Book of Heroes

mages are overpowered! · page 8

I agree with Eric and like his idea, specially on this part "Mage vs. Melee SW would be slightly fairer for SWers". I play all 3 classes and clearly mages are overpowered in pvp. They got so many status skills and high damage with most of the skills, not to mention snap cast. Mages can finish the match with frozen shard(high damage+status), smoulder+fracture(low dmg+Status), snap, ice lance/incinerate(very high damage). I dont think Jugg is overpowered for Justicar,it runs out so fast and there is long cooldown after that to reuse it.
I've never complained about anything in this game but now when i got involved in pvp, i must say pvp needs to be balanced for every class for a fair fight.
GabZ wrote:I agree with Eric and like his idea, specially on this part "Mage vs. Melee SW would be slightly fairer for SWers". I play all 3 classes and clearly mages are overpowered in pvp. They got so many status skills and high damage with most of the skills, not to mention snap cast. Mages can finish the match with frozen shard(high damage+status), smoulder+fracture(low dmg+Status), snap, ice lance/incinerate(very high damage). I dont think Jugg is overpowered for Justicar,it runs out so fast and there is long cooldown after that to reuse it.
I've never complained about anything in this game but now when i got involved in pvp, i must say pvp needs to be balanced for every class for a fair fight.

Heroic Will. .. no long cool down.
GabZ wrote: I play all 3 classes and clearly mages are overpowered in pvp.

Disagree 10,000%. Nothing compares with the Jugger, Slash (huge knockback), Brutal (high dmg+knockback), Stunning Blow (stun), and Heroic Will (reset all the cooldowns) skills.
Bbbb wrote:
GabZ wrote: I play all 3 classes and clearly mages are overpowered in pvp.

Disagree 10,000%. Nothing compares with the Jugger, Slash (huge knockback), Brutal (high dmg+knockback), Stunning Blow (stun), and Heroic Will (reset all the cooldowns) skills.

My 2 cents.

Low might - mages are severely overpowered. Snap-incinerate critting for 17k+ happens all too often since no one has enchants to counter it. My 21k wm just hops in with onslaught gems and just utterly facerolls with the same 4-5 move combo. It's unbreakable/unstoppable and pretty much wins every match that isn't vs. a justi until players start getting resists. Even vs. justi, the sheer damage output ends most matches.

High might - justis really take over. It's not even close. Once pvp gear and enchants are finished, justis roll through like no other. Warmages are still decent, but there's definite things they lack to perform at the same level they do at low might.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 9:40 am
EricM wrote:
Bbbb wrote:
GabZ wrote: I play all 3 classes and clearly mages are overpowered in pvp.

Disagree 10,000%. Nothing compares with the Jugger, Slash (huge knockback), Brutal (high dmg+knockback), Stunning Blow (stun), and Heroic Will (reset all the cooldowns) skills.

My 2 cents.

Low might - mages are severely overpowered. Snap-incinerate critting for 17k+ happens all too often since no one has enchants to counter it. My 21k wm just hops in with onslaught gems and just utterly facerolls with the same 4-5 move combo. It's unbreakable/unstoppable and pretty much wins every match that isn't vs. a justi until players start getting resists. Even vs. justi, the sheer damage output ends most matches.

High might - justis really take over. It's not even close. Once pvp gear and enchants are finished, justis roll through like no other. Warmages are still decent, but there's definite things they lack to perform at the same level they do at low might.

^ this is what I'm seeing too Eric as I PvP more at high might with SW and lower mights with Mage/Justicars.
Something needs to be done with the whole issue of Jugg and heroic will, and heroic will with seismic.

What's the point of a cooldown on Seismic Slam if they can "cheat" the cooldown?

I really think Heroic will needs its OWN cooldown for PVP, just like how snapcast has a 2s CD.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 9:29 pm
AdamM wrote:Something needs to be done with the whole issue of Jugg and heroic will, and heroic will with seismic.

What's the point of a cooldown on Seismic Slam if they can "cheat" the cooldown?

I really think Heroic will needs its OWN cooldown for PVP, just like how snapcast has a 2s CD.

It's not quite that simple - using Heroic Will too early means you won't be able to use it again for the rest of the fight (probably). It can be a waste to use it solely to get an early stun or seismic in, depending on timing.

Justicars will always need those abilities because of their lack of slowing abilities. Their only way to move timers is with seismic, which seems pretty intentional. Lets wait and see what they do with the overall balance, as its not where it should be yet.

This thread is also probably not the place for a Justicar complaint either.
Ilyana_the_Red wrote:
Nevla_Nom wrote:
Ilyana wrote:That's really the kind of 'logic' that doesn't work when you're 13, never mind adulthood. Throwing everything someone says during a debate back at them as 'proof' that the person is 'actually talking about themselves' is just a Wookiee defence and is very, very funny.

