LoB Phase 2, 3 and 4 are easily better (much fun) than anything in the new raids. The first GV raid is yet another reskinned VG/HM raid.
I was looking forward to some new onslaught not just more vanilla raids.
Button pushing for non-onslaught? Really? Try avoiding getting hit for as long as you can in a raid. That requires skill. That's the challenge.
I must say I'm very surprised at no onslaught...there's been a lot of feedback saying 'separate into OS and non-OS' for a long time now.
Iolo_Ultima wrote:Button pushing for non-onslaught? Really? Try avoiding getting hit for as long as you can in a raid. That requires skill. That's the challenge.
At lower mights, maybe it probably is a challenge, but a 50k mage doesn't take any skill on the new raids. Heard the same about Justies. According to Eric, p2 of PM for SW requires a little skill to not die.
Regardless of might, LoB p4 is still a challenge.
Bbbb wrote:According to Eric, p2 of PM for SW requires a little skill to not die
I can do it. Therefore obvious skill or a decent sw not needed[/quote]
The SW skill for P2 isn't for straight up fighting, he is talking about quicker fighting with low HP for Death Wish - that is a small challenge compared to most other things in game so far.
I agree with thread however, the non-OS will get old quickly - these will turn into very long raids
On one hand, no onslaught was surprising and like many have said, this seems to be a mode where players get the chance to tweak builds and rotations and show skill in PvE.
However, I'm also quite happy that the new raids don't have onslaught because onslaught seemed to be the only viable way to farm for essences. The new raids seem to offer much better drops for just 2e a pop (e.g. 3-4 PE in a kill if lucky). I like such rates and makes farming feel faster. I suppose if onslaught were to apply, the drop rates and tables would have to be modified downwards and then we would have to grind onslaught non-stop.
Also, without onslaught, the penalty for using PvP gear in PvE is a lot less harsh. Yes, I would kill slower in real time, and perhaps eat a couple more health pots, but in terms of energy efficiency I don't get short changed. So the PvP-side of me is glad there's no onslaught for Guardian Valor.
Iolo_Ultima wrote:Button pushing for non-onslaught? Really? Try avoiding getting hit for as long as you can in a raid. That requires skill. That's the challenge.
At high might, you one hit everything. An onslaught version of PMS p2 would have been a lot of fun. Also- why does every "hard" raid need a lame mob phase? P1 of pms and arguably p3 as well we're a little too easy. For a 36k+ might raid, I was really hoping for a brutal p2-like raid the whole way through.
Though CV really does feel like a reskinned HM.
EricM wrote:Iolo_Ultima wrote:Button pushing for non-onslaught? Really? Try avoiding getting hit for as long as you can in a raid. That requires skill. That's the challenge.
At high might, you one hit everything. An onslaught version of PMS p2 would have been a lot of fun. Also- why does every "hard" raid need a lame mob phase? P1 of pms and arguably p3 as well we're a little too easy. For a 36k+ might raid, I was really hoping for a brutal p2-like raid the whole way through.
Though CV really does feel like a reskinned HM.
It is a reskinned HM ;D just like HM is a reskinned VG.
I think most people expected a non-OS raid like HM and a OS raid. To see no onslaught at all was surprising. Even more surprising is the payout differences I've heard about in the two raids. Given the huge gear costs (go and look at T14, T16 and T18 alongside each other) this just feels like a way to drag things out.
Definitely suprised that there is no new os (LOB is about to be 1 yr old). And since I would characterize the new raid drop rates as standard vice better, the farming grind has not gotten better despite increased enchanting of gear.
