Book of Heroes

Guild Member Promotion

as a guild leader i want to motivate my members. For example if they reach a special might they get promoted from member to veteran. But as we only have 4 ranks that is not possible. In a feature update i would like to have at least 8 - 10 different Rankings in my guild. I did already write to venan and they Said if a lot of people would agree with me they would put that in an update . So if u think this would be a graet idea . Pls wirte your comment and lets see what happens ^^ :D
Well here's my only... hesitancy regarding more ranks. What purpose would they serve?

For example, looking at my guild, the "Recruit" title is reserved for alternate accounts. "Members" are main toons. Veterans can start raids. Officers can update guild description and accept members/alts. Guild Master can disband guild.

If there were more intermediary ranks, shouldn't they have a purpose? Maybe if the whole guild system gets an overhaul with more responsibilities, it could be useful, but I don't know if I'd want ranks for the sake of ranks if they don't come with additional responsibility/power/anything.
EricM wrote:Well here's my only... hesitancy regarding more ranks. What purpose would they serve?

For example, looking at my guild, the "Recruit" title is reserved for alternate accounts. "Members" are main toons. Veterans can start raids. Officers can update guild description and accept members/alts. Guild Master can disband guild.

If there were more intermediary ranks, shouldn't they have a purpose? Maybe if the whole guild system gets an overhaul with more responsibilities, it could be useful, but I don't know if I'd want ranks for the sake of ranks if they don't come with additional responsibility/power/anything.

I honestly can't think of a single "purpose" for additional ranks. However, if a toon's display pic also included a "Guild Rank" insignia, perhaps similar to military rank pins, this could serve as a carrot to members if used as a reward system. The power / responsibility would remain constant (ie at rank 5 below, the player could start raids as a Veteran, at 7 they could amend guild description).

E.g.
Rank
1 (Recruit): Private
2 (Member): PFC
3 (Member): Lance-Corporal
4 (Member): Corporal
5 (Veteran): Sergeant
6 (Veteran): Sergeant-Major
7 (Officer): Lieutenant
8 (Officer): Captain
9 (Officer): Major
10 (GM): colonel

I can't see this really appealing to any senior guilds (where the members wouldn't really tend to be tempted by this kind of bling), but for younger guilds with newer players, it might incentivise. Going by the number of people who seem to have "GM" or "Officer" in their name, it seems there is an appeal in having a visible guild status.
Yeah i think this would be great. I dont want the titles because of any functions just as a bonus for reaching might. for example if a member reaches 1800 might he will be promoted sergent. 3000 might cornel and so on.
Monster_Salad wrote:I want the title Supreme master overlord of BoH is that too much to ask?
GOD loves the trier,so keep tryin ,never give up :-D good luck!!!
No interest.

Here is a simple feature I want. The ability of officers to promote their own alts to be officers. This would eliminate having to get the GM involved everytime you remove alts to make space.
DreamingDaemon wrote:
I honestly can't think of a single "purpose" for additional ranks. However, if a toon's display pic also included a "Guild Rank" insignia, perhaps similar to military rank pins, this could serve as a carrot to members if used as a reward system. The power / responsibility would remain constant (ie at rank 5 below, the player could start raids as a Veteran, at 7 they could amend guild description).

E.g.
Rank
1 (Recruit): Private
2 (Member): PFC
3 (Member): Lance-Corporal
4 (Member): Corporal
5 (Veteran): Sergeant
6 (Veteran): Sergeant-Major
7 (Officer): Lieutenant
8 (Officer): Captain
9 (Officer): Major
10 (GM): colonel

I can't see this really appealing to any senior guilds (where the members wouldn't really tend to be tempted by this kind of bling), but for younger guilds with newer players, it might incentivise. Going by the number of people who seem to have "GM" or "Officer" in their name, it seems there is an appeal in having a visible guild status.

That would be a promoting job nightmare imo! Lol
Monster_Salad wrote:I want the title Supreme master overlord of BoH is that too much to ask?


Keep trying oh great Cesear of the salad! ... Or should that be seizure? ;)

Bj_Knows

ModeratorFri Jun 20, 2014 11:13 am
Subject
Suggestion Stub, Sub Rank
EricM wrote:
For example, looking at my guild, the "Recruit" title is reserved for alternate accounts. "Members" are main toons. Veterans can start raids. Officers can update guild description and accept members/alts. Guild Master can disband guild.

I agree with Eric, but I also see Drachenjagd's point
Drachenjagd wrote:
as a guild leader i want to motivate my members. For example if they reach a special might they get promoted from member to veteran. But as we only have 4 ranks that is not possible. In a feature update i would like to have at least 8 - 10 different Rankings in my guild.

Venan could add sub Ranks from 0- 9. Ex: Veteran s3 or Officer s0.

The advantage with the current Ranks is ease of promotion when members leave and reenter the Guild. There are only three promotions from Recruit to Officer.

The advantage with sub Ranks is letting Guild Members know they are doing a good job. Until Venan has time to tackle several Guild Related Issues, this could be an intermediate step.

The disadvantage with sub Ranks is finding the Developer Cycles. Adding more ranks would be easier to program than sub Ranks.

A compromise would be bronze, silver, gold. Ex: Bronze Veteran or Silver Officer.

Programming Note: Venan could use a keypad for inputing sub Ranks, or there could be two arrows "adjust Rank" and "adjust sub Rank" or there could be a button -1, +1, -10, +10 where the + or - 10 would move a character a full Rank ( - or + 3 for color sub Ranks).

Personally, as a RPG player, I would like Guild Titles that could be awarded by Officers and GMs to exceptional Guild members. Ex: Archmage for War Mage, Blessed for Justicar, Striker for Shadow Walker.

It sub Ranks or Guild Titles were added, it would be cool if they would show up in your Inspect Profile. Ex: along with your Guild Name or your Equipment Page.