Book of Heroes

Abilities & Description needs to be reviewed

Definition of "hit" (from dictionary)
- To deal a blow or blows

That description implies that some damage must have occurred.
In Venan's context, there's a successful hit and an unsuccessful hit. An unsuccessful hit is when damage is incurred and is accompanied by either a SPELL DODGE or BLOCKED. A hit is when the target receives damage without SPELL DODGE or BLOCK, with or without CRITICAL.

=======================================================

My argument here is that there are some abilities that need to be looked into and maybe fixed.

URGENCY
Description : Grants a 10% chance after being hit to gain a +15% haste for 2.0s.
Currently, getting attacked by an attack like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade may trigger Urgency. However, Caltrops, Smoke Bomb and Sticky Grenade do not deal any damage damage immediately to its victim when being used as they deal no damage at all.
Suggestion : Urgency SHOULD NOT trigger when non damaging skills like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade are used.

Shadow Walker's SHADOW VEIL
Description : Hide your next attack and gain an extra 10%
Vile Goblin Expert Thief's STEALTH
Descriptio : The monster has slipped into the shadows. concealing the name and increasing the damage dealt by their next attack. Also significantly increases dodge chance.

Comparing these 2 abilities, they have both similar and different effects. The similarity is that both will conceal the name of the user's next attack and increase the damage dealt. What's different is that the goblin has increased its dodge rate and when you dodge the Goblin's attack when he's on stealth mode, it REMAINS in stealth mode. Whereas when the SW's opponent has dodged the SW's attack when they're in their shadow veil, the SW is loses the Shadow Veil buff. I have no issues with SW not having an increased dodge rate when they are on Shadow Veil since a veil is a piece of cloth and doesn't render the SW invisible like Stealth.
Suggestion : EITHER make the goblin lose its stealthiness when the player dodges its attack OR make the SW retain their Shadow Veil when their opponent dodges their attack. However, should the SW use debuff applying skills like Caltrops or Sticky Grenade, the SW loses the Shadow Veil buff.

VENGEANCE
Description : 20% chance after getting hit to gain Vengeance, increasing outgoing damage by 10%. Stacks up to 3.
Same as Urgency, getting attacked by an attack like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade may trigger Vengeance.
Suggestion : Vengeance SHOULD NOT trigger when non damaging skills like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade are used.

ICE SPIKE ARMOR
Description : Magically retaliate 10% of weapon damage as Ice damage
Currently, WMs with this passive will deal damage to any player or mob who use any ability on them regardless whether the ability deals any damage or not.
According to Beeko when I asked him about this in PvP chat when Season 2 just went live, it was intended to work as a Thorns effect but they couldn't make it to return a percent of damage received. However, looking at the monster, Saydon and its THORNS skill, THORNS return a percent of Saydon's max health as damage to the player who performs a successful hit. This effect applies a Frost Rune, Fire Rune, Blight Rune and Spirt Rune as well. However, THORNS does NOT return damage to any unsuccessful hit and abilities which does 0 damage. Such abilities are Time Void, Caltrops, Sticky Grenade, Smoke Bomb, Break Rune and Purge Rune. Saydon's THORNS work just fine, but definitely not Ice Spike Armor.
Suggestion : Since Ice Spike Armor was intended to work as THORNS, it should at least work as THORNS and not like its current form. There are games that have thorns ability that returns a percentage of damage taken and there are thorns ability that returns a fixed amount of damage to its attacker, i.e. Returns X amount of damage to attacker.

ARCANE SHIELD
After being hit, you get a 10% chance to gain an Arcane Shield that absorbs 75% of the next attack.
Currently, WMs with this passive will have a chance to gain an Arcane Shield when any player or mob use any ability on them regardless whether the ability deals any damage or not. As per the description, non damaging skills like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade are still considered as an attack, the shield is dispelled even though the attack does no damage.
Since the WM has to get hit to have a chance to gain an Arcane Shield, it SHOULD NOT trigger when non damaging skills like Caltrops, Smoke Bomb or Sticky Grenade are used.
How about DoT "hits"?

Ex: When burning / caltrops / bleed / poison cloud tick, does this cause ice spike / urgency to trigger, cause Arcane to drop etc?
DreamingDaemon wrote:How about DoT "hits"?

Ex: When burning / caltrops / bleed / poison cloud tick, does this cause ice spike / urgency to trigger, cause Arcane to drop etc?

DoT damages shouldn't cause passive skills to trigger as they do damage passively.

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Wed Dec 31, 2014 12:39 pm
DJ - Well written and I highly agree.

No damage attacks remove absorb shield but don't break stuns. There isn't consistency in pvp.

Me personally am above frustrated with PvP - Venan needs to speak on the subject. They have loyal customers that are feeling ignored.

When I first joined they were the best at communicating to their players which I really liked that. They made an error or a burp they gave potions. This silence on the subject is a problem for me.

They just updated it PvP but they didn't fix one issue.

Illy_the_Red

ModeratorWed Dec 31, 2014 1:59 pm
It's more complicated than that.

If Arcane Shield is altered so it doesn't drop when (for example) caltrops is thrown, then it also can't proc when caltrops is thrown. If that balance isn't struck then either the shield is very rarely up, or is up all the time. Neither is fair or balanced.

Urgency is different. It can't be debuffed, but if it only procced when actually being hit, it would rarely be seen. It has a low base proc rate as it is without removing half the situations that trigger it. Enough SW already see entire battles without getting one proc. If only genuine hits triggered Urgency, its base proc rate would need to be higher. The same would go for Vengeance, its base proc rate needs to be higher if you want to strip half the situations in which it appears.

Ice Spike definitely needs to change...it procs on every single action regardless of type. This gives a pretty high damage advantage across the course of a battle. It either needs a change in proc rate or a change to the types of actions that proc it.

It isn't a matter of 'just change it'. Most of these skills will affect balance in bigger ways than most players realise if changed to how some players want it (there is heavy class bias in any discussion around balance).

ELORatingBasedonRNG

Fri Jan 2, 2015 12:10 pm
Which I think there should be drastic changes made. The whole system needs to shift. RNG needs to be removed or ELO needs to be removed, if they keep it the same way. ELO a skill based rating system does not apply luck as a main factor, its one persons skill versus the other.

I agree with what your saying though in regards to changing one thing can change others - I agree. That's why the whole thing needs to be revamped.
DjCleric wrote:Definition of "hit" (from dictionary)
- To deal a blow or blows

Who says that blow have to be damaging? All the abilities you described can be considered as blows as all of them have some sort or effect they apply(slow, dot, interrupt...).

I think there are more important issues to look at, when it comes to PvP balance.
Some great bugs or * wrong* things goin there..very well spotted indeed.... That post is from last year and yet no Dev respond.... Once again it shows * who cares * correct me if I'm wrong but I've posted a few things tonight....I really wish u find something wrong on what I've said