Book of Heroes

Guild limits- Increase Member Limit

Any one else think an increased guild limit would help guilds these days. Seems a lot of guilds are having to do super merges and rotation system to be successful in raids. I think a 150 toon cap or maybe a way to not count alts so only count players and not toons. Any thoughts?
Don't only 3 guilds do rotations???

Kingdom (for example) is doing just fine without using rotations with the current limit.
Bbbbleat wrote:Don't only 3 guilds do rotations???

Kingdom (for example) is doing just fine without using rotations with the current limit.

Well any guild that merges have to rotate right?
Meh... I still miss the 60 guild limit days. 100 feels like it's too many. I'd take smaller raids with 60 ppl any day :p

Cletus

ModeratorMon Jun 30, 2014 9:56 pm
I don't like this idea at all. If the member cap was raised for guilds that would be followed by longer raids.. We've gone thru that before and I do not want to think about living thru that mess again...
Salad_The_Slayer wrote:
Well any guild that merges have to rotate right?

Typically when guilds merge, one or both have a lot of deadweight.
I don't think extending raids is needed just looking for a way for guilds to be able to allow for alts and casual players to stay in guild instead of having to kick them after a day or two. I'm not suggesting allowing more members in a raid just allowing more per guild I hate to see long time members have to be removed for space and seems less players in general lately. Maybe just summer who knows

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Jul 1, 2014 4:59 am
The trend over the last few months is large numbers of dead guilds coupled with an increasing number of merges. Summer has an impact but I don't remember it being this bad last year. PvP update MAY help, but remember large numbers of players dislike it (or hate it with a fiery passion depending on the player).

Personally I think the number of guilds is too high. This means however that 100 members isn't enough (imagine everyone has 1 alt - that means 50 actual members).

Lets have a switch so each account is one slot, or if that sounds too many then 1-3 toons per slot.

And no, I don't think raids should be adjusted. Raids are too long since 1.6, the time taken should be more in line with 1.5. I remember part of the rationale for 100 guild members was 'dual raids' and that didn't take off at all.