Book of Heroes

Homosexuality

I was silenced in chat for talking about lesbians, is homosexuality a ban-able offense on Venan games? Is Venan openly coming out and saying that they hate gays? Do tell, because I think the LBGT community is widely known for understanding intolerance. I'd love some clarification on the chat rules. Thanks!

beekeo

Site AdminTue Aug 26, 2014 7:35 pm
Discussing sexual orientation of course is not against any rules.

Please email customer service from the options menu and we can review the situation.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Tue Aug 26, 2014 8:50 pm
Tobe wrote:I was silenced in chat for talking about lesbians, is homosexuality a ban-able offense on Venan games? Is Venan openly coming out and saying that they hate gays? Do tell, because I think the LBGT community is widely known for understanding intolerance. I'd love some clarification on the chat rules. Thanks!
It can be considered an offensive topic though.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 27, 2014 4:23 am
Tobe wrote:I was silenced in chat for talking about lesbians, is homosexuality a ban-able offense on Venan games? Is Venan openly coming out and saying that they hate gays? Do tell, because I think the LBGT community is widely known for understanding intolerance. I'd love some clarification on the chat rules. Thanks!

Like anything, it depends on the context of your comments and whether they are appropriate for the age rating the game is aimed at. If for example your context was sexually suggestive then it is not acceptable.
Tobe wrote:I was silenced in chat for talking about lesbians, is homosexuality a ban-able offense on Venan games? Is Venan openly coming out and saying that they hate gays? Do tell, because I think the LBGT community is widely known for understanding intolerance. I'd love some clarification on the chat rules. Thanks!


The primary thing would be what did "talking about lesbians" consist of?
Sexual orientation is right up there with politics and religion in these sorts of environments. It's generally acceptable to state one's "preference" - eg "I'm a lesbian" sits alongside "I'm a Christian / Jew / Satanist / Republican". Further in-depth discussion will see hammers fall. Remember that the chat is supposed to be 9+, and ANY sexual content sees silences land - plenty of people have been silenced/warned for (some examples I've seen over the last year and a half):
* Heterosexual content - Venan doesn't hate straight people
* Criticism of the Catholic Church - Venan isn't employed by the Pope
* "Preaching" a particular theology - Venan isn't an agent of Satan
* Criticism of America's foreign policy - Venan isn't an arm of the DoHS
* Political discussion - Venan isn't there to shut down political debate
* Recommendation of electronic cigarettes to help stop smoking - Venan isn't getting kickbacks from Marlboro
* Mention of current state of sobriety - Venan aren't paid-up members of the Teetotallers' Union.

It's also worth mentioning that what is permissable in chat doesn't always make sense. For example, mods will quickly jump on any mention of alcohol, despite there being alcohol feature in the game - eg at the Mucky Duck, the Lucky Blades questline seeing you fight many drunken pirates, and the bar-room brawl quests in the Vile Realm seeing drunken Viles use some imaginative alcohol-based actions.

Finally, there is what appears to be an openly-homosexual NPC in BoH in Claude. Token and overly-stereotypical, yes, but still there, which is more than what many games of this type do. So it could be argued that Venan are actually taking a more progressive approach on this issue than many in the industry as a whole.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Aug 27, 2014 9:36 am
DreamingDaemon wrote:
Tobe wrote:I was silenced in chat for talking about lesbians, is homosexuality a ban-able offense on Venan games? Is Venan openly coming out and saying that they hate gays? Do tell, because I think the LBGT community is widely known for understanding intolerance. I'd love some clarification on the chat rules. Thanks!


The primary thing would be what did "talking about lesbians" consist of?
Sexual orientation is right up there with politics and religion in these sorts of environments. It's generally acceptable to state one's "preference" - eg "I'm a lesbian" sits alongside "I'm a Christian / Jew / Satanist / Republican". Further in-depth discussion will see hammers fall. Remember that the chat is supposed to be 9+, and ANY sexual content sees silences land - plenty of people have been silenced/warned for (some examples I've seen over the last year and a half):
* Heterosexual content - Venan doesn't hate straight people
* Criticism of the Catholic Church - Venan isn't employed by the Pope
* "Preaching" a particular theology - Venan isn't an agent of Satan
* Criticism of America's foreign policy - Venan isn't an arm of the DoHS
* Political discussion - Venan isn't there to shut down political debate
* Recommendation of electronic cigarettes to help stop smoking - Venan isn't getting kickbacks from Marlboro
* Mention of current state of sobriety - Venan aren't paid-up members of the Teetotallers' Union.

It's also worth mentioning that what is permissable in chat doesn't always make sense. For example, mods will quickly jump on any mention of alcohol, despite there being alcohol feature in the game - eg at the Mucky Duck, the Lucky Blades questline seeing you fight many drunken pirates, and the bar-room brawl quests in the Vile Realm seeing drunken Viles use some imaginative alcohol-based actions.

Finally, there is what appears to be an openly-homosexual NPC in BoH in Claude. Token and overly-stereotypical, yes, but still there, which is more than what many games of this type do. So it could be argued that Venan are actually taking a more progressive approach on this issue than many in the industry as a whole.

Everything depends on context and how that applies to the age rating. So even the list above is deceptive because the context may have been out of line for a 9+ (or 13+ at the time) audience.

If you (not speaking to any particular person here) wouldn't be comfortable a nine-year-old child seeing your post, don't be surprised when it gets moderated. And if you do think it's acceptable for a child to see sexual comments or references to drugs or swearing...I'm glad it's not you that gets to make that call.
Ilyana wrote:
Everything depends on context and how that applies to the age rating. So even the list above is deceptive because the context may have been out of line for a 9+ (or 13+ at the time) audience.

The purpose of the examples given were to demonstrate that just because something is moderated, it doesn't indicate Venan's position, or the position of any of its staff, or the opinion of any moderator, on the subject in question - as the OP implied with the suggestion that Venan "hates gays".

Darkhorse

Site AdminWed Aug 27, 2014 3:24 pm
Review Beekeo's statement above and contact support, we will review the case.