Book of Heroes

Update 2.1.3 - PvP matching

Hi. I'm 15 k might, why I every time match with 30+ k might in PvP...sory but its a ...
Is it so Hurd to make mutchs just between players with 2k might difference?

Or to make some kind of filter in coliseum ...

Waiting for your responed. Thks for updates generally they are awesome.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Jul 10, 2014 1:55 pm
lLUCKYl wrote:Hi. I'm 15 k might, why I every time match with 30+ k might in PvP

Elo Matching (Note 1) can cause mismatches. But each time you don't win, it gets better at matching you with an opponent. Ultimately, it wants all characters to have a 50/50 chance of winning (this is simplified).

I notice when new 45k+ might characters enter PvP, my 32k might character often fights them, and loses, but this evens out in the long run. Currently I am at 62 Wins in 115 Fights (Losses, Forfeits, and Time Outs count as "not win") or 54% Wins.

Note 1)
Bj_Knows wrote:
Elo matching (Note 1), tries to give you a 50/50 change of winning a match (yes this is simplified). If you lose, you lose a little PvP Rating, but if you win, you gain more than you lose (huge gains for beating someone several League above you during first 4 PvP Matches). Skipping a lot of the technical side, eventually Elo matching finds the League you have the best chance of winning 50/50, and you get a bonus in Marks based on your League (Note 2)

When you improve your character, Elo will notice you trouncing your opponents and increase your League, giving you more bonus in Marks. This is the main incentive for getting a full set of PvP Gear (+20% VS Player, -20% VS Monster for a full set of 1h Gear or 2h Gear).
https://www.venan.com/boh_forum/viewtopic.php?p=32323#p32323
You write about 50/50 win Chance .... Fighting double might opponents gives 5% chance... So please give option to chose which might deference opponents to fight. For example to make 3 choices +-2000 might, +-5000might and unlimited ...

So now you have just to add first two options cos unlimited currently works.

Thks. Waiting for your respond.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Jul 10, 2014 6:12 pm
lLUCKYl wrote:You write about 50/50 win Chance .... Fighting double might opponents gives 5% chance
Might is a terrible predictor of PvP wins. A high Might character may be bad at PvP while a low might character may be very good at PvP.

My 32k Shadow Walker has twice defeated a 42k+ opponents. My 28k War Mage has three times defeated 36k+ opponents.

The more you PvP, the better the Elo matching works. Until everyone in PvP has 1000+ Matches, there will still be huge mismatches. With Elo matching, most characters will get "10,000 Wins in PvP" in 20,000 Bouts.

Matching by Might can be gamed by players to help them win (see Beta PvP articles about Naked Fighters with Tier 16 Weapons and Fighters with tier 16 Gear and no Augment Gems). Players removing Gems and Gear to fight in lower Leagues, lose Marks, and Medals, since PvP rewards are now League based. The only way to get more Rewards is to try and Win every PvP Bout and occasionally fight tougher opponents.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Jul 10, 2014 7:22 pm
Bj_Knows wrote:
lLUCKYl wrote:You write about 50/50 win Chance .... Fighting double might opponents gives 5% chance
Might is a terrible predictor of PvP wins. A high Might character may be bad at PvP while a low might character may be very good at PvP.

My 32k Shadow Walker has twice defeated a 42k+ opponents. My 28k War Mage has three times defeated 36k+ opponents.

The more you PvP, the better the Elo matching works. Until everyone in PvP has 1000+ Matches, there will still be huge mismatches. With Elo matching, most characters will get "10,000 Wins in PvP" in 20,000 Bouts.

Matching by Might can be gamed by players to help them win (see Beta PvP articles about Naked Fighters with Tier 16 Weapons and Fighters with tier 16 Gear and no Augment Gems). Players removing Gems and Gear to fight in lower Leagues, lose Marks, and Medals, since PvP rewards are now League based. The only way to get more Rewards is to try and Win every PvP Bout and occasionally fight tougher opponents.

Ok I have to refute this. Most of my matches for the last 50 at least have been against higher mights. Often substantially higher. The range of opponent might is between 6,000 and 17,000 higher.

You say might is a terrible predictor of wins. That really isn't true at the sharp end of things. You really don't have much chance against a 51k opponent if you are only 34k. Your statement that you've defeated far higher mights with your toons two or three times is hardly indicative of might not being a factor, is it?

This however should be fine. Win/loss doesn't really matter. What does matter is fighting all these imbalanced matches and losing disproportionate amounts of rank that can't be regained through the same amount of wins (this is from direct experience). Many higher end players are experiencing this.

The system needs to take into account might differences when calculating the rank award/loss for the match. If you were 30k and your opponent 50k and you won, you should get extra bonuses entirely separate from the league differences. The reverse should also be true - if you lost to a very high might toon the rank loss shouldn't bite so hard as it does.
Ilyana wrote:
Bj_Knows wrote:
lLUCKYl wrote:You write about 50/50 win Chance .... Fighting double might opponents gives 5% chance
Might is a terrible predictor of PvP wins. A high Might character may be bad at PvP while a low might character may be very good at PvP.

My 32k Shadow Walker has twice defeated a 42k+ opponents. My 28k War Mage has three times defeated 36k+ opponents.

The more you PvP, the better the Elo matching works. Until everyone in PvP has 1000+ Matches, there will still be huge mismatches. With Elo matching, most characters will get "10,000 Wins in PvP" in 20,000 Bouts.

