iOptioniousPrime wrote:
I've described how easily a Justi can drop a sequence for a Mage to be unable to strike for 8 direct hits. Justi's have nearly 6 stuns that a Mage needs to channel through during a fight, with a Mage trying to wait for a stun due to CD from the get go. Otherwise we have a 6 second interrupt that doesn't do much with seismic at the helm of the next strike. If the interrupt would establish a Cool Down for the blocked cast then maybe we'd be getting somewhere. Mages are sitting ducks vs Justi's. That's not a PvP match, in my opinion, but a hope for a resist or spell dodge.
I'm getting the feeling that you're talking purely about mage vs. justi here. I think part of the issue is that, like i said earlier, that without higher level enchants and gems, the innate class advantages (SW > Justi > WM > SW) become very apparent. It isn't much consolation, but at high might, it does all even out.
SW > Justi. My SW runs 57% dodge, 12% block, 36% status resist. Obviously this is a bit higher than your average player, but vs. a high might justi, where I'm always defending against seismic, it will rarely hit (57% dodge + 12% block + 20% block defend + 10% dodge defend = 1% chance of hitting on defend, 31% chance of hitting when not defending). Likewise with brutal. And then Stun is subject to stat resist. So its very unlikely that a justi actually manages to get off a brutal + seismic and they both land (Purao is about the only one who manages it semi-consistently). That said, when seismic or brutal do land, they do hurt quite a bit. But it feels to me like melee SW's are innately strong vs. melee justicars.
Justi > Warmage. Obviously, through a combo of juggernaught and resists, the justi completely dominates the first half of the match when played correctly. But at higher mights, health ends up getting high enough that the juggs do run out, and with a well played second half, a warmage can quickly make up the difference. I've seen quite a few replays of some of our warmages taking a beating from some of the top justis in the first half, but due to 36-40k health, the juggernaughts run out somewhere in the middle of that, allows warmages (with their high damage output) to quickly catch back up (provided their dodges, resists are high enough to not get caught by the seismic-brutal combos). But for these and the reasons you stated above, Justis seem to have the innate advantage here.
Warmage > Shadow Walker. Arcane Shield + Ice Spike Armor turn into a blood bath against shadow walkers. I average ~20 damaging attacks in a typical fight vs. a warmage... which is 10k+ damage right there reflected back at me when facing the top warmages (I have 36k hp, so i'm effectively facing wms with only 26k hp that i can lose). I've had matches where I've resisted every stun, every status, and spell dodged every attack and still lost due to sheer damage output by warmages (even running 70% magic damage mitigation). <<That match was actually pretty fascinating to watch. So warmages innately have an advantage in those fights.
So point of this long explanation was that, it's not that justi's are overpowered by any means. BOH PVP just has this weird rock-paper-scissors thing going on, and unfortunately, wins are a lot more class mismatch dependent at lower might. There is a definite problem though with low might pvp. My 20k wm (which i stacked for full damage) has routinely done 25-30k damage vs. toons in the lower leagues with less defenses. I definitely understand where the "wm op" and "justi op" comments are coming from, its just that I also think that much like other games of it's kind, pvp should definitely be balanced for the higher leagues, and hopefully relatively balanced for all leagues (which is much more difficult).
tl;dr -> all three classes have their strengths and weaknesses lol.