Subject
Dreaming of Pirates (R= Exp+)
Rating: Expert and up
Level Based Raid
PvP Ratings exist, because Level and Might are terrible predictors of combat effectiveness, especially at higher levels (Note 1). High PvP Rating equals high Level and high Raid Might, but the opposite is not true. There are Level 33 characters with no Gems, or few Gems (Note 2). There are Level 33 characters that only have totally random Gems from Lockbox. A poorly designed character, or one with few Gems, often has trouble with Incursion Portals, the current version’s first exposure to Monsters based on a character’s Level. A poorly designed character, or one with few Gems, will often have trouble with Elite Mobs in Combat Zones that drop Crafted Potion Recipes.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
Expectations
Personally what I was expecting from Venan, before Friday, was a Public Raid similar to Lockbolt in difficulty and Combat Encounters/ Loot Drops (CELR or waves). Lockbolt is the first Raid with three Phases. Bronze Finish 60 minutes, Silver Finish 45 minutes, and Gold Finish 30 minutes (or less). Gold based on Were Chef being 30 minutes and Bronze based on Incursion Portals being 60 minutes. Each Pirate CELR would drop Doubloons based on difficulty similar to each Incursion Portal CELR dropping Essence based on difficulty. Harder CELRs would drop more Doubloons. No Elite Mobs. But if included, the Elite Mobs would drop Doubloons and a Pirate Consumable. Pirate Consumables would sometimes drop, from any CELR, just like Mountain Lichen in Zuur. The Raid Reward Mail would include Valor, Hero Tokens and possibly bonus Doubloons, all scaled to the character’s Level, Raid Might or PvP MMR.
Quest Balancing
Before the Black Market, Max Tier Gear/ Gems were Tier 12 Gear/ Tier 4 Gems. War of Fellmarsh Raid seemed balanced for Tier 10 Gear with all Tier 3 Gems. Legacy of Blades Raid seems to be balanced for Tier 16 Gear with all Tier 6 Gems. Some of the problems are, higher Gems allow more variation from no Gems, Max Gear to best Gem Selection, Max Gear. Starting players are trained that attacking is all important since their defense is taken care of with Level Health Bar and Armor. Because of Gem Slots, and Quest silver coin, transitioning from Gear and Gems bought with silver coin to Gear and Gems bought with Valor is difficult. Increasing it seems BoH is trying to fit World of Warcraft into a smartphone, and find possible ways to monetize it, instead of using a marketing plan based around micro transactions, pledging (similar to kickstarter), transaction sets (similar to album buying on iTunes), casual gaming, free/ account based/ ad based/ subscription/ VIP subscription/ early access pay scales, or any of the other innovative smartphone payments spearheaded by Apple finally solving the micro transaction credit card problem with their Batch Submission Process (Apple assumes contractual monetary risk by not immediately validating all transactions, including risky ones, but saves fees by validating 20- 40 transactions in one batch).
Note 1)
PvP, Rating, Matching, Leagues (R= Exp+)
Note 2)
Yesterday I ran Justicar Bj_DWR (Clankette) in a Pirate Invasion. Energy Bar 14, Level 9, No Gems, Tier 6 2h Axe, Tier 3 Chest, Tier 1 Legs, Tier 2 Helm, Tier 3 Boots, Tier 1 Gauntlets. She leveled twice in the Pirate Invasion, once with a full Energy Bar losing 12 Energy, once with an empty Energy Bar, gaining 14 Energy, but I had to watch it for 30 minutes. She might have leveled a third time, but CJ needed my help for 75 minutes.
Raid lasted 5 hours, Clankette, thanks to 14 Energy from leveling from 10 to 11, earned 7,350 RPP since she died twice and went to Glenfort Temple repeatedly to buy Cleanse and Healing Potions.
Justicar Clankette died twice versus Captain Blackthorn, once with CJ and once with me. CJ (a Justicar expert) ran a full Energy Bar (14) in addition to the two full Energy Bars I ran. Clankette also ran through 8- 12k silver coin in Cleanse and Healing Potions. Justicar Clankette has Stunning Blow rank 1 with a 7.0s cool down, which got used 2- 3 times per Captain Blackthorn. At one point, Clankette was regenerating Energy faster than she could use it. 1 out of 10 Captain Blackthorns, he would roll bad, and she would finish him before her Stunning Blow cooled down. But 3 out of 10 Captain Blackthorns, she would use tons of Potions.
In the same Pirate Invasion sundancer_T was a Level 15 War Mage with a Tier 4 2h Staff. sundancer_T tried for at least 45 minutes, and was never able to kill Captain Blackthorn, but continued to die over and over and over.
Participants who helped us get to Phase 3 and Captain Blackthron:
FireGoddess
Just_Me
KJ_Big_Poppa
Nutty_Nora
BG_Draven72
Perry19
Lucky_Slevin
Perry19
Bj_DWR
pcurry
ori33
Marvellem
milkyz3211
Danio
Band_of_Jazz
Myth_2014
Ecri
userb863576f
Alice_theProton_Tesla
Jink_Junk_The_Janitor
Arcfire
Arcfire
Bhorr
Spendal_BoL
Lyonie
Wolfszahn
Inquisitor
sundancer_T (many, many thanks)
user76cba0f1
gnarrzlul
RR_Earnest
Lost_Kindred
Planets
pioupioute
rasilen
user79df34c8
vavni777
user4a6d2c9e
Kaizoku_OfThe_Galaxy
wutang187
Dreaming of Pirates (R= Exp+)
Rating: Expert and up
Level Based Raid
PvP Ratings exist, because Level and Might are terrible predictors of combat effectiveness, especially at higher levels (Note 1). High PvP Rating equals high Level and high Raid Might, but the opposite is not true. There are Level 33 characters with no Gems, or few Gems (Note 2). There are Level 33 characters that only have totally random Gems from Lockbox. A poorly designed character, or one with few Gems, often has trouble with Incursion Portals, the current version’s first exposure to Monsters based on a character’s Level. A poorly designed character, or one with few Gems, will often have trouble with Elite Mobs in Combat Zones that drop Crafted Potion Recipes.
