Book of Heroes

Please make PM P2 attractive

Can you please put some sort of drop in PM P2 that makes it worth while to everyone? At this point, it's tedious with very little relative reward. And with impure shadow waiting in the relatively easy p3, p2 is just begging to be squatted on.

Nightcrawler

Famous_Fella_O_Nutella

Mon Nov 3, 2014 10:02 am
There are so many squatters just hanging out in P2 that don't contribute. No more squatters! We struggle to get through P2 and then P3 takes ten minutes.

BP_got_smashed_on_3_toons_by_

Mon Nov 3, 2014 10:45 am
You could always do it closed!!! If its members squatting kick them :)
PM P2 is terrible. For the reward/effort ratio it is the worst single phase of any essence granting phase in the game. CV P3 and LOB P4 have a similar essence payout for a lot less effort (not arguing for those to be nerfed). The squatter/leech problem is out of hand. I'm been privy to many discussions where it was decided to take silver over risking more leeches in to steal the P3 bounty.

I had an earlier thread. The solution is some combination of:

1. Increase P2 essence/flux payout. Possibly silver too give the immense amount of health pots required.
2. Reduce P2 difficulty.
3. Shorten the phase.
4. Blacklist (we've beaten the pros/cons of this to death - let's don't go down that road again please)
5. Merc acceptance system - similar to the way you can turn off recruiting and have to let people in, do the same with mercs.

Once I get my gear/gems, I am giving serious thought that I want LoB to be my primary raid.

Finally, note to Venan dev, my experience is that the raid times for barely gold usually breaks down:

P1 - 25 minutes
P2 - 45 minutes
P3 - 15 minutes

So over half the raid in spent in a phase that I've yet to hear anybody say they enjoy or that it is worth doing for any reason beyond that it has to be done to get to P3.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorTue Nov 4, 2014 5:11 pm
Bbbb wrote:PM P2 is terrible. For the reward/effort ratio it is the worst single phase of any essence granting phase in the game. CV P3 and LOB P4 have a similar essence payout for a lot less effort (not arguing for those to be nerfed). The squatter/leech problem is out of hand. I'm been privy to many discussions where it was decided to take silver over risking more leeches in to steal the P3 bounty.

I had an earlier thread. The solution is some combination of:

1. Increase P2 essence/flux payout. Possibly silver too give the immense amount of health pots required.
2. Reduce P2 difficulty.
3. Shorten the phase.
4. Blacklist (we've beaten the pros/cons of this to death - let's don't go down that road again please)
5. Merc acceptance system - similar to the way you can turn off recruiting and have to let people in, do the same with mercs.

Once I get my gear/gems, I am giving serious thought that I want LoB to be my primary raid.

Finally, note to Venan dev, my experience is that the raid times for barely gold usually breaks down:

P1 - 25 minutes
P2 - 45 minutes
P3 - 15 minutes

So over half the raid in spent in a phase that I've yet to hear anybody say they enjoy or that it is worth doing for any reason beyond that it has to be done to get to P3.

Agree. The worst part of it is, this raid is encouraging some particularly bad merc behaviour from people who were considered helpful previously. In some ways this is even worse than the skunking in OS raids. LoB was skunked regularly but not for the same reasons. PM is bringing out the worst in the community as nobody wants to hit P2 and everybody wants to hit P3.

The raid needs to be tweaked, plus maybe some (fair) guild powers so we can control raids a little more.
I love the challenge of p2. It's hard like it should be for the might of the raid. Now, that said, it does need something to make it attractive for everyone.

I suggest making p2 onslaught.

Leave it at the same length and difficulty.

It's my opinion that it would solve the issue for most.

japster

ModeratorWed Nov 5, 2014 1:59 am
Shekka wrote:I love the challenge of p2. It's hard like it should be for the might of the raid. Now, that said, it does need something to make it attractive for everyone.

I suggest making p2 onslaught.

Leave it at the same length and difficulty.

It's my opinion that it would solve the issue for most.

Turning it into OS while not changing the loot tables? No…it'll only get worse because of the carrying-over of negative status effects. Only the most elite players would hit it while everyone else who barely makes the might requirements will avoid it because they'll spend way too much resources in OS than they can earn back.

IMO the best solution is to improve P2 loot tables. Reducing the difficulty doesn't feel right since this is an end-game raid and I enjoy the challenge of the monster difficulty.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Nov 5, 2014 6:54 am
japster wrote:
Shekka wrote:I love the challenge of p2. It's hard like it should be for the might of the raid. Now, that said, it does need something to make it attractive for everyone.

I suggest making p2 onslaught.

Leave it at the same length and difficulty.

It's my opinion that it would solve the issue for most.

Turning it into OS while not changing the loot tables? No…it'll only get worse because of the carrying-over of negative status effects. Only the most elite players would hit it while everyone else who barely makes the might requirements will avoid it because they'll spend way too much resources in OS than they can earn back.

IMO the best solution is to improve P2 loot tables. Reducing the difficulty doesn't feel right since this is an end-game raid and I enjoy the challenge of the monster difficulty.

I think the difficulty could be tweaked without making it unchallenging. P2 resists for example seem much higher than the bosses in LoB. But then it is a 36k raid.

From a 42k perspective, the difficulty swings wildly. P1 is mostly fine, like a lot of raids if you are at or just above the req it's harder than the raids you're used to. P2 is insanely hard and takes a large number of actions. Grenade can do plenty of damage to them, but spirit runes are a must and the silver lost in potions and runes is too much to make hitting this phase pay off.

P3...well I can mostly deal with him and two-hit on DW. He seems very easy for a boss...considering the general difficulty is fairly consistent in LoB, and ramps up considerably in P3 of HiM.

If the difficulty is left as-is, I think the drops need to be upped in P2 and some of the waves moved to P3 (or one of the above). I don't get the logic of a raid that goes P1 average speed P2 sloooow P3 mega fast.
japster wrote:it'll only get worse because of the carrying-over of negative status effects.

Mages will be okay because all the positive status effects. Justies and Poison SW to a lesser extant. Melee SWs though would suffer but I'm totally okay with that. :lol: :lol: :lol: