All one-handed weapons will be of the 1.0s variety; the slower, higher-damage 1.1s type is to be eliminated entirely for mages. One-handed weapons will instead be split across tiers by element: they will consist of Ice or Fire wands, which do the appropriate type of elemental damage on regular attack.
Two-handed weapons will also be split across tiers by element: they will consist of Spirit or Nature staves, which do the appropriate type of elemental damage on regular attack.
Spell damage is still based on numerical weapon damage as before; the element of the weapon has no effect on spell damage or other functionality.
Regular attack for mages will now be affected by the Magic stat, not Melee. Spirit and Nature damage from regular attacks by two-handed weapons will also be affected by Magic.
The Melee stat for mages will instead be called Intensity (I know the name doesn't exactly work, but I can't think of anything else at the moment; feel free to offer suggestions). It will increase the chances of a secondary status effect, in addition to regular damage, being inflicted on a single target upon a regular attack. Intensity is capped at 50%, with the same diminishing returns curve as the Haste stat. Intensity is added directly to any innate chance the mage's weapon may have to inflict the appropriate status effect: either Burn, Slow, or Poison, or the dispelling of one buff, as in level 1/3 of the Justicar's Radiant Light.
One-handed weapons will have an innate chance between 0 and 30% to inflict secondary effects; two-handed weapons will have an innate chance between 10 and 40% to inflict secondary effects. This percentage will be determined by the weapon's tier.
In addition to hero training, the Intensity stat will be increased by red gems; any Melee gems in possession of, or subsequently received by, a mage are automatically converted to Intensity gems.
Offhand equipment for mages will consist of talismans, a new equipment type which does no damage and confers no armor. Instead, talismans will autocast a spell before the waiting period in a new combat begins. This spell must be known to the mage, or the talisman cannot be equipped, and talismans autocast spells at the mage's skill level.
All talismans are graded 1, 2, or 3. If the mage's skill level is higher than the talisman's grade, it autocasts the spell at its own, lower, level, not the mage's, and the mage's higher skill is wasted.
The first type of talisman autocasts Arcane Barrier. The second type autocasts Inner Focus. The third type autocasts either Fire Fracture or Ice Fracture (there will be two different types of talismans per grade).
Why: this will serve to reduce the mage's setup time, which is still a problem in comparison to the other two classes, which can both begin affecting enemies at maximum effectiveness at least one step sooner than a mage. Autocast spells will also reduce the number of taps required per battle, which will make the pace of combat more comparable to that of the other two classes.
Balancing: Melee is at present an utterly useless stat for mages. While 'walkers and justicars both have good reasons to increase their Magic stats, no mage has any reason to ever increase Melee (apart from the possible minor detail of meeting Might thresholds for raids). They thus have one less stat that they can use to appreciably improve their characters' combat effectiveness. On one hand, this could be seen as an advantage, in that mages don't have to expend as many resources in the form of hero tokens and gem slots to remain on as equal a footing as is possible with the other two classes; however, at high levels this rationale breaks down, as available resources grow, and the Melee stat is left unused, because it isn't the basis of even one skill - and it shouldn't be.
Appearance: a robe-clad mage carrying a sword and shield looks rather silly. :) Imagine instead that same mage carrying a smoking wand tipped with a suspended fragment of lava from the Dragonmoor volcano in one hand, and a tooth of Vallus in a wrought electrum cage in the other. Things like the Aurous staff, and the staves tipped with a crescent moon (Moonsplint, Ballast of the Heavens), already imply Spirit magic, and it isn't a stretch to imagine that the Bogmaster's Staff, the Staff of the Undead, and the Staff of the Cobra King might inflict Nature damage. An Arcane Barrier talisman might look like a totem, or simply a bright glow around the mage's hand; an Inner Focus talisman might be a crystal ball, or an old book; a Fire Fracture talisman might be a burning censer.
In summary...
Two-handed weapon (staff), pros:
Higher damage
Flexibility in type of damage inflicted by regular attack, and access to secondary effects not usually available to a mage
Costs 155,000 silver less to open all slots
Fewer upgrades necessary
Two-handed weapon (staff), cons:
Slower casting speed
Spirit or Nature damage of regular attack not affected by Fractures
One-handed weapon (wand) and talisman, pros:
Faster casting speed
Autocast spell saves 0.5s to 0.25s per battle
Damage of regular attack increased by Fractures
One-handed weapon (wand) and talisman, cons:
Lower damage
Costs 155,000 silver more to open all slots
Must upgrade talisman as well as wand
Two-handed weapons will also be split across tiers by element: they will consist of Spirit or Nature staves, which do the appropriate type of elemental damage on regular attack.
