Book of Heroes

Make winning mean something

Two items in pVp stand out to me.

1. If winning does not end up meNing something, right now it fight rewards are independent of a win or loss, pVp is going to get boring quick and only become busy work for just another way to get gems.

2. Might needs to get factored into match ups. It gets old to get your butt handed to you only to check and find out you have 10k less might to your opponent.

I love PvP, these are just two items that would keep me loving it.
1.Well the higher leagues you move up in pays more tokens and you have to win to stay there

2. I tested this the last 3 days on my 18k might justi he is 32-19 not bad eh? My point is its not all about might now some factors are contributing to it such as better enchants gear and or gems but a lot of the Elo system based it off your ratings which the higher the rating the better you are
How about we hook up the players to electrodes and shock the loser based on how overwhelming the defeat was? That would mean something!

Or, we could have the app access the device's camera, take victory photos of the winner, and taunt the loser with them. There's nothing like some good ol' fashioned "in your face!"

Or best of all, we could make the loser's screen shake violently every time they are hit by the winner's blows. Wait, what? Venan already implemented this last one? Oh, never mind, then.

Darkhorse

Site AdminMon Jul 14, 2014 1:24 pm
Steeld wrote:Two items in pVp stand out to me.

1. If winning does not end up meNing something, right now it fight rewards are independent of a win or loss, pVp is going to get boring quick and only become busy work for just another way to get gems.

2. Might needs to get factored into match ups. It gets old to get your butt handed to you only to check and find out you have 10k less might to your opponent.

I love PvP, these are just two items that would keep me loving it.

Winning does mean something. If you win, you get a higher rating. When you get a higher rating, you move up to the next league, and your reward payout becomes higher.
Darkhorse wrote:
Winning does mean something. If you win, you get a higher rating. When you get a higher rating, you move up to the next league, and your reward payout becomes higher.

Which is great, as far as it goes. But we're dealing with gamers here, and gamers need some sense of instant gratification for accomplishing a task. Having a fight conclude with the same immediate reward whether you win or lose doesn't give that feeling of accomplishment, regardless of how it might impact a week from now.

Loath as I am to suggest that pvp needs any more reward (it's incredibly lopsided compared to pve as it is, which is just annoying the folks who don't particularly want to pvp), some form of win bonus is needed to keep interest. It's not like a user can even track their own win rates any more without a spreadsheet updated every match :-/
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Darkhorse wrote:
Winning does mean something. If you win, you get a higher rating. When you get a higher rating, you move up to the next league, and your reward payout becomes higher.

Which is great, as far as it goes. But we're dealing with gamers here, and gamers need some sense of instant gratification for accomplishing a task. Having a fight conclude with the same immediate reward whether you win or lose doesn't give that feeling of accomplishment, regardless of how it might impact a week from now.

Loath as I am to suggest that pvp needs any more reward (it's incredibly lopsided compared to pve as it is, which is just annoying the folks who don't particularly want to pvp), some form of win bonus is needed to keep interest. It's not like a user can even track their own win rates any more without a spreadsheet updated every match :-/

My vote winner recieves 1 medal

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Jul 16, 2014 9:01 am
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Darkhorse wrote:
Winning does mean something. If you win, you get a higher rating. When you get a higher rating, you move up to the next league, and your reward payout becomes higher.

Which is great, as far as it goes. But we're dealing with gamers here, and gamers need some sense of instant gratification for accomplishing a task. Having a fight conclude with the same immediate reward whether you win or lose doesn't give that feeling of accomplishment, regardless of how it might impact a week from now.

Loath as I am to suggest that pvp needs any more reward (it's incredibly lopsided compared to pve as it is, which is just annoying the folks who don't particularly want to pvp), some form of win bonus is needed to keep interest. It's not like a user can even track their own win rates any more without a spreadsheet updated every match :-/

What DH said. Winning is now about getting your rating and rank up, not trying to collect currency or maintaining win/loss ratios like it was in Beta.

Your Mark rewards should only be modified by league as they are. That way it is fair for anyone to jump into the PvP system and have a bash without feeling they are being penalised for exploring it and trying to work out a build. There's already enough sources of frustration in it without creating another one.

Also I think this setup is vastly superior as your ranking is a 'living' score...you have to keep fighting to maintain, as your opponents sure will. It means you can't PvP for three weeks, then stop and stay in the top ranked players indefinitely. Sooner or later you'll drop. We were told that this would go one step further and it would decay like Guild power, but that didn't get put in for some reason.
Ilyana wrote:
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Darkhorse wrote:
Winning does mean something. If you win, you get a higher rating. When you get a higher rating, you move up to the next league, and your reward payout becomes higher.

Which is great, as far as it goes. But we're dealing with gamers here, and gamers need some sense of instant gratification for accomplishing a task. Having a fight conclude with the same immediate reward whether you win or lose doesn't give that feeling of accomplishment, regardless of how it might impact a week from now.
(chunk removed as not relevant here)

What DH said. Winning is now about getting your rating and rank up, not trying to collect currency or maintaining win/loss ratios like it was in Beta.

Your Mark rewards should only be modified by league as they are. That way it is fair for anyone to jump into the PvP system and have a bash without feeling they are being penalised for exploring it and trying to work out a build. There's already enough sources of frustration in it without creating another one.

Also I think this setup is vastly superior as your ranking is a 'living' score...you have to keep fighting to maintain, as your opponents sure will. It means you can't PvP for three weeks, then stop and stay in the top ranked players indefinitely. Sooner or later you'll drop. We were told that this would go one step further and it would decay like Guild power, but that didn't get put in for some reason.

This is fine, as long as the aim is to actively discourage casual pvp play and only significantly reward those who play a lot of matches - and thus climb to the higher ranks. Casual pvpers, who play a few matches a day, or less, are not going to see (what they consider to be) worthwhile rewards, and are thus not going to get "sucked in" to pvp, which is what I would assume the aim to be. Although we have a hardcore group who are willing to put effort, time, and $ into gaining the tiniest advantage to maintain their Platinum I (or is it III? I don't actually know which is higher), casuals won't do that without incentive - be it direct rewards or whatever.

Personally, it doesn't make the slightest difference what the rewards are or how they're structured, I'm just seeing a lot of people moaning or confused about this side of things.
It's not just how it works that makes something like this a success, it's how it's perceived. And in this case, there seems to be a lot of confusion and disappointment in the perception - even if the reality is perfect.