Thankful_Watson wrote:I have a favor to ask. I like a good joke as well as the next guy, but I wish people would use greater discretion in choosing user names at this festive season.
Christmas for many, including me, is a holy day. For others, certainly in most western nations, Christmas is at least a holiday, one that focuses on children. Certainly Santa is a child's hero, a very commendable hero who is a good listener and is generous, giving, and kind.
With that, I'm amazed at some of the user names people are choosing to sexualize this children's holiday, in a game where teenagers and younger children play. Please remember that your name shows up on leaderboards even if you never come into global chat. I'm not asking people to be glum and serious. Christmas isn't supposed to be that kind of holiday. But I'm asking us to show a little more restraint and a little more respect.
WARNING! Long post!
Hm. Gonna have to be the odd one out here. I disagree, Derrin. Sorry and all that, but you're coming from a position I just don't agree with.
1/ Santa as a commendable hero. Nope. He's an all-seeing, all-knowing supernatural entity who watches and judges constantly, bringing reward or punishment based on unquantifiable standards. I have had to tell my own son at the age of 4 that Santa isn't real, because he was terrified by the stories about Santa in school. "Santa's watching and I don't know if I've been good enough" was what I eventually got after multiple nightmares.
Maybe the concept of Santa is more acceptable to those of a religious leaning, where such an idea maps very closely to that of (insert deity name of choice), but as this becomes less common, Santa as an allegory is becoming less of a figure of good standing and more one of dread. I've spoken to many other parents with similar experiences to mine, so it's not a unique position.
2/ Christmas sexualisation in general - this has been going on for a long time, and is nothing new. Some of the best-selling fancy dress costumes are, and have been for many decades, the "Sexy Mrs Claus", "Hunky Santa" and "Naughty Elf" genre. Jokes and songs sexualising Xmas traditions (which I won't repeat here) that were going round when I was a child are still popular now. In the 21st century, walking down any city centre street or turning on a tv - even to Nickelodeon - sees sexualisation. And why not? It's one of the most powerful human urges. It's started and ended wars, it's driven humanity forward more than anything than perhaps greed. It's there, it isn't going away, and, dammit, it's one of the most wonderful things in this life - so why on earth should it be hidden away and made an object of derision? I'm not advocating playing hardcore movies to kids, but they are exposed to the concept of sexuality from a very early age - everything from Tom & Jerry (remember Tom's reaction to an attractive female cat?) to billboards on the side of the road showing a guy in boxer shorts to try and sell aftershave. Trying to then make areas that are primarily used by adults "sexuality-neutral" are counterproductive and usually doomed to failure, as it goes against human nature.
3/ Kids play BoH? In all my time here, I've met a number of players under the age of 20 that I can count on my fingers. There really don't seem to be that many, at least not "in the wild". BoH is a land of contradictions in terms of being child-friendly.
On the one hand, saying "Man, I could do with an alcoholic beverage" in Global will get you a warning. On the other, the Vile Realm is stuffed with drunken brawlers and tavern wenches, who drink alcohol to buff their combat abilities, and the first location you meet in the game is a tavern.
On the one hand, any sort of explicit chat in Global will likewise be jumped on by mods (as is their responsibility - I'm not criticising mods here as I know that they operate under instruction!) - on the other hand we have, as in most fantasy games, many scantily-clad (not to mention impractically-clad!) and prominent female adversaries. Callisto and Shaly'n gain nothing from fighting in swimsuits, do they? It's just the very nature of this type of game to be sexualised to a degree.
4/ Showing restraint and respect - I would put forth that most players are doing exactly that. Someone changing their name to "JingleMyBells" or whatever is not generally going out of their way to offend and upset. This sort of play on words is intended to amuse and entertain. There are many round-the-year names and behaviours that I personally don't like, but I know that the intent isn't there to offend me, and that the reasoning is honest, so I'm certainly not feeling that I have any right - or reason - to ask them to stop.
Sure, there can be a fine line between amusing and deliberately offensive in some seasonal name cases - but they are very much the minority, and I put that, if necessary, they can be dealt with on a case-by-case basis as with any other offensive name. Asking everyone to stop playing around with saucy (as in British seaside postcard / Carry On film) or fun humour, in case it is seen by an 8yo playing a game where he chops monsters into pieces (including monsters falling out of bikinis) is, I would say - overkill.
I didn't intend this to be such an essay. Sorry...
TLDR: Disagree. If you see something actually offensive, tell a mod.