Spell damage is still based on numerical weapon damage as before; the element of the weapon has no effect on spell damage or other functionality.
Regular attack for mages will now be affected by the Magic stat, not Melee. Spirit and Nature damage from regular attacks by two-handed weapons will also be affected by Magic.
The Melee stat for mages will instead be called Intensity (I know the name doesn't exactly work, but I can't think of anything else at the moment; feel free to offer suggestions). It will increase the chances of a secondary status effect, in addition to regular damage, being inflicted on a single target upon a regular attack. Intensity is capped at 50%, with the same diminishing returns curve as the Haste stat. Intensity is added directly to any innate chance the mage's weapon may have to inflict the appropriate status effect: either Burn, Slow, or Poison, or the dispelling of one buff, as in level 1/3 of the Justicar's Radiant Light.
One-handed weapons will have an innate chance between 0 and 30% to inflict secondary effects; two-handed weapons will have an innate chance between 10 and 40% to inflict secondary effects. This percentage will be determined by the weapon's tier.
In addition to hero training, the Intensity stat will be increased by red gems; any Melee gems in possession of, or subsequently received by, a mage are automatically converted to Intensity gems.
Offhand equipment for mages will consist of talismans, a new equipment type which does no damage and confers no armor. Instead, talismans will autocast a spell before the waiting period in a new combat begins. This spell must be known to the mage, or the talisman cannot be equipped, and talismans autocast spells at the mage's skill level.
All talismans are graded 1, 2, or 3. If the mage's skill level is higher than the talisman's grade, it autocasts the spell at its own, lower, level, not the mage's, and the mage's higher skill is wasted.
The first type of talisman autocasts Arcane Barrier. The second type autocasts Inner Focus. The third type autocasts either Fire Fracture or Ice Fracture (there will be two different types of talismans per grade).
Why: this will serve to reduce the mage's setup time, which is still a problem in comparison to the other two classes, which can both begin affecting enemies at maximum effectiveness at least one step sooner than a mage. Autocast spells will also reduce the number of taps required per battle, which will make the pace of combat more comparable to that of the other two classes.
Balancing: Melee is at present an utterly useless stat for mages. While 'walkers and justicars both have good reasons to increase their Magic stats, no mage has any reason to ever increase Melee (apart from the possible minor detail of meeting Might thresholds for raids). They thus have one less stat that they can use to appreciably improve their characters' combat effectiveness. On one hand, this could be seen as an advantage, in that mages don't have to expend as many resources in the form of hero tokens and gem slots to remain on as equal a footing as is possible with the other two classes; however, at high levels this rationale breaks down, as available resources grow, and the Melee stat is left unused, because it isn't the basis of even one skill - and it shouldn't be.
Appearance: a robe-clad mage carrying a sword and shield looks rather silly. :) Imagine instead that same mage carrying a smoking wand tipped with a suspended fragment of lava from the Dragonmoor volcano in one hand, and a tooth of Vallus in a wrought electrum cage in the other. Things like the Aurous staff, and the staves tipped with a crescent moon (Moonsplint, Ballast of the Heavens), already imply Spirit magic, and it isn't a stretch to imagine that the Bogmaster's Staff, the Staff of the Undead, and the Staff of the Cobra King might inflict Nature damage. An Arcane Barrier talisman might look like a totem, or simply a bright glow around the mage's hand; an Inner Focus talisman might be a crystal ball, or an old book; a Fire Fracture talisman might be a burning censer.
In summary...
Two-handed weapon (staff), pros:
Higher damage
Flexibility in type of damage inflicted by regular attack, and access to secondary effects not usually available to a mage
Costs 155,000 silver less to open all slots
Fewer upgrades necessary
Two-handed weapon (staff), cons:
Slower casting speed
Spirit or Nature damage of regular attack not affected by Fractures
One-handed weapon (wand) and talisman, pros:
Faster casting speed
Autocast spell saves 0.5s to 0.25s per battle
Damage of regular attack increased by Fractures
One-handed weapon (wand) and talisman, cons:
Lower damage
Costs 155,000 silver more to open all slots
Must upgrade talisman as well as wand