Book of Heroes

PvP Seasons- Stock PvP · page 2

BaneFirerises wrote:
Gster wrote:Hate or love it, equalizing gear within seasons would be the goal here. The gear sets you choose from would change each season. And I am only talking about specific instances like season end tournaments, for example.

Equalizing gear is not as difficult as you make it sound. You want a sword? Here, take your pick from this tier of weapons and armor. Give everyone either a finite number of hero points or max hero points, whichever seems more appropriate. Either pick a tier of enchants to apply or give max tier enchants out.

Implement it by having a wardrobe spec that is only valid for that specific tournament or some other equally viable method.

In the end, I am not advocating speeding up gear acquisition for the general population. This would be for a set specific purpose. Only usable under certain conditions and highly regulated. You want to play normal ranked matches? Use your normally acquired gear. You want to be crowned Victor of the season 1 tournament? Then fight without a gear advantage and prove your might.

Thats the only place I'm going with all of this.

You want better gear then work for it.
You want more HT then work for it.
You want better gems then work for it.
You want a better chance to win a tournament then work to improve your toon to give yourself a better chance. Why should it be given to you?

You guys are completely, totally missing the point here. No, its not about getting gear. Make it disappear after a tournament. Permanently. ITS NOT ABOUT THE GEAR.

Its about competition. What is PVP? Player vs. Player. Skill vs. Skill

That is all. An equal playing field, for special events, for bragging rights. That is the sum total of the whole deal.

I imagine players at the top would embrace this idea in the name of competition. I invite anyone in the masters bracket to weigh in with their opinion.
Gster wrote:You guys are completely, totally missing the point here. No, its not about getting gear. Make it disappear after a tournament. Permanently. ITS NOT ABOUT THE GEAR.

Its about competition. What is PVP? Player vs. Player. Skill vs. Skill

That is all. An equal playing field, for special events, for bragging rights. That is the sum total of the whole deal.

I imagine players at the top would embrave this idea in the name of competition. I invite anyone in the masters bracket to weigh in with their opinion.

I get what you're saying, you want a "stock car" type tournament.

Why not have two season tournaments. One would be a "stock car" tournament where the only reward would be bragging rights.

The other would be a normal tournament with special rewards.
BaneFirerises wrote:
Gster wrote:You guys are completely, totally missing the point here. No, its not about getting gear. Make it disappear after a tournament. Permanently. ITS NOT ABOUT THE GEAR.

Its about competition. What is PVP? Player vs. Player. Skill vs. Skill

That is all. An equal playing field, for special events, for bragging rights. That is the sum total of the whole deal.

I imagine players at the top would embrave this idea in the name of competition. I invite anyone in the masters bracket to weigh in with their opinion.

I get what you're saying, you want a "stock car" type tournament.

Why not have two season tournaments. One would be a "stock car" tournament where the only reward would be bragging rights.

The other would be a normal tournament with special rewards.


That is exactly what I am trying to lobby for here :)
Gster wrote:
BaneFirerises wrote:
Gster wrote:Hate or love it, equalizing gear within seasons would be the goal here. The gear sets you choose from would change each season. And I am only talking about specific instances like season end tournaments, for example.

Equalizing gear is not as difficult as you make it sound. You want a sword? Here, take your pick from this tier of weapons and armor. Give everyone either a finite number of hero points or max hero points, whichever seems more appropriate. Either pick a tier of enchants to apply or give max tier enchants out.

Implement it by having a wardrobe spec that is only valid for that specific tournament or some other equally viable method.

In the end, I am not advocating speeding up gear acquisition for the general population. This would be for a set specific purpose. Only usable under certain conditions and highly regulated. You want to play normal ranked matches? Use your normally acquired gear. You want to be crowned Victor of the season 1 tournament? Then fight without a gear advantage and prove your might.

Thats the only place I'm going with all of this.

You want better gear then work for it.
You want more HT then work for it.
You want better gems then work for it.
You want a better chance to win a tournament then work to improve your toon to give yourself a better chance. Why should it be given to you?

You guys are completely, totally missing the point here. No, its not about getting gear. Make it disappear after a tournament. Permanently. ITS NOT ABOUT THE GEAR.

Its about competition. What is PVP? Player vs. Player. Skill vs. Skill

That is all. An equal playing field, for special events, for bragging rights. That is the sum total of the whole deal.

I imagine players at the top would embrave this idea in the name of competition. I invite anyone in the masters bracket to weigh in with their opinion.

