Book of Heroes

Suggestion Stub, Built In, Grey Gem

Bj_Knows

ModeratorThu Aug 28, 2014 8:15 pm
Subject
Suggestion Stub, Built In, Grey Gem

Shift all colored Gem Slots from A- C Gem Slots (0- 20GS to unlock) to B- D Gem Slots (10- 30 GS to unlock). Make all A Gem Slots (0 GS to unlock) Gray Gem Slots. Every Gear, from Helm to Shield, would have a permanent, Gray Gem. Ex: Tier 16 Helm would have a permanent Tier 6 Gray Gem. Tier 8 Helm would have a permanent Tier 3 Gray Gem. Gray Gems add +X Bonus to all 9 Stats, from Health to Crit Power.

Gray Gems are permanently attached to Gear. But Gray Gem Slots could be filled with Black Gems (+2X Bonus to all 9 Stats, Tier 1- 6)

Currently the characters can get very far with zero Gems. The only Stats they have are Level, Weapon Damage, Armor, Health, Magic Rating, Melee Rating, Dodge 5%, Crit 5%, Crit Power 150%. This game balance reinforces the Magic/ Melee Gems, Haste Gem, Crit Power Gems, 2h Axe/ Off Hand Dagger, Elixir of Power, Elixir of Speed, focused Build. Gray and Black Gems would make other Build focuses viable.

Bj_Knows

ModeratorSun Dec 21, 2014 8:04 am
Subject
Suggestion Stub, Trade Craft Customizable Ancestral Grey Gem Gear
Suggestion Stub, TCCAGGG

Warning: This article is a rough draft that contains known, and deliberate, inconsistencies. Feel free to discuss with Venan how to resolve these problem.

Dungeons & Dragons (the original six booklets from my youth), was the ultimately player customizable RPG game (Modable). But players desire to mod games goes back even farther, probable to the first game ever played on Earth. The most notorious being cards, especially Poker, and its variants. For a very funny book, find Phil Foglio’s book of Poker variants. _Dealer’s Choice: The complete Handbook of Saturday Night Poker by James Ernest, Mike Selinker, Phil Foglio_. Currently there is no way to mod BoH.

Magic The Gather the collectable card game the the most famous recent game that allows players to trade. Trade is central to its business model. Traditional RPGs limit trade to random treasures from looted bodies or Quests.

In the real world, people often trade something they don’t want for something they do (barter). An interesting twist is that moding an item can increase its value to certain people and decrease its value to others. A plain white shirt vs a tie dyed shirt vs a white shirt dyed black. A plain white coffee mug vs a white coffee mug with “#1 Dad” vs a white coffee mug with Uncle Jeb proudly proclaiming “I am full of Space Impatience”. A NERF fully automatic rifle vs the same rifle moded in “Steam punk” style vs the same rifle with replaced components for better range and accuracy.

In the current BoH business model, Gold Shields are the universal currency. If Trade A is worth X GS, and Trade B is worth Y GS, then a fair trade is if X and Y are within 10% of each other.

Another advantage with GS valuation is its resistance to third party trading. If all tradable items can be bought in Shops, than third party trading (e.g. eBay) are capped by the price in the Shop. If Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny can be traded with another player or bought at a Shop for 10 GS then eBay will never offer an Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny for more than 10 GS.

One way to get people to trade for Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny is if they can get it for less than 10 GS. Crafting Gear requires time playing the game, and time in the BoH Workshop, making Crafted Gear an attractive trade item. BoH already has a grind problem, balancing grinding vs GS price will require time invested in rebalancing both.

Another way to get people to trade for Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny is if to let people mod it.

Trading with LOW LEVEL characters is the only business model that makes a decent profit. While it can be exploited by players with high Level characters, attracting new customers who can mod the game, is a growth cycle. More new customers can create more mods, more mods create more variety in the game *without* spending a single cent on Venan salaries, more variety in the game attracts more new customers who can mod the game, ad infinitum.

The Smith’s house would let you design your own Armor Color Set. For every 10 Levels, a character unlocks another Armor Color Set slot. Using pre made elements and a choice of colors for each element, you can customize a set of armor as long as you have the complete set. If you have the complete set of Shattered Soul Armor (Helm, Chest Armor, Leg Armor, Boots, Gauntlets) you could change the color to pink and add racing stripes. You can apply an Armor Color Set to Gear you wish to Trade.