MY PERSONAL OPINION
Expectations
Personally what I was expecting from Venan, before Friday, was a Public Raid similar to Lockbolt in difficulty and Combat Encounters/ Loot Drops (CELR or waves). Lockbolt is the first Raid with three Phases. Bronze Finish 60 minutes, Silver Finish 45 minutes, and Gold Finish 30 minutes (or less). Gold based on Were Chef being 30 minutes and Bronze based on Incursion Portals being 60 minutes. Each Pirate CELR would drop Doubloons based on difficulty similar to each Incursion Portal CELR dropping Essence based on difficulty. Harder CELRs would drop more Doubloons. No Elite Mobs. But if included, the Elite Mobs would drop Doubloons and a Pirate Consumable. Pirate Consumables would sometimes drop, from any CELR, just like Mountain Lichen in Zuur. The Raid Reward Mail would include Valor, Hero Tokens and possibly bonus Doubloons, all scaled to the character’s Level, Raid Might or PvP MMR.
Quest Balancing
Before the Black Market, Max Tier Gear/ Gems were Tier 12 Gear/ Tier 4 Gems. War of Fellmarsh Raid seemed balanced for Tier 10 Gear with all Tier 3 Gems. Legacy of Blades Raid seems to be balanced for Tier 16 Gear with all Tier 6 Gems. Some of the problems are, higher Gems allow more variation from no Gems, Max Gear to best Gem Selection, Max Gear. Starting players are trained that attacking is all important since their defense is taken care of with Level Health Bar and Armor. Because of Gem Slots, and Quest silver coin, transitioning from Gear and Gems bought with silver coin to Gear and Gems bought with Valor is difficult. Increasing it seems BoH is trying to fit World of Warcraft into a smartphone, and find possible ways to monetize it, instead of using a marketing plan based around micro transactions, pledging (similar to kickstarter), transaction sets (similar to album buying on iTunes), casual gaming, free/ account based/ ad based/ subscription/ VIP subscription/ early access pay scales, or any of the other innovative smartphone payments spearheaded by Apple finally solving the micro transaction credit card problem with their Batch Submission Process (Apple assumes contractual monetary risk by not immediately validating all transactions, including risky ones, but saves fees by validating 20- 40 transactions in one batch).
Note 1)
PvP, Rating, Matching, Leagues (R= Exp+)
Note 2)
Yesterday I ran Justicar Bj_DWR (Clankette) in a Pirate Invasion. Energy Bar 14, Level 9, No Gems, Tier 6 2h Axe, Tier 3 Chest, Tier 1 Legs, Tier 2 Helm, Tier 3 Boots, Tier 1 Gauntlets. She leveled twice in the Pirate Invasion, once with a full Energy Bar losing 12 Energy, once with an empty Energy Bar, gaining 14 Energy, but I had to watch it for 30 minutes. She might have leveled a third time, but CJ needed my help for 75 minutes.
Raid lasted 5 hours, Clankette, thanks to 14 Energy from leveling from 10 to 11, earned 7,350 RPP since she died twice and went to Glenfort Temple repeatedly to buy Cleanse and Healing Potions.
Justicar Clankette died twice versus Captain Blackthorn, once with CJ and once with me. CJ (a Justicar expert) ran a full Energy Bar (14) in addition to the two full Energy Bars I ran. Clankette also ran through 8- 12k silver coin in Cleanse and Healing Potions. Justicar Clankette has Stunning Blow rank 1 with a 7.0s cool down, which got used 2- 3 times per Captain Blackthorn. At one point, Clankette was regenerating Energy faster than she could use it. 1 out of 10 Captain Blackthorns, he would roll bad, and she would finish him before her Stunning Blow cooled down. But 3 out of 10 Captain Blackthorns, she would use tons of Potions.
In the same Pirate Invasion sundancer_T was a Level 15 War Mage with a Tier 4 2h Staff. sundancer_T tried for at least 45 minutes, and was never able to kill Captain Blackthorn, but continued to die over and over and over.
Participants who helped us get to Phase 3 and Captain Blackthron:
FireGoddess
Just_Me
KJ_Big_Poppa
Nutty_Nora
BG_Draven72
Perry19
Lucky_Slevin
Perry19
Bj_DWR
pcurry
ori33
Marvellem
milkyz3211
Danio
Band_of_Jazz
Myth_2014
Ecri
userb863576f
Alice_theProton_Tesla
Jink_Junk_The_Janitor
Arcfire
Arcfire
Bhorr
Spendal_BoL
Lyonie
Wolfszahn
Inquisitor
sundancer_T (many, many thanks)
user76cba0f1
gnarrzlul
RR_Earnest
Lost_Kindred
Planets
pioupioute
rasilen
user79df34c8
vavni777
user4a6d2c9e
Kaizoku_OfThe_Galaxy
wutang187