Book of Heroes

Snap Cast- PvP, Defend

Soooo....Venan prevented allowing WM's from being able to defend through snap cast without consuming it, which is fine by me, but why is the opponent allowed to defend between selecting snap cast and selecting your actual attack. Is this intended or is this a bug? Personally if snap cast "instantly" allows you to cast your next spell, it isn't really "instant" when your opponent is allowed to throw up defend. Dev input would be appreciated, Thanks!
Sarala wrote:Soooo....Venan prevented allowing WM's from being able to defend through snap cast without consuming it, which is fine by me, but why is the opponent allowed to defend between selecting snap cast and selecting your actual attack. Is this intended or is this a bug? Personally if snap cast "instantly" allows you to cast your next spell, it isn't really "instant" when your opponent is allowed to throw up defend. Dev input would be appreciated, Thanks!

Isn't riposte the same? If it instantly finishes the attack, why does enemy get to defend. At least there's some consistency now. Though I wouldn't mind if both became true instants.
EricM wrote:
Isn't riposte the same? If it instantly finishes the attack, why does enemy get to defend. At least there's some consistency now. Though I wouldn't mind if both became true instants.

I'll be the first to admit, that other than generally knowing what SW atks do, I'm a SW dummy. If that is what rispote actually says, then I'm all for changing that too. The alternative would be to allow the opponent make a move but now allow then to defend.
Personally I think rispote happens too many times in a PvP match to allow for this action but we could always ask them to lower the frequency ;-)
Sarala wrote:
EricM wrote:
Isn't riposte the same? If it instantly finishes the attack, why does enemy get to defend. At least there's some consistency now. Though I wouldn't mind if both became true instants.

I'll be the first to admit, that other than generally knowing what SW atks do, I'm a SW dummy. If that is what rispote actually says, then I'm all for changing that too. The alternative would be to allow the opponent make a move but now allow then to defend.
Personally I think rispote happens too many times in a PvP match to allow for this action but we could always ask them to lower the frequency ;-)

Yet as I found out roughly 15 minutes ago snap cast isn't actually instant. I cast it against a sw (I'm a dummy in regards to this class beyond the basics as well), was knocked back .73 seconds and did not receive the buff 'instantly' as the tool tip suggests. I too agree that riposte should act this way as well but this functionality seems broken to me.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 10, 2014 2:59 am
Being able to defend before Snap is used was deliberately added. This was because when the opponent used it, you would of course hit defend. The WM would then hit defend too to waste the defend time and hit their snap undefended.

Since PvP came along, you were able to hit defend before a Riposte actually hit. Whether either are a bug I think is answered by the latest update where Riposte was left as-is and Snap was changed to bring it in-line (and also make it less overpowered as a PvP skill).
I don't see a problem with snap cast. The ideal way to use it is when your opponent is mid cast.

Then it truly is instant.

I've been experimenting with ability usage and using snap at the start of a round while not completely useless pretty much assures you're opponent will defend. Why could this be a good thing?

1. It gives you a free cast where the goal is to apply a status over damage. If the spell isn't blocked.

2. It allows you to cast a long spell that the opponent has to sit through while coming out of defend.

Kalindrov

Site AdminFri Jul 11, 2014 10:23 am
Step 1: You click Snap Cast
Step 2: Your opponent clicks Defend
Step 3: You click Defend
Step 4: Defends both expire
Step 5: You cast whatever you want instantly with Snap Cast
Step 6: Opposing player cannot defend this undefendable move

This is a behavior we did not like seeing because if your opponent has defend and uses it he should be able to defend whatever you instantly cast.

That being said, snap cast is potentially the strongest move in the game depending what you use it on and when. So allowing it to be undefendable was not going to work.

Just use it wisely like Azmo said and you will be fine. Sub optimal times will result in it being defended by your opponent.
I'm sorry but disagree. Snap cast, like any other attack from any other class, can he reasonably predicted. Using your theory, anytime a SW has initiative proc(the actual biggest PITA move as it happens to me almost regularly 2-4 times a match) I should be able to defend as that actually is random...Snap cast happens at the very most twice(if you're incredibly lucky) a round and even when you do manage to get snap cast off when there not defending, better than half the time it gets blocked/resisted/dodged...you take your pick. There's absolutely nothing you can do about smoke bomb going off, as far as I know since I've never resisted/dodged/blocked it before. How is any of this any different than allowing Snap Cast to actually be instant. You call it "potentially" ye best move of all classes yet you have nerfed the hell out of it to the point that it's barely useable in PvE. Wouldn't it be grand if we based our attack/RPP model off the Justi as opposed to trying to balance everything around the SW?
I disagree somewhat Sara, I like defending against moronic Wm that use snapcast at that time :D

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Jul 14, 2014 6:26 am
Kalindrov wrote:Step 1: You click Snap Cast
Step 2: Your opponent clicks Defend
Step 3: You click Defend
Step 4: Defends both expire
Step 5: You cast whatever you want instantly with Snap Cast
Step 6: Opposing player cannot defend this undefendable move

This is a behavior we did not like seeing because if your opponent has defend and uses it he should be able to defend whatever you instantly cast.

That being said, snap cast is potentially the strongest move in the game depending what you use it on and when. So allowing it to be undefendable was not going to work.

Just use it wisely like Azmo said and you will be fine. Sub optimal times will result in it being defended by your opponent.

^ this explains it very well. In post-2.0 beta snap cast was a shockingly overpowered ability.

Snap cast couldn't be defended before, whereas smoke can if you get timings right. Snap cast needed to be defendable. Mages already have an extremely fast stun, even at base, which no other class boasts. They can even cast it instantly via snap which makes it even better.

Urgency is hardly an ability to worry too much about. It has a low proc rate (whole matches can go by without it appearing). Its not as bad as backswing which I think has a 75% proc rate and often does more damage than the ability you just dodged. Also Urgency affects your Haste, not Initiative. Defending it is just not possible mechanically.