The Smith’s house would let you design your own Armor Infinite Set for every 20 Levels and 25 GS (another 25 GS if you want to reset a AIS slot). You can apply an Armor Infinite Set to Gear you wish to Trade. In addition to the normal elements and colors available to the regular Armor Color Set, you can select one custom HTML color and upload a custom element for Chest Armor, Light Shield and Heavy Shield. Useful for adding Guild logos, mottos, in jokes, etc. These custom elements would .PNG files placed in a moderation queue. If your .PNG file violates TOS, it will be flagged by a chat mod client or admin client, and denied. Any client (customer, chat mod, admin) can also flag an approved .PNG file for further review (from a chat channel or during PvP), especially useful for mottos containing foreign languages. Denied, or revoked, .PNG files would be held for 4 months for 1 file, 8 months for 2 files and 12 months for 3 files. If you currently have 3 denied .PNG Files on your account you are banned from creating AIS for 12 months.

Both Armor Color Sets and Armor Infinite Sets have a Power Slot in their Chest Armor and Cloak. Your character can select one of their Class abilities and add it to the Gear when they Craft it. Power slots count as Rank 1, have twice the cool down of normal and half the normal chance to Proc. A Crafted Chest Armor with Urgency would have half the normal chance to proc. A Crafted Cloak with Smite would have twice the cool down. This would not stack. If you have Urgency rank 3, a Crafted Chest Armor with Urgency rank 1 and a Crafted Cloak with Urgency rank 1, you still have Urgency rank 3. Power Slots are most useful to other classes, but are still useful to all classes.

Both Amor Color Sets and Armor Infinite Sets have Gray Gems. Gray Gems are a way to allow people to mod Gems. A Tier 3 Haste Gem is boring. But a Pink Cloak with Grey Gems, “SPOON!!” across it, and Riposte rank 1 is not boring.

Both Armor Color Sets and Armor Infinite Sets are Ancestral Gear (Stats depend on character’s Level, min and max Stats for different Ancestral Sets). This allows a high Level character to trade with a low Level character without instantly unlocking the highest level Raid in the Game. The combination of Ancestral Gear and Gray Gems makes this very attractive to low Level characters, without replacing Max Tier Gear and Gems. The disadvantage of Ancestral Gear to a low Level Character is mitigated by the Gear leveling (until max Stats for its Ancestral Set) with the low level player.

Trading with LOW LEVEL characters is the only business model that makes a decent profit. While it can be exploited by players with high Level characters, attracting new customers who can mod the game, is a growth cycle. More new customers can create more mods, more mods create more variety in the game *without* spending a single cent on Venan salaries, more variety in the game attracts more new customers who can mod the game, ad infinitum.

Ancestral Gear also helps with the problem of storing Gear that has an infinite amount of appearance and an infinite number of Class Abilities in Power Slots.

The Server would track the most popular Power Slots. Every X hours, the Power Slot on Ancestral Armor sold in Shops would change to the current most popular. If Chest Armor Power Slot is mostly Urgency rank 1 (all Chest Armor currently in the game), the same Gear would be sold in Shops with Urgency rank 1. This would give customers another incentive to log in to BoH on a regular basis, without making it mandatory (see current Shops in BioWare’s Destiny).

Anything that can be Traded can be removed from the character and put in the Venan ID’s Warehouse. Characters can only remove items from the Warehouse that they have put into it, but the total number of Warehouse slots is per Venan ID, *not* per character. Identical Items will stack up to 198.

Enchantments will be valued at the GS cost of materials from the Black Market for purposes of Trading. Transfer Plates will also be valued at the same GS cost for purposes of Trading. Most players will want to remove Enchants from Trade Gear and trade Transfer Plates instead.

Another advantage with GS valuation is its resistance to third party trading. If all tradable items can be bought in Shops, than third party trading (e.g. eBay) are capped by the price in the Shop. If Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny can be traded with another player or bought at a Shop for 10 GS then eBay will never offer an Angelique’s Breast Plate of Shiny for more than 10 GS. Thus anything available for Trade will also be available for sale at the Shops, but without the mods. You could buy an Ancestral Cloak with Grey Gems from a shop, but would have to trade for an Ancestral Cloak with Grey Gems, colored Pink, with “SPOON!!”, Riposte rank 1 (with or without Enchants).

Tradeable, Craftable, Customizable, Ancestral, Grey Gem Gear would extend the amount of time BoH was a viable game, without completely overhauling the core game mechanics.

Alternate Business Models Discussion
While it would not work with Venan’s current business model (see BioWare’s Destiny), the better version for a game containing PvP would be to replace the Grey Gem Gear model with Level Stats (all your Stats go up when you level, replacing all White Gem Slots, colored Gem Slots let you specialize). This would prevent a lot of the about of PvP Matching since Levels in BoH cannot be reversed unlike D&D or Age of Legends. If Venan ever does a Space Miner MMO, having Level Stats for pilots then equipment Stats for Gear and Ships would work. A common variance is your Level Stat is unusable without Gear. At Level 15, if you equip a single Haste Gem, you get an addition +X to your Haste Rating due to character level and an additional +Y to your Haste Rating due to the Level of your Guild members.