Generally agree, though I'd say you'd have to have been playing for at least a few months to really understand everything that goes on in BoH enough to feed back properly. For example, I've seen people complaining about enchanting, that enchanting is rubbish and needs to be changed, without having a single enchantment on the gear they were wearing (back in the single-spec pre-PvP days).
Agree with Derrin and Ilyana. Lots of good changes made in a hurry, which has made the event entertaining.
I also agree with the point that even a very small group of ordinary players asked for an opinion in confidence would have advised against the original form of the event.
Most of all, I want to say THANK YOU for tweaking the pirates event to be enjoyable!!