Book of Heroes

Guild wars- pillage · page 2

Oh, and if there is a tie, say one guild wins both the Champion battle and the GM battle, and loses the Guild War, then both teams only gain a small amount of Guild Coins, there is no raid, and no other prizes. Its simply a tie.

ARC_ShinoFanGirl1

Thu Jul 5, 2012 4:41 pm
MythicalTitan wrote:
shinofangirl1 wrote:its not that i dont like combat or anything i luv combat its just that the guilds should both agree and be at the same level, which was just mentioned it seems fair that way and yes i agree that i should be 100% optional


Guild Wars would be fantastic. Here are some of my ideas.

1) Guild wars would be fought between guilds of similar ranks. In fact, divide guilds by their rank. Every guild would be able to fight other guilds within 5 ranks above and below them.

IE: My guild (Fear of War; Rank 9) would be able to fight the Guilds above us in level, up to the Rank 4 Guild, and the Guilds below us, down to Rank 14.

Rewards are handed out in percentage rates, according the rank of the guild that was defeated.

AKA; 1000 guild points(or whatever the reward points are) for the guild 5 levels below, up to 10,000 guild points for the guild 5 levels above.


2) The might of everyone in your guild would be added into a total might score that would go towards ranking your guild as well. So you would have your Power, Prestige, & Might that would make up the ranking of each guild. That way Guild Wars would be much more fair between guilds, because youre taking into account the personal makeup of each guild.

3) Now, how the actual fights would work.

Each Guild Fight would be made up of 3 pieces.

1 - The Guild Master Battle.
A GM could choose up to 2 teammates, and then fight the other Guilds GM and 2 teammates. This battle being won would constitute about 25% of the guild score.

2 - The Guild Champion Battle.
Each Guild Master will select a champion that represents the very best of the guild. This Champion fights it out with the other Guilds Champion in a One-on-One deathmatch! This scenario again contributes 25% of the total guild score.

3 - The Guild War!
The restve the Guild members will join each other in teams of 3. Each team battles it out until the opposing team is anniahilated. If your team wins, even if one or 2 teammates died, they are revived to fight the next opposing team. It continues like this until one side's teams are utterly destroyed. This fight comprises 50% of the Guild Score.

Winning Guild Prizes -

- Guild Points to add to rank
- Guild Coins(to purchase Guild Goods from Majerio! Like things to remodel the Guildhouse, or decor that adds bonuses)
- Treasure Pieces (each piece can be put together to form a Guild Trophy/Idol/Statue/Guild Quest piece, or wtvr)
- A one time raid on the losing guild. The "raid" would just randomly take a percentage of the Guilds Guild Coins, and some players gems. Those gems would then be awarded to the victorious Guilds top players- The GM(if he won his battle) the Champion(if he won his battle) and the top team. So 5 gems total taken randomly from the losing team.

P.S. I realized I mentioned something about Treasure Pieces & Guild Quests. What do yall think of quests(story affiliated, not these gather 5k rope things, lol) that are guild oriented?

P.P.S.
I realize many players of a guild will not all be on at the same time. In those instances, the offline characters will all be on teams together & pitted against other non online teams randonmly to get winners. If there is a uneven number, then someone will just be on a team with some offline characters.

Thoughts, comments anyone?
seems like you have everything planned out there! sounds really awesome :D
Yes, very interesting, except for the bit about random loss of gems. I don't think a guild contest should touch individual inventories, especially if a player isn't even around to affect such an outcome.

ARC_ShinoFanGirl1

Thu Jul 5, 2012 7:19 pm
Marney wrote:Yes, very interesting, except for the bit about random loss of gems. I don't think a guild contest should touch individual inventories, especially if a player isn't even around to affect such an outcome.

agreed. also, it shouldnt negatively affect a guild's progress either
TomAgua wrote:each guilds are at different levels. maybe can only attack without permission on same lv but differ lv prrmission? i dont know but raid other
guilds is great idea! makes it more interesting!!

This Idea still seems to be something people want, but I will restate what I've said before: Many OTHER games already have this Feature! Do NOT lose something that keeps THIS game Unique--The Players vs. Monsters Mechanics. If this feature of Guilds fighting is ever implemented, it MUST be on a COMPLETELY Voluntary basis. I suggested before the idea of an Arena where players could go to put themselves, "In the Lists" if they want P v P combat. The same idea would be for Guilds. If a GM decided they wanted their guild to Battle another, they would submit their guild, "To the Lists" and match-ups could be made. Again, this is ALL Voluntary! One of the GREATEST Unique aspects of this game is that one can Quest peacefully, without fear of sudden and UNWANTED attacks from other players. Do NOT lose this Unique Aspect of the game! It is one of the major things that sets THIS game apart, from so many others. Thank you for considering this Viewpoint.
Markonian wrote:If this feature of Guilds fighting is ever implemented, it MUST be on a COMPLETELY Voluntary basis.
I have to wonder under what circumstances you (and others, some of whom vehemently oppose the idea of any kind of PVP) see this game ever implementing an involuntary, or free-for-all, PVP system.

You say that the "Players vs. Monsters Mechanics" are what makes this game "Unique." Well, I'd agree with you. Go with that. It's the very mechanics of BoH combat that make "sudden and UNWANTED attacks from other players" impossible to conceive of, unless a real-time response system is also implemented - which would have far more wide-ranging effects than mere PVP combat, and would be opposed by a far greater number of players, as it would be a far more fundamental change.

In short, I don't think anyone's asking for what you're opposing. :)
Marney wrote:
Markonian wrote:If this feature of Guilds fighting is ever implemented, it MUST be on a COMPLETELY Voluntary basis.
I have to wonder under what circumstances you (and others, some of whom vehemently oppose the idea of any kind of PVP) see this game ever implementing an involuntary, or free-for-all, PVP system.

You say that the "Players vs. Monsters Mechanics" are what makes this game "Unique." Well, I'd agree with you. Go with that. It's the very mechanics of BoH combat that make "sudden and UNWANTED attacks from other players" impossible to conceive of, unless a real-time response system is also implemented - which would have far more wide-ranging effects than mere PVP combat, and would be opposed by a far greater number of players, as it would be a far more fundamental change.

In short, I don't think anyone's asking for what you're opposing. :)

I see what you're saying, but I think you missed the Key Point of what I put forth. Simply this: that any P v P, or Guild v Guild Battles should be on a voluntary basis, where the Player or Guild involved would be LOOKING for that kind of interaction. I too realize that the present combat mechanics do not allow direct, real-time confrontation. All I was putting forth was a desire to avoid a situation where either an individual player or guild was put in a position to battle another, when they didn't want that to happen. The idea I've mentioned before of the Arena, where both Players and Guilds could submit themselves, "To the Lists" I think would be a good mechanism to allow those who want P v P, or Guild v Guild to have a Venue for this kind of Interaction. Hopefully, something along these lines can eventually be developed, so both groups can enjoy the game in the manner they like best! In the end, it will make the game better, as it will service a wider cross-section of gamers. :)
Markonian wrote:any P v P, or Guild v Guild Battles should be on a voluntary basis, where the Player or Guild involved would be LOOKING for that kind of interaction.
I agree entirely. :)