Matching by Might can be gamed by players to help them win (see Beta PvP articles about Naked Fighters with Tier 16 Weapons and Fighters with tier 16 Gear and no Augment Gems). Players removing Gems and Gear to fight in lower Leagues, lose Marks, and Medals, since PvP rewards are now League based. The only way to get more Rewards is to try and Win every PvP Bout and occasionally fight tougher opponents.

Ok I have to refute this. Most of my matches for the last 50 at least have been against higher mights. Often substantially higher. The range of opponent might is between 6,000 and 17,000 higher.

You say might is a terrible predictor of wins. That really isn't true at the sharp end of things. You really don't have much chance against a 51k opponent if you are only 34k. Your statement that you've defeated far higher mights with your toons two or three times is hardly indicative of might not being a factor, is it?

This however should be fine. Win/loss doesn't really matter. What does matter is fighting all these imbalanced matches and losing disproportionate amounts of rank that can't be regained through the same amount of wins (this is from direct experience). Many higher end players are experiencing this.

The system needs to take into account might differences when calculating the rank award/loss for the match. If you were 30k and your opponent 50k and you won, you should get extra bonuses entirely separate from the league differences. The reverse should also be true - if you lost to a very high might toon the rank loss shouldn't bite so hard as it does.

I'm going to say something my sw is 47k might and let me tell you im 22-89 so might isnt that much of a contributing factor while my 30k justi is 109-76
So might is part of it as "more might you should hit harder" well, as true as this skill is better that getting one lucky crit imo

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jul 11, 2014 4:36 am
That is very much the exception. Like I said, at the high end might makes a huge difference in terms of rank loss/gain. If you've played over 100 matches and only won 22, that's a sign the build or enchants need work.

As further evidence look at the mights of everyone in the first few pages of the rankings.
I'm getting really frustrated by this. My 22k is fighting 40+ in at least a third of my fights. It's too big of a mountain to climb. I get that I'm going to lose quite a bit but I'm not even competitive in these fights. Basically, they dodge/block well over half of the time. I don't have the firepower to hang with that. I enchanted accuracy. I don't know what else to do until I get my might up. It's just really frustrating trying to play a game you have virtually no chance of winning.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorFri Jul 11, 2014 8:51 am
pubear wrote:I'm getting really frustrated by this. My 22k is fighting 40+ in at least a third of my fights. It's too big of a mountain to climb. I get that I'm going to lose quite a bit but I'm not even competitive in these fights. Basically, they dodge/block well over half of the time. I don't have the firepower to hang with that. I enchanted accuracy. I don't know what else to do until I get my might up. It's just really frustrating trying to play a game you have virtually no chance of winning.

A third? I'm now fighting on average 12,000 might higher opponents every fight.

The explanation to me was that I'm fighting at a level above that for a 35k toon and that by dropping huge amounts of rating even in losses to 52k might opponents, it decreases the chance that I'll fight them again.

My take is that the above is not skill-based. It doesn't reward skill - it allows the high-might folks to climb to the top even though there are similarly skilled players around them. Yeah, they worked hard to get their might, it doesn't mean the system should favour them by penalising lower might players.

Please alter the gain/loss system to take might differences into account. The system should apply a modifier to the lower might toon's ranking gain or loss based on both league, ranking AND might. Say your toons gets lucky and beats a 40k next match. If they are higher rank, league and might that should be a windfall for you and likely will be. But say you're doing well and make into the same league as them, if you immediately match with them again and they destroy you, you'll lose a disproportionate amount of rating. You'd lose even more if you happened to lose to a 52k might PvPer who has only played 20 matches and is 'on the way up to where they should be'.

The PvP system is great and I love the vast majority of the features. It was however 'sold' as being a skill-based system.
Hi,

I took a break from the game for like 3-4 months. Got back into it to check out the new PvP system and to continue raiding moderately. And honestly, I am shocked that this PvP matchmaking system is now alive and well.

I am a WM with around 21k might. I used to PvP extensively during the beta, had around 7k matches played IIRC and was in top 10/20 ranked all the time. Maybe some colleague PvPers might remember me. I remember moaning back then when very rarely I got matched with people with 10+k might but it was really rare. Boy, I had no idea what was coming.

So now I got back to the game and it all starts nicely. Got myself into gold 2 and 1 range and what do I see now? Fighting people with 40k+ might CONSTANTLY. Thats double my might. Even if they are not specced and enchanted for PvP they still do double my dmg and even though I can get a lucky win now and there, it's just an uphill battle. I got hit by Incinerate for 11k THROUGH ice shield, yet my Incinerate crits for 10k on undefended target. Its bullshit.

I have read some discussion about it and people are advocating this new matchmaking system by saying that the system seeks to match you in a way that ultimately we all would have around 50/50 win/loss ratio. What is that? My win/loss ratio was like 6/1 in beta. I was fighting good opponents with +/- 3 to 5k might difference and I was having fun. I felt good with my winning ratio and I though I was good in PvP. I felt I accomplished something in this game.

Now PvP seems like its just for the high might characters. Its a boring 50/50 win/loss fest. There is no more skill involved, at least on my matchmaking level. I am constantly hovering around gold 2 and 1 with no possibility of progression whatsoever. I dont play to win any more. I just play for medals so I can improve my gear whereas I used to play for enjoyment WHILE still improving my gear and every win was great and every loss used to hurt on personal competitive level.

Even though this post might sound like a whining post, I actually want it to be positive criticism. I want thing to improve for the enjoyment of all PvP community. Because atm, whats the point to PvP with your alts or with your main if he is not in the top might bracket? I dont see any apart from dueling your similar might guildies and/or friends.