 2052%

It will take 228% longer with Smite rotation to get Bleed Stack 1 and trigger Frenzy 3 for maximum physical damage (including Backswing). It will also take 228% longer with Smite rotation to get Bleed Stack 3 and trigger maximum Bleed damage.

I will take 2052% longer with Smite rotation to get Wrath Stack 3, versus Bleed Stack 1 rotation, and maximize Basic Attack Damage Per Second.

The Smite rotation takes a very long time to increase damage (Bleed 1) and even longer to maximize damage (Wrath 3). It will also require choosing between 1 Spirit / 2 Physical Damage Enchants and 2 Spirit/ 1 Physical Damage Enchants. Spirit Damage Enchants will not increase Bleed damage.

The Wound rotation is very speedy to maximize damage (Bleed 1). It is also good against high Resist Bosses. 3 Physical Damage Enchants will increase damage of all attacks in the rotation and Bleed damage.

Note: Wound rotation has an increase of 14% in Knockback chances. If you are running Elixir of Speed (Haste 15%), Haste 10% Potion and 2h Axe, this can translate an insane amount of knockback since knockback is based on Weapon Speed not actual attack speed. Sedalb fo Ecnirp (Prince) has Burst of Speed (Knockback Resist 100%), suggesting 2h Sword would get better RPP per 10 Energy than 2h Axe, though 2h Axe will probably be better in an RPP Race.

Check, give up Juggernaut 2 for Elder Fury 3

Attack Rotation Physical ( Brutal Strike/ Wound/ Cleave/ Repeat )
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
208%+ 130%+ 182%= 520%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 0.75+ 1.00= 2.75
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
520% / 2.75= 189.09%
Knockback Chances
1+ 0+ 0= 1
Knockback Chances per Second of Rotation
1 / 2.75= 0.3636

Wound rotation has a 57.15% increase in knockback over Physical rotation. See Elixir & Potion notation above.

Increase in Damage Per Second of Smite Rotation versus Physical Rotation
222% / 189.09%= 17.4%

Check With Bleed 1 & Wrath 0

Attack Rotation Smite
(Bleed Stack 1+ Frenzy & Wrath Stack 0 then Brutal Strike/ Cleave/ Brutal Strike/ Smite/ Repeat)
Damage Ratio Basic Attack
208%+ 182%+ 208%+ 200%= 798%
Speed Ratio Basic Attack
1.00+ 1.00+ 1.00+ 1.00= 4.00
Basic Attack Per Second of Rotation
798% / 4.00= 199.5%

Increase in Damage Per Second of Smite Rotation versus Physical Rotation
199.5% / 189.09%= 5.5%

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu May 29, 2014 10:52 am
This topic is about 2h Axe rotations.

The main difference between Sword and Axe are

Axe does more direct damage with Runes,
Axe does more Periodic Damage (DOT),
Axe gains more Basic Attack Damage Per Second (a DPS metric) from fixed speed attacks,
Axe has faster Kills Per Minute.

Sword has more consistent damage (casting time, less wasted damage per Combat Encounter/ Loot Roll [CELR or wave], damage range),
Sword rolls for more Critical Hits,
Sword has more RPP per 10 Energy in Boss Onslaught.

To see some additional comparisions of 2h Axe versus 2h Sword see:
Melee, wtih Smite, 2h Axe Justicar, Single Spec, Vile Realm
Hi BJ
Thanks for doing that analysis, will take me some time to think it all through. A few thoughts:
- I think LoB p2-3 bosses have quite high resists, so Wrath has a much bigger effect. Eg. If resist is 50%, 3 stacks of wrath reduce it to 5% and Smite damage is nearly doubled (95/50 instead of 145/100). That is my experience, I have all phys damage enchants, melee gems equipped (just enough magic to reach soft cap), but Smite with 3 stacks of wrath still does as much damage as BS. I concentrate on phys damage enchants to maximise bleed DoT.
EDIT: actually none of the PvE bosses seem to have high resist. However smite still does a lot of damage (with no dodge/block possible).
- With the BS/Cleave/BS/Smite/BS rotation, you can also replace Cleave with Radiant Light 3 and Seismic Slash in the same time. Not every time due to SS cd, but sometimes (more if you use HW as well). RL+SS does as much damage as Cl but also can stack a wrath and does a knockback. Similarly for RL+Stun.
- Another advantage of Smite is that it can't be dodged. Does happen occasionally in LoB.

On the other hand BS/Wound/BS is a really simple rotation, for kills per minute of real time it probably can't be beaten. Just a pain that you have to sacrifice a level or two of EF and use axe to be able to do it.