For this thread, let's put aside the pro-onslaught argument (which I fully support) and talk about the flaws and easy fixes to PM that Venan could make quickly.
The flaws:
1. P2 is long and tedious. It's not very fun and it is just a chore to get to P3. Please note I am NOT complaining about the difficulty.
2. The rewards for P2 do not match the amount of work. Very much like the bear was originally in HM.
3. P3 is too short.
4. Due to these factors, the leech merc factor is the worst of any raid. People join and do not hit P2.
Possible solutions (not mutually exclusive):
1. Move waves from P2 to P3.
2. Up the rewards for P2 so that it is worth people's effort to hit it instead of leech.
3. If you won't up the rewards or lower the waves in P2, then make each battle quicker. Note: personally, I'd prefer the other solutions.
Final note: this post is based on discussions with members of The Kingdom, EricM and others in game.
The flaws:
1. P2 is long and tedious. It's not very fun and it is just a chore to get to P3. Please note I am NOT complaining about the difficulty.
2. The rewards for P2 do not match the amount of work. Very much like the bear was originally in HM.
3. P3 is too short.
4. Due to these factors, the leech merc factor is the worst of any raid. People join and do not hit P2.
Possible solutions (not mutually exclusive):
1. Move waves from P2 to P3.
2. Up the rewards for P2 so that it is worth people's effort to hit it instead of leech.
3. If you won't up the rewards or lower the waves in P2, then make each battle quicker. Note: personally, I'd prefer the other solutions.
Final note: this post is based on discussions with members of The Kingdom, EricM and others in game.