You know, another way to do this (and this might remove some argument against) or as a stand alone idea all-together different would be to go the other way with it and have a "naked" tournament with only melee weapon/s equippable. It would be more of a novelty than a real pvp environment but I imagine it would be fun.
Now the only way to do Gster's idea that I think would be executed successfully is to just have an extra PvP build where you can just apply any weapon (even if you don't have it), do the same with gems, and give us a certain amount of Hero Tokens to spend on whatever we want. And apply any two enchantments on each gear piece at the level of our choice. This character spec should be completely reset-able. I am not sure if this would be tough for Venan to carry out but it appears to be the only logical solution to having a fair PvP season for all players.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 11, 2014 9:53 am
Gfro wrote:Now the only way to do Gster's idea that I think would be executed successfully is to just have an extra PvP build where you can just apply any weapon (even if you don't have it), do the same with gems, and give us a certain amount of Hero Tokens to spend on whatever we want. And apply any two enchantments on each gear piece at the level of our choice. This character spec should be completely reset-able. I am not sure if this would be tough for Venan to carry out but it appears to be the only logical solution to having a fair PvP season for all players.

You don't want to PvP they way that Venan set it up because of perceived 'unfairness' due to might/gear/level/training etc etc. The problem with that assertion is that you will always level out in PvP at the level your skill + gear will get you. To get higher, get more gear.

I don't personally like this approach either, as we were led to think the new setup would truly reward skill, whereas it actually rewards skill so long as you have the PvP gear and high enchants to back it up.

So I think a 'stock car' approach would actually be interesting. Stick everyone in the same gear, give them all identical training, gems and enchants and see who is really good at this. I don't know whether it would ever become a reality but now I know what you mean, it's a great idea ;-)
You don't want to PvP they way that Venan set it up because of perceived 'unfairness' due to might/gear/level/training etc etc. The problem with that assertion is that you will always level out in PvP at the level your skill + gear will get you. To get higher, get more gear.

I don't personally like this approach either, as we were led to think the new setup would truly reward skill, whereas it actually rewards skill so long as you have the PvP gear and high enchants to back it up.

So I think a 'stock car' approach would actually be interesting. Stick everyone in the same gear, give them all identical training, gems and enchants and see who is really good at this. I don't know whether it would ever become a reality but now I know what you mean, it's a great idea ;-)[/quote]

The thing about 'stock car' PvP is that there should be no rewards other then bragging rights.

Is it really fair that someone who doesn't put any time and effort into building their toon up be given all the same gear,gems,HT as someone who has.
BaneFirerises wrote:You don't want to PvP they way that Venan set it up because of perceived 'unfairness' due to might/gear/level/training etc etc. The problem with that assertion is that you will always level out in PvP at the level your skill + gear will get you. To get higher, get more gear.

I don't personally like this approach either, as we were led to think the new setup would truly reward skill, whereas it actually rewards skill so long as you have the PvP gear and high enchants to back it up.

So I think a 'stock car' approach would actually be interesting. Stick everyone in the same gear, give them all identical training, gems and enchants and see who is really good at this. I don't know whether it would ever become a reality but now I know what you mean, it's a great idea ;-)

The thing about 'stock car' PvP is that there should be no rewards other then bragging rights.

Is it really fair that someone who doesn't put any time and effort into building their toon up be given all the same gear,gems,HT as someone who has.[/quote]

World of Warcraft had pvp seasons where to get the normal season rewards you had to play in your regular gear, but they also set up separate tournament servers where you could play where everyone had the ability to choose from equal gear. This was the format used for professional play and, not that Im exactly advocating the creation of professional level Book of Heroes PvP formats, having the ability to play in this way would probably attract players who arent into grinding months on end for gear that makes them competitive.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorThu Sep 11, 2014 4:36 pm
Lost me as soon as Warcraft was mentioned. Now I know why this was suggested...this is it's own game, lets not get down the road of 'they did it in WoW' suggestions.
Ilyana wrote:Lost me as soon as Warcraft was mentioned. Now I know why this was suggested...this is it's own game, lets not get down the road of 'they did it in WoW' suggestions.

Ilyana, I think I did a pretty good job of explaining the 'why' already. I could have just as easily used a RTS example as world of warcraft. League of Legends, DOTA/DOTA 2, any FPS game...should I go on?

At the crux of this is the whole getting everyone on an equal playing field. Im saddened that you would have already read all of this and immediately assumed ulterior motives as soon as another game was mentioned.

Get over your prejudices, this is truly about equal competition.