Book of Heroes

Looking for ability damage calculations- Caltrops

Are there any posts or anyone knowledgeable on how damage is calculated with abilities? The main ability I'm looking for is caltrops. I am seeing to get a VERY large range of damage when it comes to it's ticks. Understanding how the calculations are done might help me understand edgy this is so.

Thank you in advance,
Brandon
That's a surprisingly complicated question.

I have backtracked all the damage formulas, but short answer is that yes, there always will be a huge range, depending on what weapon you have equipped (1h sword has a smaller damage range than 1h axe for example), how much defense enemy has, how many offense enchants you have, whether your attack is blocked, etc.

The simple version of the formula is:

(Weapon Min Damage + Melee/Magic Bonus)*Enchant Levels*Ability Damage = Min Damage
(Weapon Max Damage + Melee/Magic Bonus)*Enchant Levels*Ability Damage = Max Damage

But that's modified by death wish, spirit runes, crits, enemy defense enchants, enemy blocks, seasonals, potions, elixirs, etc.

For example, say my sword's min damage is 1000, my melee bonus is 800, I have 3 Lv. 6 phys damage/1h damage, and I'm using piercing strike.
Min damage = (1000+800)*1.36*1.5 = 3672 damage when I don't crit.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 23, 2014 9:08 am
Brandonia wrote:
Are there any posts or anyone knowledgeable on how damage is calculated with abilities?
The main ability I'm looking for is caltrops. I am seeing to get a VERY large range of damage when it comes to it's ticks.

That surprises me. Caltrops by it self has two damages in PvE, normal and Crit (Note 1), that is consistent versus each Monster Type (each has its own Physical Mitigation number)

If you mean PvP, then all bets are off. From Stagger rank 3 (Reduce opponent's damage by 60%) to Arcane Shield (Periodic Damage reduced 75% without removing Shield) to Neurotoxin Stab rank 3 (Reduce opponent's damage by 15%) to tons of other modifiers.

Note 1)
Many things can modify this, from Major/ Minor Spirit Runes, Infest, Nether Ward, etc.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 23, 2014 9:15 am
EricM wrote:
The simple version of the formula is:

(Weapon Min Damage + Melee/Magic Bonus)*Enchant Levels*Ability Damage = Min Damage
(Weapon Max Damage + Melee/Magic Bonus)*Enchant Levels*Ability Damage = Max Damage

Your simple version forgot Weapon Speed, which is why 2h Axe (1.4 Speed) does such enormous damage in PvE. I is also why Caltrops, Poison Cloud and all Runes do more damage with 1h Axe (1.1 Speed) than 1h Sword (1.0 Speed).
Bj_Knows wrote:Subject
Choosing a Weapon, 100% Weapon Damage

The formula for 100% Weapon Damage, or Base Weapon Damage:

100% Weapon Damage =
Main Hand Weapon Damage ( shown on weapon) + Offhand Weapon Damage ( shown on offhand weapon) + [ Bonus Damage ( shown on Stat page) * Weapon Speed ( shown on weapon ) ] + Appropriate Enchants

Bonus Damage is Melee Bonus Damage for Melee Attacks. Bonus Damage is Magic Bonus Damage for Magic Attacks.

Example:
Gwynn's Devastation ( 821- 1,111) Speed 1.1
Vile Razor ( 234- 286)
Poison Cloud 3 ( 100% weapon damage) Magic Attack
Magic Bonus Damage ( 848)
+7% 1H Damage

Damage Range shown on Poison Cloud 3 Tool Tip:
( 821+ 234+ [ 848* 1.1] ) * 1.07 = 2,126 Min damage roll
( 1,111+ 286+ [ 848* 1.1] ) * 1.07 = 2,492 Max damage roll

Damage Shown after the Class Attack is Damage Rolled * Opponent's Damage Mitigation.
Choosing a Weapon

Bj_Knows

ModeratorMon Jun 23, 2014 9:25 am
Bj_Knows wrote:
That surprises me. Caltrops by it self has two damages in PvE, normal and Crit (Note 1), that is consistent versus each Monster Type (each has its own Physical Mitigation number)

Note 1)
Many things can modify this, from Major/ Minor Spirit Runes, Infest, Nether Ward, etc.

Forgot. Periodic Damage (DOT) is the average of your minimum and maximum 100% Weapon Damage. In the below example (Note 1) it would be 923 per Damage Tick versus a Monster with Physical Damage Mitigation 0% and no Buffs or Debuffs on either side.

Note 1)
Bj_Knows wrote:
[ (2,126 + 2,492) / 2 ] * ( 120% / 3.0s) = 923
Choosing a Weapon
Bj_Knows wrote:
Your simple version forgot Weapon Speed, which is why 2h Axe (1.4 Speed) does such enormous damage in PvE. I is also why Caltrops, Poison Cloud and all Runes do more damage with 1h Axe (1.1 Speed) than 1h Sword (1.0 Speed).

My bad ;) Knew I forgot something. Though, also keep in mind that a 1h sword's minimum damage is very similar to a 1h axe's minimum. The axe just has a significantly larger max damage to compensate for it's lack in speed.