Book of Heroes

Ice Spike Armor- PvP

Hey there :)

I`ve searched the forum for it but didn`t find the right answer.

My WM has ice spiked armor 3, and the discribtion says: Ice Spike Armor (P) – Magically retaliate 10% of (WD) as Ice damage, at lvl 1, 30% at lvl 3.

But why didn`t proc it when another WM use fire skills ?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSat Jul 12, 2014 11:20 am
Knäckebrot wrote:Hey there :)

I`ve searched the forum for it but didn`t find the right answer.

My WM has ice spiked armor 3, and the discribtion says: Ice Spike Armor (P) – Magically retaliate 10% of (WD) as Ice damage, at lvl 1, 30% at lvl 3.

But why didn`t proc it when another WM use fire skills ?

Also, why does it return damage when you use non-damaging abilities like caltrops (it's initial casting does no damage unlike others). It also seems to trigger from smoke bomb.
Ilyana wrote:

Also, why does it return damage when you use non-damaging abilities like caltrops (it's initial casting does no damage unlike others). It also seems to trigger from smoke bomb.

It retaliates anything placed on the warmage - including caltrops/smoke. The move doesn't have to do damage for it to retaliate. It's almost like a counter.
Really? Doesn't reflect fire? I need to imbue my blades with fire now! :)

Coming from sw point of view, I really hate that bloody ice spike lol

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSat Jul 12, 2014 8:55 pm
Knäckebrot wrote:
But why didn`t proc it when another WM use fire skills ?

Icy Spike Armor is not triggered by Periodic Damage (DOT) like Burn, Bleed, Exploding Sticky Grenade Damage, Caltrop Periodic Damage and Poison Cloud Periodic Damage.

If I remember correctly, Icy Spike Armor only retaliates Critical Hits and Normal Hits. You may have Blocked or Spell Dodged a Direct Damage Fire Attack.

It does do damage when you are first hit with Caltrops and Sticky Grenade because they are considered 0 Initial Damage Attacks. I cannot remember if Smoke Bomb triggers it.

Icy Spike Armor rank 3+ Ice Mastery rank 3 does 36% Base Weapon Damage and Reflexive Strike rank 3 does 70% Base Weapon Damage. Depending on timing, multiple Reflexive Strike may be a bad idea. It is even worse if you are a Shadow Walker using an Sword and Shield instead of a Sword and Dagger, since Sword and Dagger does about the same Damage Per Second as Staff and Staff Mastery 3 while Sword and Shield does less, increasing the imbalance (skipping some very complicated technical details).

MY PERSONAL OPINION
I hate when my opponent's Icy Spike Armor gets a Critical Hit and kills me.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 9:32 am
EricM wrote:
Ilyana wrote:

Also, why does it return damage when you use non-damaging abilities like caltrops (it's initial casting does no damage unlike others). It also seems to trigger from smoke bomb.

It retaliates anything placed on the warmage - including caltrops/smoke. The move doesn't have to do damage for it to retaliate. It's almost like a counter.

How can it retaliate something that doesn't do damage? Smoke does no damage, yet damage gets returned. Caltrops do no damage (and the ticks don't apply for ice spike) but damage gets returned.

I'm inclined to think this is a bug, as the ice spike ability has to be calculating from something.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 9:50 am
EricM wrote:
It retaliates anything placed on the warmage - including caltrops/smoke. The move doesn't have to do damage for it to retaliate. It's almost like a counter.

Just remembered Arcane Shield (Note 1).

EricM, I bet you 5 GS that Icy Spike Armor and Arcane Shield both trigger the same (same programming).

Note 1)
Sticky Grenade foils Arcane Shield... - NOT A BUG

japster

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 10:20 am
Ilyana wrote:
EricM wrote:
Ilyana wrote:

Also, why does it return damage when you use non-damaging abilities like caltrops (it's initial casting does no damage unlike others). It also seems to trigger from smoke bomb.

It retaliates anything placed on the warmage - including caltrops/smoke. The move doesn't have to do damage for it to retaliate. It's almost like a counter.

How can it retaliate something that doesn't do damage? Smoke does no damage, yet damage gets returned. Caltrops do no damage (and the ticks don't apply for ice spike) but damage gets returned.

I'm inclined to think this is a bug, as the ice spike ability has to be calculating from something.

Not sure if it's a bug, but the damage is calculated based on the WM's WEAPON damage + ice mastery + ice enchant modifiers (not modified by magic stat). Hence it doesn't matter what kind of damage you're dealing, as long as it's a direct hit (non-block or dodge) on the WM (i.e. non-damaging or damaging) it will reflect.
Bj_Knows wrote:
EricM wrote:
It retaliates anything placed on the warmage - including caltrops/smoke. The move doesn't have to do damage for it to retaliate. It's almost like a counter.

Just remembered Arcane Shield (Note 1).

EricM, I bet you 5 GS that Icy Spike Armor and Arcane Shield both trigger the same (same programming).

Note 1)
Sticky Grenade foils Arcane Shield... - NOT A BUG

I know you're probably right, but i'll take that bet for fun BJ ;)

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorSun Jul 13, 2014 4:40 pm
It's not actually reflecting anything, though. It can't be reflecting damage from smoke bomb as that doesn't do any. 0 reflected is 0 so there has to be something else going on. Or it's a bug ;)