I would love to see SW get a physical based AOE skill (call it like Blade Storm or something). At the moment, physical SW is the only class/spec that doesn't give a decent aoe. And no sticky grenade doesnt count, I mean something that you can open with against groups like Justi's Cleave or War Mages... like 5 of them.
Shadow Walker Aoe
The phys sw workaround for this is assassinate. For lower raids, basic hits two enemies, and assassinate will proc to kill the third. It's not as fast as AOEs, but it still works reasonably well.
To me, the melee SW on (non-CoC) mobs is pure torture and I just won't do it.
B4Play wrote:To me, the melee SW on (non-CoC) mobs is pure torture and I just won't do it.
You need Death Wish... I carve up with a melee SW. As long as they don't hit me back, that is!! :p
Yes, these are valid points; though Death Wish applies for Nature SWs also.
It doesn't take away from the initial purpose of the post, which is to point out that Melee SW is the only class without a reliable AoE. Assassinate is okay, but on later areas can't hit all 3 opponents using assassinate. Pretty much just CoC, because at 33 you can 1+2 shot the first two and assassinate the third. But having an AoE to soften up the badguys in, say, HM or LoB's non onslaught rounds (or hell, p4) would be awesome.
It doesn't take away from the initial purpose of the post, which is to point out that Melee SW is the only class without a reliable AoE. Assassinate is okay, but on later areas can't hit all 3 opponents using assassinate. Pretty much just CoC, because at 33 you can 1+2 shot the first two and assassinate the third. But having an AoE to soften up the badguys in, say, HM or LoB's non onslaught rounds (or hell, p4) would be awesome.
I would love to see a sw aoe attack. Wms and justis own lob because of their ohk aoes. Assassinate is great when it procs but we have to hit 3-4 times more per mob to get the same numbers down
SurrealSaDiablo wrote:I would love to see a sw aoe attack. Wms and justis own lob because of their ohk aoes. Assassinate is great when it procs but we have to hit 3-4 times more per mob to get the same numbers down
Justis own lob?????
Justi's own phase 1 of lob. Suck at 2 and 3. Adequate at p4.
SurrealSaDiablo wrote:I would love to see a sw aoe attack. Wms and justis own lob because of their ohk aoes. Assassinate is great when it procs but we have to hit 3-4 times more per mob to get the same numbers down
If you have to hit 3-4x more to kill a mob... then an AOE wouldn't help you too much. Unless you're one-hitting with an AOE, it's going to take you multiple kills either way. Remember that AOEs typically tend to be weaker than single target attacks. Easiest work around is to get 2-3 magic gems to stick into your build til you're at 2k magic stat, and then just use poison cloud and acid spray.
Only reason I'm against a melee AOE is that it'll take up a valuable ability spot... and honestly, I like the abilities we currently have. Also... I beg to differ
B4Play wrote:SurrealSaDiablo wrote:I would love to see a sw aoe attack. Wms and justis own lob because of their ohk aoes. Assassinate is great when it procs but we have to hit 3-4 times more per mob to get the same numbers down
Justis own lob?????![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Justi's own phase 1 of lob. Suck at 2 and 3. Adequate at p4.
You got there before me... Justis own nothing Onslaught!!
EricM_Returns_July_2nd wrote:SurrealSaDiablo wrote:I would love to see a sw aoe attack. Wms and justis own lob because of their ohk aoes. Assassinate is great when it procs but we have to hit 3-4 times more per mob to get the same numbers down
If you have to hit 3-4x more to kill a mob... then an AOE wouldn't help you too much. Unless you're one-hitting with an AOE, it's going to take you multiple kills either way. Remember that AOEs typically tend to be weaker than single target attacks. Easiest work around is to get 2-3 magic gems to stick into your build til you're at 2k magic stat, and then just use poison cloud and acid spray.
Only reason I'm against a melee AOE is that it'll take up a valuable ability spot... and honestly, I like the abilities we currently have. Also... I beg to differSWers can hold their own in lob :p
Well we thought melee SW would finally get an AoE with sticky grenade, but it turned out to be only useful in specific situations. With melee SW everything is about more button presses, which tbh I'm fine with cos I've played it for a long time. It's just curious that SG is the only physical one and that its usefulness is limited.