Book of Heroes

ability to ban mercs

I realize we can password raids. However, we want to keep most of our raids open and it seems horribly inefficient to password raids to avoid a select few mercs bad behavior.

It would be nice if the gm could ban mercs from future mercing in a guild. Incidents happen that dont break venan rules but do break guild rules.

Sort of like a blacklist.

I feel this might be a great way to control those one hit wonder mercs who dont swing in raids.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Mon Oct 6, 2014 8:10 am
FitTrend wrote:I realize we can password raids. However, we want to keep most of our raids open and it seems horribly inefficient to password raids to avoid a select few mercs bad behavior.

It would be nice if the gm could ban mercs from future mercing in a guild. Incidents happen that dont break venan rules but do break guild rules.

Sort of like a blacklist.

I feel this might be a great way to control those one hit wonder mercs who dont swing in raids.
This idea has already been discussed and has its pros and cons. One of it's biggest cons is that it can easily be abused. I'm not sure if Venan will try it, but I wouldn't get my hopes up

Possessed_Mithrid

Mon Oct 6, 2014 10:38 am
Bimbosigliere wrote:Cue Ilyana

Not yet Bims...we have to set the trigger.... :D
ÅpëxThêPérmâñêñtlÿSîlêñçêd wrote:...... One of it's biggest cons is that it can easily be abused. .....

Seriously....I think peoples definition of abuse now a days is weak at best. Telling certain individuals they aren't allowed into your club is not abuse. It already happens in guilds, they kick people all the time they don't like or want. Extending that ability to a guilds raid is NOT abuse.

Just because someone does't like you isn't merit for the word "abuse". Unless you consider it abuse that Guilds only allow people they like into their guild, you, by extension of the concept, can not call it abuse if they only allow people they like into their raids.

If you believe that a raid blacklist would cause abuse, then you have to admit that the current guild system of allowing guilds to boot members or only allow members they want is abuse already. Apart from a few outliers who have weak cases at best, I don't see the later being true so there is no evidence that arguments in favor of the former has merit.

Ok Bims...that should do it. ;)

PS: I should add, this isn't just bait...I think the idea that a blacklist would be abusive is preposterous. We are not talking about people being booted mid-raid and having their effort stolen form them. Which was always the concern of allowing guilds to boot mercs who were not performing. We are talking about merely not allowing toons to join a raid in a similar manner in which we don't allow toons to join a raid by use of a password or closed raid all together.

Zombie_Princess_Kenny

Mon Oct 6, 2014 1:51 pm
Mithrid wrote:
Bimbosigliere wrote:Cue Ilyana

Not yet Bims...we have to set the trigger.... :D
ÅpëxThêPérmâñêñtlÿSîlêñçêd wrote:...... One of it's biggest cons is that it can easily be abused. .....

Seriously....I think peoples definition of abuse now a days is weak at best. Telling certain individuals they aren't allowed into your club is not abuse. It already happens in guilds, they kick people all the time they don't like or want. Extending that ability to a guilds raid is NOT abuse.

Just because someone does't like you isn't merit for the word "abuse". Unless you consider it abuse that Guilds only allow people they like into their guild, you, by extension of the concept, can not call it abuse if they only allow people they like into their raids.

If you believe that a raid blacklist would cause abuse, then you have to admit that the current guild system of allowing guilds to boot members or only allow members they want is abuse already. Apart from a few outliers who have weak cases at best, I don't see the later being true so there is no evidence that arguments in favor of the former has merit.

Ok Bims...that should do it. ;)

PS: I should add, this isn't just bait...I think the idea that a blacklist would be abusive is preposterous. We are not talking about people being booted mid-raid and having their effort stolen form them. Which was always the concern of allowing guilds to boot mercs who were not performing. We are talking about merely not allowing toons to join a raid in a similar manner in which we don't allow toons to join a raid by use of a password or closed raid all together.
I'm still wondering why a blacklist is needed when we have the ability to set a password.
ÅpëxThêPérmâñêñtlÿSîlêñçêd wrote:
I'm still wondering why a blacklist is needed when we have the ability to set a password.

1. People share passwords.
2. Often you want the raid open to all comers except one or two people.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorMon Oct 6, 2014 2:19 pm
The pros and cons have already been discussed and I'm sure Venan has taken note of all our opinions.

Cletus

ModeratorMon Oct 6, 2014 2:45 pm
This topic has been discussed to the end of time... locking this thread and merging if I can figure out how... :?