Book of Heroes

Wardrobe, weapons and PvP

japster

ModeratorTue Aug 5, 2014 2:50 am
This is most likely unintended but the wardrobe allows players to equip one weapon-type but displaying a different look. However it only classifies weapons by whether it's one-handed or two-handed, and ignores whether the weapon is an axe or sword.

So we get situations where some players equip two-hand sword but display a two-hand axe, or equip a one-hand sword but display a one-hand axe. This makes it rather deceptive in PvP for an opponent to gauge what sort of timers/speed he is expecting.

Since there's no way to check the gear of the enemy when the matchmaking finds an opponent, this illusion creates a sort of unfair advantage/nasty surprise that cannot be uncovered until the first cast begins. This has bearing on the choice of skills used, especially against the player who goes first.

Would it be possible if the devs limited it so that wardrobe can only display weapons of the actual weapon-type, as opposed to merely the general broad categories of one-hand and two-hand weapons?

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Aug 5, 2014 3:18 am
I doubt this wasn't intentional. I remember having a chat with Kal about it during beta and it didn't seem so. Personally I don't see the problem with it...if I'm fighting a SW that equips an axe but makes it look like a sword, I don't base my moves on what weapon it looks like. I base it on whether I have initiative and what moves come at me with what speed.

japster

ModeratorTue Aug 5, 2014 12:12 pm
Ilyana wrote:I doubt this wasn't intentional. I remember having a chat with Kal about it during beta and it didn't seem so. Personally I don't see the problem with it...if I'm fighting a SW that equips an axe but makes it look like a sword, I don't base my moves on what weapon it looks like. I base it on whether I have initiative and what moves come at me with what speed.

These are good suggestions for pvp, in that you should look at what moves come at you with what speed. But it doesn't address the problem I raised earlier. I might have been unclear, so allow me to state it clearly. The problem is that the player is unable to make an informed decision on his first move when he has the initiative, because the graphics create a deception. If the player knew it was a sword or an axe for sure, then he could gauge the opponent's potential first opening move better.

Your own initiative doesn't tell you anything about the opponent's weapon speed. What throws a player off is thinking the opponent has the speed of an axe when it's actually a sword, and the player with initiative is unable to view his opponent's first cast without making the first move.

The first cast is the problem if you have initiative, because you simply can't tell and cannot make an informed decision, and worst still if you have been deceived by the wardrobe graphics. Of course one can deduce the speed of the weapon and subsequent attacks after seeing the first cast. But without that crucial first cast, a player can't tell and the graphics really create a useful deception since there's no other way to find out until you commit to the first move.

These are of course rather fine mechanical details that I suspect most players do not concern themselves with, but it would be nice if it could be resolved in some way or the other, without compromising the wardrobe function, e.g. just the game could state the opponent's base weapon speed (1.0, 1.3, or 1.4) on the loading matchmaking screen.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Aug 5, 2014 7:03 pm
You weren't unclear...I just didn't agree. I'm tired of seeing people suggest that disagreeing somehow means they didn't understand.

Using an axe graphic instead of a sword one (and vice versa) is completely intentional. It's an option two classes have and one unfortunately doesn't.

What you seem to want, when you have the initiative and thus an advantage, is the further advantage of seeing what weapon the opponent is using in those small cases where someone has an axe that looks like a sword.

When I PvP I look at who has initiative, then plan my first move based on that initiative score. There isn't anything any class can throw as a first move that will particularly surprise anyone.

Based on a convo I had with Kal, using a different weapon skin to cover your actual weapon is a good tactic in PvP. It keeps people guessing. I think the devs should let people keep this option, without giving away that advantage, and mages can keep their obscene 13-20k Incinerate crits.
Ilyana wrote:You weren't unclear...I just didn't agree. I'm tired of seeing people suggest that disagreeing somehow means they didn't understand.

Using an axe graphic instead of a sword one (and vice versa) is completely intentional. It's an option two classes have and one unfortunately doesn't.

What you seem to want, when you have the initiative and thus an advantage, is the further advantage of seeing what weapon the opponent is using in those small cases where someone has an axe that looks like a sword.

When I PvP I look at who has initiative, then plan my first move based on that initiative score. There isn't anything any class can throw as a first move that will particularly surprise anyone.

Based on a convo I had with Kal, using a different weapon skin to cover your actual weapon is a good tactic in PvP. It keeps people guessing. I think the devs should let people keep this option, without giving away that advantage, and mages can keep their obscene 13-20k Incinerate crits.

I agree with this! I don't PvP yet...but I did during beta and will PvP soon to start on the feats.

In a pro vs con scenario chalk it up as a con to the initiative enchant.
@japster

what u described is mainly the idea of wardrobe..

it change nothing but its more fun on pvp if u play with it..
and after a while on pvp u will know the most of your opponents and some players are allways strong no matter how they look ;)