I don't have anything against you personally (despite your every effort to make this a personal issue rather than a debate informed by opinion and facts) but please just accept that yes, WM were overpowered (the whole point of this thread you managed to derail) otherwise Venan wouldn't have done the balancing they did. As far as I'm concerned this thread is dead and you can open another once you feel mages are underpowered again. For me the issue is not whether or not class A is OP compared to class B but that something is done about it, and something has.

Can we now go back to something we agree about, like spec prices?

Actually, I think it IS personal, despite your effort to deny it. I think you have a problem with me having been somewhat successful in PvP and at the same time having an opinion. Once again you accuse me of something you do yourself, some sort of double standards.

I do think that a good Justi had an advantage, and even more so since the update. Being able to bypass starting timers, having insane knockbacks, and juggernaut with 100% status resistance + status resist enchant.

But i have realised that I have little interest in Book of Heroes since 2.1 came out, as it feels like starting over again, so I probably won't be playing nor visit the forum much. So I guess that in some regard you won! Tho I expect you to reply to this as well, considering you seem to have an obsession with getting the last word. :lol:

No, your 'success' at PvP has very little to do with anything. Most people on the forums save a certain one or two very much disagree with you.

What most people have a problem with is your absolute insistence that a) mages weren't overpowered (which they were, the balance changes make this absolutely irrefutable) and b) that Justicars were somehow broken, despite many players showing you to the contrary.

Your opinions though, when challenged by people who can actually debate and don't have 14-year old approaches to human interaction, shift into personal attacks and trolling. I will always point this out on the forums, because one day I believe the forums will be moderated as effectively as the game channels themselves. Many people on here get away with behaviour that is unacceptable on the game itself. Again, you've tried a schoolyard approach to debate - this time apparently if someone disagrees with you it's because you are some kind of PvP god-king that should be listened to above anyone else.

'Top' players do not proclaim themselves to be so. A lot of them just happen to have played the game longer. I consider people like Eric to be the true top players of this game, as they don't brag about it. They just use their experience to help other players.

I hope you do keep playing the game, but I have very little sympathy for anyone that thinks 2.1 somehow cripples WM class or makes it unplayable. They are wrong. I know dozens of Justicar and SW players who could have abandoned the game in the same manner over earlier updates and they didn't.

"No, your 'success' at PvP has very little to do with anything. Most people on the forums save a certain one or two very much disagree with you."

Really? I had a different experience.


"What most people have a problem with is your absolute insistence that a) mages weren't overpowered (which they were, the balance changes make this absolutely irrefutable) and b) that Justicars were somehow broken, despite many players showing you to the contrary."

Mages not being overpowered does not justify mega-buffing justies to mage slaying machines. Mages were insanely underpowered in the beginning of PvP and deserved the extra kills. Also, the lack of resetting or hiding the stats in the PvP beta made it worse since when one could finally start winning, the stats were already screwed.

"Your opinions though, when challenged by people who can actually debate and don't have 14-year old approaches to human interaction, shift into personal attacks and trolling. I will always point this out on the forums, because one day I believe the forums will be moderated as effectively as the game channels themselves. Many people on here get away with behaviour that is unacceptable on the game itself. Again, you've tried a schoolyard approach to debate - this time apparently if someone disagrees with you it's because you are some kind of PvP god-king that should be listened to above anyone else."
Blah blah, high school ranting.

"'Top' players do not proclaim themselves to be so. A lot of them just happen to have played the game longer. I consider people like Eric to be the true top players of this game, as they don't brag about it. They just use their experience to help other players."
Neither did I, but you reject reality and substitute your own.

"I hope you do keep playing the game, but I have very little sympathy for anyone that thinks 2.1 somehow cripples WM class or makes it unplayable. They are wrong. I know dozens of Justicar and SW players who could have abandoned the game in the same manner over earlier updates and they didn't."
Nah, I quit playing half a year ago. I don't miss it.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Dec 31, 2014 5:50 am
Why are you reopening a six month old thread just to snipe again? Game has had more rebalancing since, so stop whining and come and take a look at it now. Actually, don't bother. Hopefully the forum mods will take notice and lock this ancient thread that's about balance from an earlier version of the game.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Wed Dec 31, 2014 8:46 am
Nevla_Nom wrote:
Ilyana wrote:WM players insisting that Justicars are overpowered, even though Venan's data does not back this up? And I guarantee someone will say 'figures are one thing, but experience is xyz'.

Jugger is a great skill, but it is not as overpowered as snap cast. This is on top of all the fractures and defence-reducing abilities.

Well, experience IS xyz. :D I still say justi has a lot more potential if specced correctly. When people figure it out, bye bye mages.

I say juggernaut is even more powerful than snap cast. Also, justis can heroic will abilites even though they are still active, and they can use it to bypass starting cooldowns. Why does justis even have starting cooldowns when it can be bypassed? As a mage, if a just casts jugger you have to cast a long casting time spell and hope justi misses with knockback, and wait for jugger to clear. Can't do anything.
This is because im too lazy to find another shorter post by Nevla. But prior to.updates, you're saying the Warmages ability to freeze 5-7 times in one match was not overpowered? That it was fair? You're a scrub.